Question

In: Physics

I have a hard time understanding the subject of fictitious forces. Let's discuss a few examples:...

I have a hard time understanding the subject of fictitious forces. Let's discuss a few examples:

1) I'm sitting inside a vehicle which is accelerating in a straight line. I feel like someone is pushing me to the seat. So, on the one hand, I'm told that this happens according to the third Newton's law: this pressure is the result of me pushing the seat as a reaction to the seat pushing me (because it is accelerating with the same acceleration as the car). On the other hand, these forces are acting on different objects and I'm told that there is another fictitious force acting on me in an opposite direction to the acceleration. So what is right? And if there is a fictitious force, then why some call it a "math trick" when they are real and I can feel them?

2) I do not understand why some call centrifugal force a fictitious force. The earth is pulling the earth with its "invisible" string called gravitation. That's why the moon is still there. And this is the centripetal force. However the moon is also pulling the earth according to the Newton's third law, and that's why we have tides. This is the centrifugal force. So why it is fictitious? What it has to do with frame of reference? When we observe this in non-inertial frame of reference (such as the moon), does it simply mean that we can't call it anymore a reaction force according to the Newton's third law? But why if it is virtually the reaction force?

3) Accelerating elevator - similar to the first example - let's say the elevator is accelerating upwards. So we get that N? =m(g+a), and that's the same as me pushing the floor. That is why I feel heavier. Then why some add to here the fictitious force?

I will appreciate any answer.

Solutions

Expert Solution

1) You surely feel the pressure when you accelerate. Whether you attribute it to fictitious forces or other forces depends on your choice of the "reference frame" (vantage point). From the viewpoint of your body's reference frame, which is not an inertial frame, there exist fictitious forces (inertia and/or centrifugal and/or Coriolis' force) that are pushing your body towards the seat. In an inertial reference frame, such as the vantage point of people who stand on the sidewalk and watch you, the pressure is exerted by the seat because it's accelerating i.e. pushing (you are pushing on the seat as well, by the third Newton's law) and there are no additional fictitious forces. Both of these descriptions are OK but the description from the inertial systems (e.g. the sidewalk system) is described by simpler, more universal equations. Without a loss of generality, we may describe all of physics from these frames and these frames never force us (and never allow us) to add any fictitious forces. The frame of your (accelerating) body may be considered "unnatural" and therefore all the forces that appear in that frame are artifacts of the frame's being unnatural, and therefore they are called "fictitious". They may be avoided.

2) Centrifugal forces are the textbook examples of fictitious forces; they have to be added if you describe the reality from the viewpoint of rotating systems. They are avoided if you use non-rotating frames. However, the tides have nothing to do with centrifugal forces. The tidal forces appear because the the side of the Earth that is further from the Moon is less strongly attracted to the Moon than the side that is closer to the Moon. In other words, the tidal forces totally depend on the non-uniformity of the gravitational field around the Moon


Related Solutions

On the subject of Social Determinants of Health, I have a few questions I have to...
On the subject of Social Determinants of Health, I have a few questions I have to answer like describe overall impression of how we are doing in terms of social determinants? What surprised you the most? Where do you see us doing a good job? What social determinants factors negatively the health of individuals? From a ethical standpoint how can we do bter as a country? As a state? As a community? As a individual?
can someone explain to me what osmolality is.? i am having a hard time understanding it
can someone explain to me what osmolality is.? i am having a hard time understanding it
I am having a hard time understanding these two questions. If someone can explain that would...
I am having a hard time understanding these two questions. If someone can explain that would be great. 1) Explain the steps that enables body to metabolize fat to ATP? 2) Write out the amount of ATP, NADH, FADH2 produced in each step of cellular metabolism of a glucose.
In C++, please comment on everything as much as posible because i have hard understanding with...
In C++, please comment on everything as much as posible because i have hard understanding with this topic. DO NOT COPY PAST FROM OTHER POSTS PLEASE Write a program to do the following. In the main function, the program should define an integer array and a pointer that points to the array.it will ask the user to input25students’scores (scores are between 0 and 100inclusive, so need to do input validation), then pass the pointer and its size to a function....
I’m having a very hard time. I have to do a poster pensebtation which I have...
I’m having a very hard time. I have to do a poster pensebtation which I have no clue how to do on Identify the key mental health disorders that affect the elderly. Determine how these key mental disorders differ across racial, ethic, gender, and socioeconomic lines. Thank you,
I have figured out this assignment, but I am having a hard time figuring out the...
I have figured out this assignment, but I am having a hard time figuring out the extra credit, Thanks! Creating a Rectangle class We have created a representation of a rectangle in C++ and extended it to create multiple representation's of rectangles. Classes can simplify that process considerably. In this assignment, your task is to convert the representation of a rectangle we created earlier in the semester to a Rectangle class. The Rectangle class shall consist of the following: The...
What are the four forces of evolution? Discuss examples of how they may have impacted the...
What are the four forces of evolution? Discuss examples of how they may have impacted the evolution of our species, Homo sapiens, specifically.
What are application controls?   Pick a few of these and discuss a few examples of what...
What are application controls?   Pick a few of these and discuss a few examples of what might be a good IT control for a company to put in place.
May I have some examples of van der waals forces in chemistry please?
May I have some examples of van der waals forces in chemistry please?
Economic understanding. Write a few paragraphs about your economic understanding. You can use examples . Summarize...
Economic understanding. Write a few paragraphs about your economic understanding. You can use examples . Summarize the example and explain why you find it particularly interesting or important. Add any relevant comments you have. It is a chance for you to express your economic opinions.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT