Question

In: Physics

Baryons in quantum chromodynamics can be described as a bound state of three quarks. But they...

Baryons in quantum chromodynamics can be described as a bound state of three quarks. But they can also be described as a topological soliton of the pion field. How can both descriptions be equivalent?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The skyrmion description only appears in an effective, non-renormalizable theory where pions are treated as elementary particles. Using a more high-energy viewpoint, however, pions themselves are made out of quarks and gluons, and the short-distance QCD rescription using quarks and gluons is renormalizable and much more accurate.

However, the pion effective field theory is still marginally applicable at the scale of the proton, so it must inevitably have a description for that. It is not surprising that it must be topologically nontrivial because baryons carry new kinds of charges, the baryon charge, that would vanish in topologically trivial configurations of pion fields.

There is no contradiction - the bound state of quarks and gluons that make up the proton is not "any bound state". It has some specific properties and quantum numbers, and those inevitably mean that the best approximation in an effective pion theory has to be a skyrmion. So this is not a real duality.

There are very similar descriptions of baryons (among many other objects) that are full-fledged dualities. In AdS/CFT, the baryons are branes wrapped on an internal sphere:

http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9805112

In AdS/CFT, the quark-gluon composition of the baryons really becomes invisible in the bulk, so the branes as baryons can't be reduced to quarks and gluons in any direct way. The branes are wrapped, much like the skyrmions are wrapped around some place of the configuration space, but I don't think that there is a direct isomorphism between these two wrappings


Related Solutions

The quantum state of a particle can be specified by giving a complete set of quantum numbers (n, l, m_l, m_s).
The quantum state of a particle can be specified by giving a complete set of quantum numbers (n, l, m_l, m_s). How many different quantum states are possible if the principal quantum number is n = 4?  To find the total number of allowed states, first write down the allowed orbital quantum numbers l, and then write down the number of allowed values of m_1 for each orbital quantum number. Sum these quantities, and then multiply by 2 to account...
In elementary quantum mechanics, the square well is used to model the behavior of a bound...
In elementary quantum mechanics, the square well is used to model the behavior of a bound particle in which one or more forces (external potentials, interaction with other particles, etc) prevent or restrict its ability to move about. We have seen in class that the solutions to the Schrodinger equation in and around the quantum well result in a series of eigenvector wavefunctions with distinct energy levels. In this assignment, we will use MATLAB to create the system and experiment...
• state the purpose of quantum mechanics
• state the purpose of quantum mechanics
The ground state for a quantum Hall system on a torus with fractional filling factor can...
The ground state for a quantum Hall system on a torus with fractional filling factor can be classified by the Chern number, which is why the Hall conductance is quantized. Is there another method or classification one can use to distinguish states? A more clear version of this question: Different quantum Hall states can be characterized by their different Hall conductances. Is there other characterizations that one can use to distinguish different quantum Hall states? I propose to change the...
What theoretical explanations exist for the fact that there are three generations of leptons and quarks?...
What theoretical explanations exist for the fact that there are three generations of leptons and quarks? I'm not so much asking why there are exactly 3 generations, but rather what makes electron, muon and tau differ. Also, since the three families of quarks don't have to be a priori related to the three families of leptons, I'm interested in answers for either quarks, leptons, or both.
A quantum particle is described by a wavefunction Which of the following is the correct equation...
A quantum particle is described by a wavefunction Which of the following is the correct equation for normalization? QUESTION 4 Using the correct normalization equation from problem 3 to find the A value and use this value to replace A in the wavefunction: ψ=
<Quantum tunneling> State and derive transmission probability
<Quantum tunneling> State and derive transmission probability
Chemical reactions are often described using a three state model: Reactants→Transition State→ProductsReactants→Transition State→Products In most cases...
Chemical reactions are often described using a three state model: Reactants→Transition State→ProductsReactants→Transition State→Products In most cases the energy of the transition state is much higher than the energy of the reactant state. This means that the reaction cannot proceed until there is a random thermal fluctuation large enough to `kick' the reactant molecule(s) up to the transition state energy. Say we have a reaction in which the transition state is 9.0×10−20 J above the reactant state. a.) Calculate the ratio...
Find the all the bound state energies for the potential V = - Vo
Find the all the bound state energies for the potential V = - Vo
The deuteron is a bound state of a proton and a neutron of total angular momentum...
The deuteron is a bound state of a proton and a neutron of total angular momentum j = 1. It is known to be principally an S(ℓ = 0) state with a small admixture of a D(ℓ = 2) state. Calculate the magnetic moment of the pure d state n-p system with j = 1. Assume that the n and p spins are to be coupled to make the total spin s which is then coupled to the orbital angular...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT