Question

In: Statistics and Probability

Discuss in detail why determining true cause and effect is difficult and why it is important....

Discuss in detail why determining true cause and effect is difficult and why it is important. Also discuss how the results of a stsitical test can be significant without there being

1. Association between the two variables

2. A true cause and effect relationship between the two variables

Solutions

Expert Solution

1.suppose we observe that people who daily drink more than 4 cups of coffee have a decreased chance of developing skin cancer. This does not necessarily mean that coffee confers resistance to cancer; one alternative explanation would be that people who drink a lot of coffee work indoors for long hours and thus have little exposure to the sun, a known risk. If this is the case, then the number of hours spent outdoors is a confounding variable—a cause common to both observations. In such a situation, a direct causal link cannot be inferred; the association merely suggests a hypothesis, such as a common cause, but does not offer proof. In addition, when many variables in complex systems are studied, spurious associations can arise. Thus, association does not imply causation.

2. If your data have a correlation coefficient of +1 or -1, it is important to note that correlation still does not imply causality. For instance, a scatterplot of popsicle sales and skateboard accidents in a neighborhood may look like a straight line and give you a correlation coefficient of 0.9999...but buying popsicles clearly doesn't cause skateboard accidents. However, more people ride skateboards and more people buy popsicles in hot weather, which is the reason these two factors are correlated.

It is also important to note that the correlation coefficient only measures linear relationships. A meaningful nonlinear relationship may exist even if the correlation coefficient is 0.


Related Solutions

Discuss the standard model in detail and why particle physics is important to astronomy.
Discuss the standard model in detail and why particle physics is important to astronomy.
Explain what the greenhouse effect is and discuss the cause and consequences of this to the...
Explain what the greenhouse effect is and discuss the cause and consequences of this to the planet. What evidence is there to show that “global warming ”has been the worst in the last ten years? Experts suggest that we must practice the three R’s to reduce the impact of global warming. Explain?
Explain why it is difficult to identify a treatment effect for a single individual?
Explain why it is difficult to identify a treatment effect for a single individual?
Why are dividends an important in determining the future price of the firm? Why is it...
Why are dividends an important in determining the future price of the firm? Why is it important to understand the prospectus of future growth of a company when determining its value, and more importantly, your investment strategy with that firm?
Does linear regression estimate a cause and effect relationship? Why or why not?
Does linear regression estimate a cause and effect relationship? Why or why not?
What is the Suess Effect and why is it important?
What is the Suess Effect and why is it important?
4) Discuss in detail an appropriate method for determining the moisture content of sugar
4) Discuss in detail an appropriate method for determining the moisture content of sugar
why is it important for determining the function of a membrane protein to know if it...
why is it important for determining the function of a membrane protein to know if it spans the bilayer or appears only on one face of the membrane? provide 3 example proteins and their functions.
Discuss additive, synergistic(potentiation), and antagonist drug effect. Why is it important for the nurse to understand...
Discuss additive, synergistic(potentiation), and antagonist drug effect. Why is it important for the nurse to understand these concepts
Why is communication important during organizational change and why is it so difficult to communicate with...
Why is communication important during organizational change and why is it so difficult to communicate with followers? How are leadership and HR related to change initiatives? please provide at least one reference.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT