In: Economics
As an economist what would you propose?
Answer : B. Disagree with the proposal in principle because redistribution of income is always inefficient.
As the net income of individuals whether they are young adults or senior citizens is after the deduction of various taxes payable by them to the economy. In the broadsum category of senior citizens, there will be those with high social security benefits such as pensions, large savings, retirement plans by former employees and those reaping strategic investment plans. They don't have to be exempted from paying the normal tax rates just because of the age criteria.
But rather, those senior citizens who earned less during their employment period may earn lesser than that during their later ages. And a large number of aged population still find it hard to earn for a living. They are the people who need to be exempted from paying higher taxes than broadly categorizing the old age people as a whole.
Exceptions that are given based on income levels as a sub category to old age benefits will be a better alternative.