Henrietta Lacks was an African American woman living in Baltimore. She was a mother of five,...

Henrietta Lacks was an African American woman living in Baltimore. She was a mother of five, who died at the age of 30 in 1951 due to cervical cancer.

Discuss the ethics of using someone’s cells/biological materials without consent.
Was it ethical for doctors to take Henrietta Lacks' cells without her consent?
Should her family have been compensated for the use of her cells?
Discuss how this differs from current procedures relating to organ denotation.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Use of biological material including cells and tissues have been a subject of concern and importance in the community of scientists since many centuries. Although there were no ethical restrictions and norms regarding use of cell material of patients and participants and concent, credit or compensation were not of priority, many changes were made in the worldwide ethical standards.

The case of Henrietta Lacks triggered many discussions in the field of scientific research and raised questions of just treatment, importance of concent, confidentiality etc.

Tissues of Henrietta Lacks was taken during the diagnosis of her cancer and later were used as a sample for an ongoing research. Use of biospecimens was neither then nor in today's day require any concent from patient as long as the identity of the donor is not revealed, or it was orginally collected for another purpose or no interaction with the person is involved. Ethical restrictions is not feasible in this case as most of the time the donor remains anonymous and also there are very less chance of each sample to become as unusual or of value like that of Henrietta Lacks.

The case of Henrietta Lacks was exceptional and the major reason for ethical norm violation centres around the use of her name initials HeLa against the cell line . There were discussions made regarding this case and proper compensation and concent were followed up with her family.

Hence this case was partly ethically violating and also exceptional.

Thankyou

gladiator answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Based on the Novel The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks using the discussion on the American...

Based on the Novel The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks using the discussion on the American Nurses Association’s Definition of Ethical Principles based on the 1990 Self Determination Act Ethical Principles Autonomy Beneficence Non maleficence Fidelity Justice Paternalism Ethical Theories Ethical Relativism Feminist Theory Deontology Utilitarianism Apply how ethical principle were misused. Discuss ethical theories as it applies to Henrietta and family. Explore current research that would impact the ethical dilemmas which occurred during and after Henrietta’s life and discuss...

An African American woman approaches a pharmacist at the local drugstore near the hospital where she...

An African American woman approaches a pharmacist at the local drugstore near the hospital where she was given a prescription for chest congestion. She asks the pharmacist for oils in the store with camphor so she can rub it on her chest to help with her congestion. The pharmacist immediately tells her that to do so would be ridiculous and that she should not proceed with such a remedy but only use the medicine per her prescription. Did the pharmacist...

A woman with “hitch-hiker’s thumb” marries a man who lacks this trait (but whose mother had...

A woman with “hitch-hiker’s thumb” marries a man who lacks this trait (but whose mother had it). What is the probability that a child born to this couple will have a hitch-hiker’s thumb?

Renee is a 21-year-old African American woman in her 35th week of pregnancy. She is married...

Renee is a 21-year-old African American woman in her 35th week of pregnancy. She is married and the mother of two young children. Her pre-pregnancy BMI was 18.1. She has gained 24 pounds since becoming pregnant, but at her most recent prenatal visit, she was found to have lost a pound over the past week. She says that her weight loss is due to “stress.” Renee says she enjoys eating canned spinach cooked in tomato sauce with chopped onions and...

Mrs. Johnson, a 78 yrs. old African-American woman who lives in Bangor, Maine. She rarely goes...

Mrs. Johnson, a 78 yrs. old African-American woman who lives in Bangor, Maine. She rarely goes outside because of her health and concern for her safety as she lives in a high crime rate area of the city. She has been diagnosed with osteomalacia and lactose intolerance. What factors likely contributed to the osteomalacia diagnosis and why?

Chapter 34, Antihyperlipidemic Drugs Susan Smith is a 40-year-old African American woman. She has a history...

Chapter 34, Antihyperlipidemic Drugs Susan Smith is a 40-year-old African American woman. She has a history significant for diabetes, hypertension, and smoking (1 pack/day). She is being discharged from the hospital today after having a myocardial infarction. The only new prescription she will be leaving with is pravastatin (Pravachol) 40 mg with directions to take one tablet daily at bedtime. The physician has asked the nurse to go over discharge instructions with Mrs. Smith. During the discharge counseling, Mrs. Smith...

Amaani Lyle, an African American woman, was hired by Warner Brothers Television Productions to be a...

Amaani Lyle, an African American woman, was hired by Warner Brothers Television Productions to be a scriptwriters’ assistant for the writers of Friends, a popular, adult-oriented television series. One of her essential job duties was to type detailed notes for the scriptwriters during brainstorming sessions in which they discussed jokes, dialogue, and story lines. The writers then combed through Lyle’s notes after the meetings for script material. During these meetings, the three male scriptwriters told lewd and vulgar jokes and...

15 year old African American male presents with his mother to the ER where you are...

15 year old African American male presents with his mother to the ER where you are the physician assistant helping the ER attending in a very busy rural hospital. He is complaining of abdominal pain for one day and nausea with vomiting. His mother reports a fever and malaise. He has no significant medical history but his mother is concerned that he may have the "kissing disease" as he has a boy friend who had mononucleosis six months ago and...

An African-American woman, Mary, brought her infant son to the hospital with a high fever accompanied...

An African-American woman, Mary, brought her infant son to the hospital with a high fever accompanied by her grandmother, Mrs. Washington. You are the nurse assigned to care for Mary’s infant son. After admitting the child to the hospital unit, you explain to Mary and Mrs. Washington the plan of care. You explain the undressed infant will be place in a cool mist tent and given a bath in cold water to reduce his temperature. The child’s mother, Mary, is...

A medical assistant calls in her patient, an African American transgendered woman (in her late 40s)...

A medical assistant calls in her patient, an African American transgendered woman (in her late 40s) to take a patient history, blood pressure, weight, and other vitals before she sees the physician. The assumption is that she is of middle class economic status. The medical assistant notes in her history that she is in the process of transitioning from male to female and questions the patient’s religious beliefs in relation to her decisions. The patient becomes agitated and expresses to...

Subjects