2. Albert and Benjamin inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume...

2.
Albert and Benjamin inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume two goods: corn and sausage. They both face constant returns to scale. The table below shows the production possibilities for Albert and Benjamin if they are to fully specialize in each good only:
Albert Benjamin
Corn only 150 200
Sausage only 200 400

Originally Albert and Benjamin practices self-sufficiency and do not trade with each other. An economist proposes to Albert and Benjamin that they should end self-sufficiency and trade with each other. The economist proposes that Albert should specialize in sausage production and Benjamin should focus on corn production, and Albert should give Benjamin 100 sausage in exchange for 100 corn. Would the proposal make both Albert and Benjamin better off? Explain why yes or why not using the economic theories you have learnt?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Solution:

The system of trading, and benefiting from the trade can be identified using concept of comparative advantage. A person/economy must specialize in the production of the good in which they have a comparative advantage. Which good gives comparative advantage to who can be found using opportunity cost.

Opportunity cost is the amount of one good given up in order to increase the production of the other good by one unit (in this sense, it is also the slope of a production possibility frontier). A person has comparative advantage in production of the good for which it has lower opportunity cost as compared to the other person.

Opportunity cost if producing corn = units of sausage produced/units of corn produced

Given the information, Albert can produce either 150 units of corn or 200 units of sausage. So, opportunity cost of producing corn:

For Albert = 200/150 = 1.33 sausages

Similarly, for Benjamin = 400/200 = 2 sausages

As the opportunity cost of producing corn is lower for Albert (1.33 < 2), Albert has comparative advantage in corn production. Correspondingly, Benjamin has comparative advantage in sausage production.

Thus, Albert should specialize in corn production and Benjamin should specialize in sausage production. So, no the proposal will not make any of them better off.

Furthermore, even the exchange rate mentioned is not beneficial even if specialization would have been proposed correctly. This is because exchange rate must lie within opportunity cost range. Proposal that 100 units of corn be exchanged for 100 units of sausage means one corn for one sausage. With the found out opportunity cost above, one corn must be exchanged for somwehere between 1.33 to 2 sausages, for both of them to be better off.

All in all, the mentioned proposal is not beneficial for any of them.

Rahul Sunny answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Albert and Benjamin inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume two...

Albert and Benjamin inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume two goods: corn and sausage. They both face constant returns to scale. The table below shows the production possibilities for Albert and Benjamin if they are to fully specialize in each good only: Albert Benjamin Corn only 150 200 Sausage only 200 400 Originally Albert and Benjamin practices self-sufficiency and do not trade with each other. An economist proposes to Albert and Benjamin that they...

Paul and Tim inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume two...

Paul and Tim inhabit a two person world and they could only produce and consume two goods: cigars and oranges. They both face constant returns to scale. Below is a table that show the production possibilities for both Paul and Tim if they are to fully specialize in each good only: Paul Tim Cigars only 50 100 Oranges only 200 250 a. Who has an absolute advantage in producing cigars? Who has the comparative advantage in producing cigars? b. Who...

Assume Haiti and Antigua are the only two countries that produce and consume fish and sugar....

Assume Haiti and Antigua are the only two countries that produce and consume fish and sugar. In a single year, Haiti can catch 50 tons of fish or produce 500 bags of sugar. In the same growing season, Antigua can catch 50 tons of fish or produce 750 bags of sugar. When the two countries begin trading fish for sugar, we expect the price of fish in Haiti:

Assume that Mexico and Brazil are the only two countries in the world and they produce soybeans and avocados.

Assume that Mexico and Brazil are the only two countries in the world and they produce soybeans and avocados. Mexico 150 million hours of labor per month 5 hours to produce 1 pound of soybeans 3 hours to produce 1 pound of avocados Brazil 300 million hours of labor per month 1 hours to produce 1 pound of soybeans 3 hours to produce 1 pound of avocados For each good, state and explain which country has the comparative advantage.

Assume that there are only two countries in the world, Atlantica and Pacifica. Both countries produce...

Assume that there are only two countries in the world, Atlantica and Pacifica. Both countries produce and consume surfboards. The pre-trade equilibrium price of surfboards in Atlantica is $300 and the pre-trade price of surfboards in Pacifica is $400. a) Draw a three-graph diagram to depict the Pacifica, Atlantica, and international markets for surfboards. Assume that free trade opens up between Pacifica and Atlantica yielding an international price of $375 with 10,000 surfboards being traded. Be sure to label all...

Absolute Advantage has nothing to do with world trade. Absolute advantage only indicates who could produce...

Absolute Advantage has nothing to do with world trade. Absolute advantage only indicates who could produce the most of something, but not necessarily at the lowest marginal opportunity cost. Only comparative advantage – producing at the lowest marginal opportunity costs - is relevant in world trade. - Who would be better off? Who would be worse off? Why? - What is the difference between a ban and an import tax? - Look at explanation in Unit 2 Seminar slides of...

Consider a Ricardian world consisting of U.S. and Japan. Both countries produce and consume the same...

Consider a Ricardian world consisting of U.S. and Japan. Both countries produce and consume the same two goods: cars and computers. In U.S., it takes 400 hours of labor to make a car, and 100 hours of labor to make a computer. In Japan, it takes 400 hours of labor to make a car, and 200 hours of labor to make a computer. Each country has 2 billion hours of labor. a. What would the autarky equilibrium (i.e., the...

2. In the oligopoly market, only two companies A and B produce goods of the same...

2. In the oligopoly market, only two companies A and B produce goods of the same quality. Each company is involved in producing goods. The marginal cost and average cost are the same at 30. When the market demand function is Q=900-10P, answer the following questions - Draw the balance with Bertrand, and describe the process in which Bertrand's balance was drawn. -Draw the profits of each of the two companies in Bertrand's balance.

Suppose there are only two firms in the market, firm 1 and firm 2. They produce...

Suppose there are only two firms in the market, firm 1 and firm 2. They produce identical products. Firm 1 has a constant marginal cost where AC1 =MC1 =20, and firm 2 has a constant marginal cost AC2 =MC2 =8. The market demand function is given by Q = 100 - 0.5P. a) Find the Cournot Nash Equilibrium price and quantity, write down the profits for each firm. (Use "q1" to represent output level for firm 1, and "profit1" to...

In a simple economy, people consume only two goods: food and clothing. The market basket of...

In a simple economy, people consume only two goods: food and clothing. The market basket of goods used to compute the CPI has 65 units of food and 22 units of clothing. Food Clothing Last year’s price $ 4 $ 16 This year’s price $ 8 $ 19 a) What are the percentage increases in the price of food? ____________ b) What are the percentage increases in the price of clothing? ____________ c) What is the percentage increase in the...

Subjects