Question

In: Physics

I know that string theory is still under heavy development, and as such it still can't...

I know that string theory is still under heavy development, and as such it still can't make predictions (or not that many predictions anyways).

On the other hand, it is clear from the number of years this theory has been under development and from the large number of theoretical physicists studying it, that it is considered a good and viable candidate as a quantum gravity theory.

So, what is the evidence that this is true? Why is it considered such a good candidate as the correct quantum gravity theory?

Without wanting to sound inflammatory in the least, it has been under heavy development for a very long time and it's still not able to make predictions, for example, or still makes outlandish statements (like extra dimensions) that would require a high amount of experimental evidence to be accepted. So - if so many people believe it is the way to go, there have to be good reasons, right? What are they?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Some random points in support of ST, with no attempt to be systematic or comprehensive. I will not get into a long discussion, if someone does not find this convincing I'd advice them not to work on the subject. I also don't have the time to elaborate or justify the claims below, just take them at face value, or maybe you can ask more specific follow up questions.

  1. ST incorporated naturally and effortlessly all of the mathematical structure underlying modern particle physics and gravity. It does so many times in surprising and highly non-trival ways, many times barely surviving difficult consistency checks. Certainly anyone with any familiarity with the subject has a strong feeling that you get out much more than you put in.

  2. ST quantizes gravity, and that form of quantization avoids all the difficulties that more traditional approaches encounter. This is also surprising: it was developed originally as theory of the strong interactions, and when people discovered it contains quantized gravity they spent years trying to get rid of it, with no success. As a theory of quantum gravity it passes many consistentcy checks, failure of any of them would invalidate the whole framework, for example in providing a microscopic description of a large class of black holes.

  3. ST extends the calculational tools available to us to investigate interesting physical systems, many times the only such calculational techniques available. Again, it does so in novel and unexpected ways. It therefore provides a natural language to extend quantum field theory, to models which include quantized gravity, and (relatedly) models with strong interactions. Many calculations using that language are simpler and more natural than other methods, it seems therefore to be the right language to discuss a large class of physical systems.

  4. ST contains in principle all the ingredients needed to construct a model for particle physics, though this has proven to be more difficult than originally thought. But, in view of the above, even if it turns out not to provide a model for beyond the standard model physics, it is certainly useful enough for many physicists to decide spending their time stuying it.

Of course other people may have their own reasons to find the subject interesting, I'm only speaking for myself


Related Solutions

I try to invent the examples, but I can't still. I do not understand how setvbuf...
I try to invent the examples, but I can't still. I do not understand how setvbuf can be useful, and also I don't understand with setbuf. please explain setvbuf vs setoff
I need to create a monthly loan Calculator in C++. I know the formula but can't...
I need to create a monthly loan Calculator in C++. I know the formula but can't figure out what's wrong with my code. Any clarification would be appreciated! // Only add code where indicated by the comments. // Do not modify any other code. #include <iostream> #include <cmath> using namespace std; int main() {    // ---------------- Add code here --------------------    // -- Declare necessary variables here              --        int years = 0; //n     int LoanAmount =...
I know that there's big controversy between two groups of physicists: those who support string theory...
I know that there's big controversy between two groups of physicists: those who support string theory (most of them, I think) and those who oppose it. One of the arguments of the second group is that there's no way to disprove the correctness of the string theory. So my question is if there's any defined experiment that would disprove string theory?
My Java program keeps "running." I know I need to close a "loop" but I can't...
My Java program keeps "running." I know I need to close a "loop" but I can't find it. I'm learning how to code. This is confusing for me. import java.util.Scanner; import java.util.ArrayList; public class SteppingStone4_Loops {    public static void main(String[] args) { Scanner scnr = new Scanner(System.in); String recipeName = ""; ArrayList<String> ingredientList = new ArrayList(); String newIngredient = ""; boolean addMoreIngredients = true; System.out.println("Please enter the recipe name: "); recipeName = scnr.nextLine();    do {    System.out.println("Would you...
I keep getting minor errors I can't figure out and I don't know how to convert...
I keep getting minor errors I can't figure out and I don't know how to convert decimal .10 to percentage 10% either.   With these functions defined now expand the program for a company who gives discounts on items bought in bulk. Create a main function and inside of it ask the user how many different items they are buying. For each item have the user input a price and quantity, validating them with the functions that you wrote. Use your...
Would anyone know how to code this in SQL? I can't quite figure it out. The...
Would anyone know how to code this in SQL? I can't quite figure it out. The following drop command is inserted for convenience so that if you need to recompile your code, it will drop the table DROP TABLE Orders Cascade constraints DROP TABLE OrderLine CASCADE CONSTRAINTS; -- CREATE TABLE Orders ( ordernum INTEGER PRIMARY KEY, priority CHAR(10) NOT NULL, cost INTEGER NOT NULL, /* IC1: The priority is one of: high, medium, or low */ >> /* IC2: The...
1) Know and understand the history of the development of the atomic theory (name the scientist...
1) Know and understand the history of the development of the atomic theory (name the scientist and what they did) 2) State the Law of Consercation of Matter 3) State the Law of Constant Composition (aka Law of Definite Proportions) a) Be able to calculate percent by mass 4) Name the three subatomic particles of atoms, and know the mass and charge of each particle. 5) Draw a diagram of Thomson's plum-pudding model of the atoms and explain why it...
since firstN is a string it can't compare to an ArrayList * list so how am i suppose to write these parts comparing the string to the list[mid]
c++ question:int ArrayList::binarySearchID(string firstN) const{   int first = 0;         int last = length - 1;         int mid = (first + last) / 2;   bool found = false;   int index;   while (!found && last >= first)   {       if (firstN == list[mid])       {           found = true;       }       else if (firstN > list[mid])       {           first = mid - 1;       }       else if (firstN < list[mid])       {           last...
1)      What evidence is there to support String Theory? Is String Theory really a scientific theory,...
1)      What evidence is there to support String Theory? Is String Theory really a scientific theory, or is it “just philosophy”? Why or why not? Does it have potential for proof?
Helicopter money Is it still a theory?
Helicopter money Is it still a theory?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT