Question

In: Economics

KJ and Andy develop a 2-brain framework which they call system 1/system2. Thaler develops a framework...

KJ and Andy develop a 2-brain framework which they call system 1/system2. Thaler develops a framework surrounding nudge moments. Please explain and define system 1/ system 2 and nudge moments with examples. How are they similar and how are they different.

Solutions

Expert Solution

A dual-system theoretical framework to explain why our judgments and decisions often do not conform to formal notions of rationality.

  • System 1 “is the brain’s fast, automatic, intuitive approach”. System 1 activity includes the innate mental activities that we are born with, such as a preparedness to perceive the world around us, recognise objects, orient attention, avoid losses - and fear spiders! Other mental activities become fast and automatic through prolonged practice.
  • System 2 is “the mind’s slower, analytical mode, where reason dominates” . Usually, system 2 activity is activated when we do something that does not come naturally and requires some sort of conscious mental exertion.

A common example used to demonstrate the two systems is the following puzzle: A bat and a ball together cost $1.10. The bat costs $1 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?


Faced with this puzzle, the majority of people instantly guess 10 cents. The correct answer, however, is 5 cents - which, again, most people can work out after spending more time thinking about the question. For years, this has been used as a perfect example of how the way we think is ruled by two types of mental processes: fast and intuitive, versus slow and analytical.

Nudge theory suggests consumer behaviour can be influenced by small suggestions and positive reinforcements.

Proponents of nudge theory suggest that well-placed ‘nudges’ can reduce market failure, save the government money, encourage desirable actions and help increase the efficiency of resource use. Critics argue nudges can be misused and become a form of social engineering or way to encourage consumers to buy goods they don’t really need.

“Irrational” Decision Making: The Example of the Psychology of Price

Boundedly rational choices, made due to limits in our thinking processes, especially those we make as consumers, are illustrated well in Dan Ariely’s popular science book Predictably Irrational. A good portion of the research he discusses involves prices and value perception. One study asked participants whether they would buy a product (e.g. a cordless keyboard) for a dollar amount that was equal to the last two digits of their US social security number. They were then asked about the maximum they would be willing to pay. In the case of cordless keyboards, people in the top 20% of social security numbers were willing to pay three times as much compared to those in the bottom 20%. The experiment demonstrates anchoring, a process whereby a numeric value provides a non-conscious reference point that influences subsequent value perceptions (Ariely, Loewenstein, & Prelec, 2003).

Nudge theory accepts that people have certain attitudes, knowledge, capabilities, etc., and allows for these factors (whereas autocratic methods ignore them). Nudge theory is based on understanding and allowing for the reality of situations and human tendencies (unlike traditional forcible instruction, which often ignores or discounts the reality of situations and people).

Fundamentally (and properly, according to its origins) Nudge theory operates by designing choices for people which encourage positive helpful decisions; for the people choosing, and ideally for the wider interests of society and environment, etc.

Additionally, Nudge theory offers a wonderful methodology for identifying, analysing and re-shaping existing choices and influences that people are given by governments, corporations, and other authorities. Given that so many of these choices and influences are extremely unhelpful for people, this is a major area of opportunity for the development and use of Nudge theory, even if it were not envisaged as such by its creators.

Nudge theory is very relevant to leadership, motivation,  change management, and many aspects of personal/self-development.


Related Solutions

As the nervous system develops(from embryonic to adult brain) would you expect to see any changes...
As the nervous system develops(from embryonic to adult brain) would you expect to see any changes in LTP induction? Explain why or why not?
1. Which is/are formed during the embryonic stage? Group of answer choices circulatory system alone brain...
1. Which is/are formed during the embryonic stage? Group of answer choices circulatory system alone brain alone major body organs digestive system alone 2. The brain forms during Group of answer choices the germinal phase the fetal stage birth and delivery the embryonic stage 3. Professor Misra is an evolutionary psychologist. To explain morning sickness, what statement would he make Group of answer choices "Morning sickness evolved to protect the embryo from poisonous foods." "Women who have morning sickness are...
Zachman Framework 1. What is the purpose of the architecture framework? 2. In what area the...
Zachman Framework 1. What is the purpose of the architecture framework? 2. In what area the architecture framework is used? 3. How to use the architecture framework? 4. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the architecture framework? 5. Select a minimum of 10 articles (journals or conference paper) published 5 years back. Analyze the articles. Identify and discuss what researches have been done related with architecture framework in the software design and architecture. You can summarize the analysis in...
1. Design and develop a fuzzy logic system for DC motor speed control a) Develop the...
1. Design and develop a fuzzy logic system for DC motor speed control a) Develop the input membership function based on error and change in error as inputs b) Formulate the rules for the fuzzy based DC motor speed control. c) Develop and test the fuzzy system using both Mamdani and Sugeno Methods.
Question 1 In the framework of monopolistic competition, which of the following is not a possible...
Question 1 In the framework of monopolistic competition, which of the following is not a possible outcome for a firm that runs a successful advertising campaign? Select the correct answer below: allocative efficiency the ability of the firm to charge a higher price the ability of the firm to sell a greater quantity an increase in profits for the firm Question 2 In a market characterized by monopolistic competition, how will new firms choose to engage this market? Select the...
1) In which organ the embryo nests and develops until its birth. a) Of the organ...
1) In which organ the embryo nests and develops until its birth. a) Of the organ mentioned in the previous paragraph, say its portions. b) Briefly explain the female sexual cycle.
The main pathway through which is the information is transfer and connected in the brain and nervous system is the spinal cord.
Spinal cord and its relation to the nervous systemThe main pathway through which is the information is transfer and connected in the brain and nervous system is the spinal cord.spinal cord is made of nervous tissue and its structure is like long, tubular and thin. It is elongated from the medulla oblongata region of the brain system till the vertebral column region of lumbar.The spinal cord helps the body in the following function like it help to control the blood...
Develop a 1- to 2-page case study analysis in which you: Based on the scenario. Explain...
Develop a 1- to 2-page case study analysis in which you: Based on the scenario. Explain why you think the patient presented the symptoms described. Identify the genes that may be associated with the development of the disease. Explain the process of immunosuppression and the effect it has on body systems. Scenario 3: A 34-year-old Hispanic-American male with end-stage renal disease received a kidney transplant from a cadaver donor, as no one in his family was a good match. His...
Consider the following system at equilibrium where H° = 87.9 kJ/mol, and Kc = 1.20×10-2 ,...
Consider the following system at equilibrium where H° = 87.9 kJ/mol, and Kc = 1.20×10-2 , at 500 K. PCl5 (g) PCl3 (g) + Cl2 (g) When 0.17 moles of PCl5 (g) are removed from the equilibrium system at constant temperature: the value of Kc A. increases. B. decreases. C. remains the same. the value of Qc A. is greater than Kc. B. is equal to Kc. C. is less than Kc. the reaction must: A. run in the forward...
Consider the following system at equilibrium where Kc = 1.29×10-2 and H° = 108 kJ/mol at...
Consider the following system at equilibrium where Kc = 1.29×10-2 and H° = 108 kJ/mol at 600 K. COCl2 (g) CO (g) + Cl2 (g) The production of CO (g) is favored by: Indicate True (T) or False (F) for each of the following: ___ T F 1. decreasing the temperature. ___ T F 2. increasing the pressure (by changing the volume). ___ T F 3. decreasing the volume. ___ T F 4. adding COCl2 . ___ T F 5....
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT