Question

In: Finance

On page 248 (438) of your textbook under "Cyberlaw in Action", the case of the $24.98...

On page 248 (438) of your textbook under "Cyberlaw in Action", the case of the $24.98 tickets to Paris is discussed. Make an argument for either United Airlines in declining to honor the price in the e-ad or a counter argument for the consumer that the price should be honored. You can put yourself in the position of a consumer who bought the ticket, or in the position of United Airlines. Be sure to use legal theories from the textbook. Make sure you respond to the question: "Is it ethical for a customer to insist on a contract that is based on a mistaken price?" and "Is it ethical for an e-tailer to refuse to honor a contract that is based on a mistaken price?" Even though I usually request that you use an objective standard and not insert your personal opinion, in this case you should state what you think is right or wrong from an ethical standpoint, not necessarily what the outcome would be under the law.

Solutions

Expert Solution

I will make an argument for United Airlines in declining to honor the price. The basis of the argument is the presence of an intention to create legal relations. An integral part of any contract is the presence of an intention to create legal relations. In this case there was a unilateral mistake by United Airlines and as the error had caused the ticket to be heavily discounted United Airlines had no intention to form a contract at $24.98.

No, it is not ethical for a customer to insist on a contract that is based on a mistaken price. This is because the price is a result of a unilateral mistake and hence a proper contract was not intended to be formed. From an ethical point of view a customer should appreciate the situation and not try and exploit the situation for his own benefit at the expense of the e-tailer.

Yes, it is ethical for an e-tailer to refuse to honor a contract that is based on a mistaken price. Ethically speaking there was no intention on the part of the e-tailer to enter into the contract at this price and hence e-tailer is merely protecting its interest. To ensure that the interest of the consumers are not harmed the e-tailer should properly communicate with the customer and should also negate any applicable cancellation charges so that the customers are not harmed in any way.


Related Solutions

Case Study The Tale of Chromatic to Lucent Instructions Go to page 276 of your textbook...
Case Study The Tale of Chromatic to Lucent Instructions Go to page 276 of your textbook From concept to Wall Street: A complete guide to entrepreneurship and venture capital and read the case study “The Sale of Chromatic to Lucent”. In one paragraph, briefly summarize the case. Then, discuss what you learned from the case. What would you have done differently? Case Study—The Sale of Chromatis to Lucent In May 2000, Lucent Technologies announced it was acquiring an almost unknown...
In the case Las Vegas Sands v. Nehme, reported on page 380 of your textbook, the...
In the case Las Vegas Sands v. Nehme, reported on page 380 of your textbook, the casino's "marker" was found by the court to be a negotiable instrument. The Venetian (a hotel owned by Las Vegas Sands LLC) was then allowed to sued Nehme for not paying a negotiable instrument. In a 500 word paper discuss the required elements for a negotiable instrument. Is it feasible that the casino marker contained all of these elements? Explain whether or not you...
Read case: The marry-Go-Round - Letter to my Doctor on page 444 of the textbook, and...
Read case: The marry-Go-Round - Letter to my Doctor on page 444 of the textbook, and address the following: 1. The physician never responded to the patient's letter of desperation. Discuss what you would suggest the patient should do. 2. Describe the legal and ethical issues that appear in the correspondence. 3. As the patient continues on her marry-go-round, discuss what you would advise her to do.
In the textbook, Managerial Epidemiology on page 609 there is Capstone Case H: Cost-Effectiveness Analyses of...
In the textbook, Managerial Epidemiology on page 609 there is Capstone Case H: Cost-Effectiveness Analyses of type II Diabetes. I am trying to figure out how to answer questions 8 & 9. Question 8 ask to calculate the incremental cost of screening vs. not screening and question 9 ask you to calculate the Risk difference, cumlative incidence, as well as total cost and savings of screening and not screening.    Looking for how to answer questions 8 & 9 for Capstone...
Read the Richard’s Furniture Company case that starts on page 58 of the textbook (problem 11)...
Read the Richard’s Furniture Company case that starts on page 58 of the textbook (problem 11) and then describe how internal control could be strengthened at Richard’s. Richards Furniture company is a 15-store chain, concentrated in the southwest, that sells living room and bedroom furniture. Each store has a full-time manager and an assistant manager, who are paid on a salary basis. The cashiers and sales personnel typically work part-time and are paid an hourly wage plus a commission based...
The mechanism for the Fischer esterification is shown on page 762 of your textbook. The acid...
The mechanism for the Fischer esterification is shown on page 762 of your textbook. The acid catalyst is specifically used in twosteps – protonation of 10 to make 11 and in the formation of 13 (it is unlikely that 12 directly goes to 13 – there is probably a deprotonation of 12 then a reprotonation to make 13).Explain mechanistically what the purpose of these two protonations are.
On page 512 of your textbook, it states that “…a 10 o C increase in temperature...
On page 512 of your textbook, it states that “…a 10 o C increase in temperature increases the rate of a typical reaction by two or three times.” Is this the case for the decolorization of CV + ? Show your work using 2 of the average temperatures (from the data table) that differ by about 10 o C. The temps I have are 18.1'C and 28.1'C
Creatine clearance Worksheet Refer to page 14 of your textbook for reference and calculations For each...
Creatine clearance Worksheet Refer to page 14 of your textbook for reference and calculations For each of these questions calculate the creatine clearance using the most appropriate method John Sanders DOB 4-17-91 Patient’s urine creatine- 569mg/day Patient’s plasma creatine- 3.69mg/dL Total volume-729ml/24 hours Debbie Renninger DOB 7-19-86 Patient’s urine creatine- 1179 mg/day Patient’s plasma creatine-5.79 mg/dL Total volume- 2253mL/24 hours Samantha Pierson DOB 8-25-76 Patient’s urine creatine- 1589 mg/day Patient’s plasma creatine- 7.73 mg/dL Total volume- 785mL/24 hours Wesley Matthews...
Instructions: Format each of your Answers as follows: (A) Definition (quote from the Textbook, with page...
Instructions: Format each of your Answers as follows: (A) Definition (quote from the Textbook, with page number, OR quote from another permitted source -- i.e. an online law dictionary, with proper source citation ) (B) Explanation in your own words (C) Example (either your own, OR one that is in the Text, OR one that is in another permitted source, with proper source citation) (D) Find a website that supports and further explains your answer (not one that I have...
Compute a 98% confidence interval, using method 1 in page 297 of your textbook, for the...
Compute a 98% confidence interval, using method 1 in page 297 of your textbook, for the proportion of defective items in a process when it is found that a sample of size 100 yields 8 defectives.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT