Question

In: Operations Management

When actor Robin Williams took his life in August of 2014, major news organizations covered the...

When actor Robin Williams took his life in August of 2014, major news organizations covered the story in great detail. Most major news outlets reported on Marin County Sheriff’s Lt. Keith Boyd’s press conference, which revealed graphic details from the coroner’s report about the methods Williams used. While there was great interest on the part of the public in finding out what happened, many argued that reporting too much detail about the suicide violated the family’s privacy. Indeed, many of Robin Williams’s fans posted on Facebook, Twitter, and other social networks to express their objections to the media treatment of the suicide, urging reporters to respect the family’s right to grieve in peace. Several members of the mental health community also took issue with the detailed reports. Paul Farmer, chief executive of the mental health charity Mind, wrote to CNN that “When a media report describes clear details of unusual methods of suicide and essentially gives a “how to” guide—the danger is it can make suicide seem like a more accessible action to take.” Some journalists expressed similar viewpoints, criticizing the reports as a clear violation of media ethics. According to the Press Complaints Commission, “When reporting suicide, care should be taken to avoid excessive detail about the method used.” Yet other journalists argued that the primary responsibility of the media was to report the story truthfully and factually. In an op-ed in the LA Times, Andrew Klavan wrote, “The manner of Williams’ death is public information. Journalists should report it as long as it remains of interest to the public. It is not a journalist’s job to protect us from the ugly facts.” Klavan argued that the journalist’s duty is not to do good or be wise, but to report the whole story, which may in fact be a part of a larger story unfolding elsewhere. Sheriff Boyd similarly defended his own actions by stating that he had a duty to report the details as part of the public record. In an interview with Today, Williams’s daughter Zelda discussed how her father never sought to hide his problems, mentioning his openness about struggling with alcoholism. She stated, “I think that one of the things that is changing, that is wonderful, is that people are finally starting to approach talking about illnesses that people can’t immediately see…He didn’t like people feeling like the things that were hard for them they should go through alone.”

Discussion Questions

1. Systematic moral analysis (SMA) first requires identifying the problems in a situation. In this case, who was harmed and how? You may reference the list of moral rules in the transcript of the narration below.

(The first step of SMA is conceptualization, which involves determining who might be harmed and how. If no one is likely to be harmed, then there’s no ethical problem. But how do we really know if we’re about to cause harm? 20th Century Philosopher Bernard Gert developed a list of 10 moral rules that can help us identify ethically questionable acts. 1) Do not kill. 2) Do not cause pain. 3) Do not disable. 4) Do not deprive of freedom or opportunity. 5) Do not deprive of pleasure. 6) Do not deceive. 7) Keep your promises. 8) Do not cheat. 9) Obey the law. 10) Do your duty.)

2. The second step of SMA requires asking who is responsible. Is Sheriff Boyd responsible? The journalists? Anyone else? How do their role-related responsibilities relate to the harm caused?

3. Third in the process of SMA is to consider whether or not the action can be justified. Do you think the role-related responsibilities of Sheriff Boyd or the journalists justified their actions? Why or why not? What alternative ways of reporting Robin Williams’s suicide would have caused less harm?

4. Finally, if you had been in the position of Sheriff Boyd or the journalists, what do you think would have been the ethically ideal action to take?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:-

1)

Right now was hurt right now, all relies upon how set we up are and our psyche is.We can make an environmental well of ethically determined virtual truthsin non consious memory to control our critical thinking and dynamic from the most elevated level of insight and knowing towards increasingly adjusted and in this manner progressively moral selves.

2)

I might want to help the possibility that there could be an all inclusive arrangement of organic reactions to moral issues, a kind of morals incorporated with our cerebrums. My expectation is that we before long have the option to reveal those morals, distinguish them and start to live more completely by them.

I accept we live by them generally unconsiously now, however a great deal of affliction, war, disarray, and clashes could be dispensed with on the off chance that we could consent to live by them all the more consiously.

Our lives, and Journalism's lives rely upon it. Watchers and perusers merits and need it.

3)

Regardless of whether the watchers and perusers accomplish work through SMA for News report and picture of visual news-casting they are bound to recollect the substance of the story the manner in which it was confined in the photo than it was surrounded in the story.

We accept that Sheriff Boyd while acting with most elevated moral goals legitimized their instinctive reactions of worry through concious investigation unexpectedly acting unethically driving by the news report. Integrative brain and visual morals hypotheses persuade that Sheriff Boyd would have settled on a superior choice by respecting their natural reactions that the news strengthened negative impacts and damage as opposed to it passed on the significance of psychological well-being issue in todays world.

4)

A serviceable arrangement we believe is to prepare oneself in moral reflection, cautiously considering intense issues when time permits, in order to be more ready to react ethically as the situation requests.

Also, perusers and watchers only sometimes have the opportunity to work through the means of SMA for each and every news report they see.

A serviceable arrangement is to assemble the investigation of morals and media into instructive frameworks inorder to upgrade the decisions of clients of contemperory media.

please like the answer........


Related Solutions

Montgomery was covered under a group life insurance policy and his ex-wife was the beneficiary. When...
Montgomery was covered under a group life insurance policy and his ex-wife was the beneficiary. When he remarried, Michael designated his new wife, Cynthia, as the beneficiary, and she mailed the form to Aetna. When Michael died, Cynthia Claimed the benefits, but Aetna denied the claim, stating it did not have the change of beneficiary form in its files. cynthia argued that when she mailed the form a presumption was raised that Aetna had received the form. Is she correct?...
Montgomery was covered under a group life insurance policy and his ex-wife was the beneficiary. When...
Montgomery was covered under a group life insurance policy and his ex-wife was the beneficiary. When he remarried, Michael designated his new wife, Cynthia, as the beneficiary, and she mailed the form to Aetna. When Michael died, Cynthia Claimed the benefits, but Aetna denied the claim, stating it did not have the change of beneficiary form in its files. cynthia argued that when she mailed the form a presumption was raised that Aetna had received the form. Is she correct?...
You and a friend, who is not an accounting major, are watching the news when they...
You and a friend, who is not an accounting major, are watching the news when they announce that Amazon.com, Inc. has just released their earnings report, including all four primary financial statements. Your friend knows that you are well versed in financial reporting and the usefulness of accounting information and asks you, Why is this news? Prepare a written response explaining the objectives of financial reporting. Include in your response an explanation of who might care about this news and...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid $15.0 million to write his book My Life. The book took...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid $15.0 million to write his book My Life. The book took three years to write. In the time he spent​ writing, Clinton could have been paid to make speeches. Given his​ popularity, assume that he could earn $8.1 million per year​ (paid at the end of the​ year) speaking instead of writing. Assume his cost of capital is 10.4% per year. a. What is the NPV of agreeing to write the book​ (ignoring any royalty​...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid $10 million to write his book My Life. The book took...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid $10 million to write his book My Life. The book took three years to write. In the time he spent writing, Clinton could have been paid to make speeches. Given his popularity, assume that he could earn $8 million per year (paid at the end of the year) speaking instead of writing. Assume his cost of capital is 10% per year. a.What is the NPV of agreeing to write the book (ignoring any royalty payments)?...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid 10 million to write his book My Life. The book took...
Bill Clinton reportedly was paid 10 million to write his book My Life. The book took three years to write. In the time he spent writing, Clinton could have been paid to make speeches. Given his popularity, assume that he could earn 8 million per year (paid at the end of the year) speaking instead of writing. Assume his cost of capital is 10% per year. What is the IRR of agreeing to write the book (ignoring any royalty payments)?...
Collin has been listening to the business news and his interest was piqued when he heard...
Collin has been listening to the business news and his interest was piqued when he heard about the idea of investing in stocks and bonds. He was however a bit confused when he heard about ordinary shares, preference shares and debentures. As a financial advisor, please advise Collin on two benefits and two drawbacks of investing in each type of instrument mentioned above. Please ensure that you state the instrument to which you are making reference.
1.When Steve died, his wife Linda was the sole beneficiary of his $50,000 life insurance policy....
1.When Steve died, his wife Linda was the sole beneficiary of his $50,000 life insurance policy. How will the $50,000 life insurance proceeds affect Linda’s gross income? 2.For tax purposes in 2018, A&P had operating income of $375,000 and operating expenses of $128,000. Included in A&P’s expenses is $22,000 for bad debts write-offs during 2018. In January of 2019, they received $7,000 from an account that was written off as a bad debt in 2018. What effect does this collection...
1. What are the major differences between term and permanent life insurance? When is it best...
1. What are the major differences between term and permanent life insurance? When is it best to get term insurance? (15 points) 2. Driving in a severe thunderstorm, Polly collided with another car. Two passengers in the other vehicle were injured. They filed suit against Polly. One claimed $115,000 injuries and the other claimed $135,000 in injuries. The driver of the other vehicle was not harmed, but his car’s damage totaled $6,600. Polly has bodily injury coverage for 100/300/50. Assume...
Community Case: Mental Health Case Part 1 Seventeen-year-old Justin Sutton took his own life last night...
Community Case: Mental Health Case Part 1 Seventeen-year-old Justin Sutton took his own life last night with a handgun owned by his parents. Recently,several of his peers had posted photographs and demeaning comments about him on social media, suggesting that Justin was gay. This was only the most recent incident in a long history of bullying and depression experienced by Justin, who had been meeting with his guidance counselor regularly. The counselor had referred him for mental health services, and...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT