Ans - Reason for choosing equity over debt -
- A company is pioneer stage- If the company is in pioneer stage
that company chooses to opt for equity. The reason behind that in
initial period it is very hard for startup to earn profits due to
high cost associated with the project. So in case of debt, a
company has to pay fixed amount of interest , no matters company is
in profits or losses. So in that case a company opt for common
stock for financing
- .Reduction of risk - The interest payment of debt is mandatory
even company are in losses. So a company has no obligation to pay
some cash flow to common stockholders. This reduces the risk of
debt burden but it will increase the required return of equity
investors.
- To earn capital profits- The company can issue shares at
premium if company wants to earn capital profits. But there is no
scope for earning profits in case of debt.
- When company has ample growth opportunities- When company has
ample growth opportunities it can finance through equity. As they
don't have debt burden and all the profit will go in growth
opportunities.
Reason for choosing debt over equity-
- To get tax benefits- Sometimes a company issues debt to get tax
benefits. Because it provides tax shield due to interest fall under
expense category, which provide tax benefits.
- When company wants to retain profits- If company wants to
retain more profits either due to liquidity needs or for large
expenditure, they can retain maximum amount to themselves by paying
fixed amount of interest.
- Debt is cheaper source of finance- Although there is no
obligation of payment to equity shareholders but their required
return is quite high as compared to debt. Debt has generally low
risk due to regular payments and it is cheaper source of finance as
compared to equity.
- To obtain optimal capital structure- Sometimes company finances
through debt to achieve optimal debt structure and to increase the
earning per share. The optimal capital structure also increase the
value of firm.