Question

In: Nursing

What significance does the case of Can Asylum Seeking Be Managed Ethically? have regarding vulnerability and...

What significance does the case of Can Asylum Seeking Be Managed Ethically? have regarding vulnerability and marginalized populations? Explain your answer.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Public health practitioners attempt to identify and then remove, or at least reduce, threats of harm. However, harm does not affect everyone in the same way. Some people and communities are resilient, whereas others are more susceptible to potential harm. Much public health work is carried out by, or on behalf of, governments. Where people or communities are at great risk of harm, government has a clear and firm responsibility to protect its citizens. One way of describing a potential source of such a risk of harm is to focus on the idea of vulnerability. This introduction explores the concept of ‘vulnerability’ and the role that it may play in public health.

Asylum seekers under threat of forced repatriation have emerged as a new category of hunger strikers, posing novel challenges for management. The management of 3 Cambodian asylum seekers on hunger strike admitted to a hospital in Sydney, New South Wales, Australia, posed important ethical dilemmas for the physicians and mental health experts involved in their care. Several factors confounded the task of assessment and decision making, including language and cultural barriers, the patients' past exposure to persecution by authorities, and the complexities of the legal procedures being pursued. Different rules appeared to govern the actions of the hunger strikers, the medical team, and the immigration authorities, creating a "malignant triangle" of mounting confrontation. Recent recommendations for the management of asylum-seeking hunger strikers include the appointment of an external physician of confidence and the writing of a confidential advance directive specifying the hunger striker's wishes about resuscitation in the event of collapse. In addition, we consider the value of constituting an ad hoc ethics committee to advise the responsible physician on points of conflict in managing the hunger strike.

Thank you..


Related Solutions

What significance does the case of Ethics of Administering Anthrax Vaccine to Children have regarding disease...
What significance does the case of Ethics of Administering Anthrax Vaccine to Children have regarding disease prevention and control? Explain your answer.
What significance does the case of The Prohibition of Smoking in Public Places in Bulgaria have...
What significance does the case of The Prohibition of Smoking in Public Places in Bulgaria have regarding chronic disease prevention and health promotion? Explain your answer
What significance does the case of Internet-Based HIV/AIDS Education and Prevention Programs in Vulnerable Populations have...
What significance does the case of Internet-Based HIV/AIDS Education and Prevention Programs in Vulnerable Populations have regarding international collaboration for public health research? Explain your answer.
What is the insurance significance of the incoterms? Does it have anything to do with the...
What is the insurance significance of the incoterms? Does it have anything to do with the insurable interest doctrine? Say that you bought a life insurance policy against the early death of your neighbor down the street. Then the neighbor dies. Will the insured be allowed to collect on the policy? Now let’s change the scenario. You have a manufacturing business and you employ salespersons. Your business would be in major trouble if anything were to happen to your star...
what significance does electronic notation have to the study of plastics?
what significance does electronic notation have to the study of plastics?
What is genericide? what is a recent case and what are recommendations regarding how marketers can...
What is genericide? what is a recent case and what are recommendations regarding how marketers can avoid it.
What significance does the case of Safe Water Standards and Monitoring of a Well Construction Program...
What significance does the case of Safe Water Standards and Monitoring of a Well Construction Program have regarding environmental and occupational public health? Explain your answer.
Can you introduce one case regarding the positive externality, and explain it with details? How does...
Can you introduce one case regarding the positive externality, and explain it with details? How does the externality impact the company’s project, and how you evaluate it? Project externality should be considered carefully when you attempt to list potential projects and do capital budgeting as a financial manager.Briefly talk about its outcomes, and attach your evaluation.
What is the vulnerability model of schizophrenia? How does it account for schizophrenia developing in an...
What is the vulnerability model of schizophrenia? How does it account for schizophrenia developing in an individuals with a low genetic predisposition? How does it account for schizophrenia NOT developing in some with a high genetic predisposition?
What effect does estrogen have in calcium homeostasis? what concerns would a woman athlete seeking to...
What effect does estrogen have in calcium homeostasis? what concerns would a woman athlete seeking to use hormonal contraceptives (containing both estrogen and progestin) have? Be thorough with your response. no concept map needed. just thoroughly explain it
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT