Question

In: Economics

A study published in BMC Health Services Research in October 2008 considered the cost-effectiveness of assisting...

  1. A study published in BMC Health Services Research in October 2008 considered the cost-effectiveness of assisting general practitioners in management of patients with diabetes by use of a centralized database of clinical data to coordinate care. Based on five years of data a simulation model was used to predict patient outcomes and complications up to the time of death.

The per-patient increase in costs due to the program were estimated to be $3,000. Quality-adjusted life years were calculated to be 8.5 years for those in the program and 8.2 years for those not in the program. A year of perfect health is felt to be worth $50,000.

(a) Perform a cost-benefit analysis of the program. What do you conclude? i.e is the program worthwhile or not ? (Hint MB Vs MC)

(b) Perform a cost-utility analysis of the program. What do you conclude? i.e is the program worthwhile or not?

Solutions

Expert Solution

a) On performing Cost - Benefit Analysis we know per patient cost ( MC) or marginal cost = $ 3,000

Quality life adjusted for those in program = 8.5 years

Quality life for those not in the program = 8.2 years

Marginal benefit of the intervention = 8.5 - 8.2 = 0.3 years

A year of perfect health is felt to be worth = $50,000

Marginal benefit interms of money from program = 0.3 * $50,000 = $ 15,000

Comparing the marginal cost versus the marginal benefit ( MC ($3,000) < MB ( $15,000)) , we can say participants of program enjoy more marginal benefit thus the program is worth while.

b) Cost - Utility analysis  is a financial assessment used to guide procurement decisions applicable in health technology assessment.

Quality life adjusted for those in program = 8.5 years

Quality life for those not in the program = 8.2 years

the net benefit of the intervention = 8.5 - 8.2 = 0.3 years for participants

Thus the program is worthwhile from CUA perspective as it gives participants an increase in the quality adjusted life years.


Related Solutions

The Journal of Accounting Research (March 2008) published a study on relationship incentives and degree of...
The Journal of Accounting Research (March 2008) published a study on relationship incentives and degree of optimism among analysts’ forecasts. Participants were analysts at either a large or small brokerage firm who made their forecasts either early or late in the quarter. Also, some analysts were only concerned with making an accurate forecast, while others were also interested in their relationship with management. Suppose one of these analysts is randomly selected. Consider the following events: A = {The analyst is...
A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue 6)...
A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue 6) by researchers at the University of Minnesota (U of M) found that 124 out of 1,923 U of M females had over $6,000 in credit card debt while 61 out of 1,236 males had over $6,000 in credit card debt. a. Construct a 95% confidence interval for the difference between the proportions of female and male U of M students who have more than...
13) A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue...
13) A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue 6) by researchers at the University of Minnesota (U of M) found that 124 out of 1,923 U of M females had over $6,000 in credit card debt while 61 out of 1,236 males had over $6,000 in credit card debt. a) Verify that the sample size is large enough in each group to use the normal distribution to construct a confidence interval for...
A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue 6)...
A study published in 2008 in the American Journal of Health Promotion (Volume 22, Issue 6) by researchers at the University of Minnesota (U of M) found that 124 out of 1,923 U of M females had over $6,000 in credit card debt while 61 out of 1,236 males had over $6,000 in credit card debt. 10. Verify that the sample size is large enough in each group to use the normal distribution to construct a confidence interval for a...
13. A study published in 2008 by researchers at UT Austin found that 124 out of...
13. A study published in 2008 by researchers at UT Austin found that 124 out of 1,923 U of T females had over $6,000 in credit card debt while 65 out of 1,236 males had over $6,000 in credit card debt. Test using 0.05, if there is evidence that the proportion of female students at U of T with more than $6,000 credit card debt. a. Verify that the sample size is large enough in each group to use the...
health outcomes in a cost-effectiveness methodology.
health outcomes in a cost-effectiveness methodology.
To study the effectiveness of treatments for insomnia, a health psychologist conducted a study with 12...
To study the effectiveness of treatments for insomnia, a health psychologist conducted a study with 12 participants. Four participants were instructed to count sheep (Sheep Condition), four were told to concentrate on their breathing (Breathing Condition), and four were not given any special instructions. Over the next few days, measures were taken of how many minutes it took each participant to fall asleep. The average times for the participants in the Sheep Condition were 14, 28, 27, and 31; for...
Accounting and Machiavellianism. A study of Machiavellian traits in accountants was published in Behavioral Research in...
Accounting and Machiavellianism. A study of Machiavellian traits in accountants was published in Behavioral Research in Accounting (January 2008). Recall (from Exercise 1.6, p. 4) that Machiavellian describes negative character traits such as manipulation, cunning, duplicity, deception, and bad faith. A Machiavellian ("Mach") rating score was determined for each in a sample of accounting alumni of a large southwestern university. The accountants were then classified as having high, moderate, or low Mach rating scores. For one portion of the study,...
Describe comparative effectiveness research as it relates to new technology in health care.
Describe comparative effectiveness research as it relates to new technology in health care.
Suppose we want to study the average number of citations of research papers published by all...
Suppose we want to study the average number of citations of research papers published by all faculty members. Towards that, we choose 10 departments at random and note down the total number of citations of research papers published by all faculty members in these departments. This is an example of a I. simple random sampling. II. stratified sampling. III. convenience or biased sampling. IV. systematic sampling. V. cluster sampling. Suppose an urn contains 6 red balls and 5 black balls....
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT