Question

In: Psychology

Describe similarities among the triplets from the film “Three Identical Strangers”, specifically how they were similar...

Describe similarities among the triplets from the film “Three Identical Strangers”, specifically how they were similar in their physical traits, personality traits and their upbringing/ environment.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The recently released documentary, Three Identical Strangers, tells a story that’s at times humorous, at times incredible, and at other times foreboding. The film, directed by Tim Wardle and released across the United States in the past few weeks, tells a story some might remember from headlines in the 1980s: Three college-aged identical triplets—Eddy Galland, David Kellman, and Robert Shafran—each put up for adoption, learn they were separated at birth and are reunited.

It is almost too good to be true. At the time, it was the kind of good news everyone wants to hear. Seeing the three hardy boys together, whether in New York Post photos, on prime-time TV shows, or in person at the Manhattan restaurant they ended up opening, was deeply heart-warming. Everyone wants to belong to a tribe; one can only imagine how powerful it must feel to find two other people who are immediate family; who have ties to you from before you knew; who literally reflect your likeness on their faces; and, who can give you a bear-hug as warm as your own, which you can all but imagine if you’ve ever seen photos of Eddy, David, and Bob together.

It’s a story of the power of nature and nurture. But it’s a story that quickly turns dark when one looks past the lighthearted headlines and comedic banter of TV show hosts, who note how the trio happens to like the same brand of cigarettes.

David was placed in an upper-class family with a doctor as his adoptive father; he experienced a rather reserved home life where his father was often unavailable. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Bob was placed in a working-class home with a grocery-store owner as a father who had a very warm and jovial disposition and later became affectionately called the Yiddish nickname “Bubula” by all three boys. Meanwhile, Eddy was placed in a middle-class family with a dad he often clashed with. A person close to the triplets said in the film, Eddy’s relationship with his dad “couldn’t have been good...otherwise, we would have seen him, or Eddy would have talked about him.”

As the brothers grew up, got married, and pursued their business endeavors, some coped better than others with the inevitable stressors in life that come up. After one of the brothers left their joint restaurant business, Eddy’s behavior became erratic and unpredictable, and he displayed manic-depressive symptoms. After receiving brief psychiatric care, he returned home. One morning, when he didn’t show up at work, a family member went to check the house and discovered that Eddy had shot himself. He was 33 years old.

After the tragedy, the surviving brothers couldn’t help but see differences in how they were raised and how it may have affected their life choices. The elderly father of Eddy even said, still in grief, “I often wondered if I didn’t teach him something…how to live life or something…that bothers me.”

Three Identical Strangers offers an empathic view of multiple perspectives throughout the film, but the most salient are those that caution viewers away from intentionally and unnecessarily dividing biological family members. The story clearly conveys how it never serves anyone well to unnecessarily mess with nature.



Related Solutions

Prove that among any six people, there are always three mutural acquaintances or three mutural strangers....
Prove that among any six people, there are always three mutural acquaintances or three mutural strangers. If among five people, can we still have such a conclusion?
From a physiological perspective how are salmon similar to/different from marathon runners (muscles specifically)
From a physiological perspective how are salmon similar to/different from marathon runners (muscles specifically)
describe the major differences and any similarities among these three frameworks (deonology, utilitarianism, and virtue ethics)
describe the major differences and any similarities among these three frameworks (deonology, utilitarianism, and virtue ethics)
describe how an insulating allocation promotes or discourages cooperation among managers. In your discussion, explain similarities...
describe how an insulating allocation promotes or discourages cooperation among managers. In your discussion, explain similarities and differences between the two allocation theories.
Describe three beliefs key beliefs of Jainism and/or Sikhism. How similar are these beliefs to those...
Describe three beliefs key beliefs of Jainism and/or Sikhism. How similar are these beliefs to those found in Hinduism?
Describe the three stages of planning. Explain how they are related. What is the relationship among...
Describe the three stages of planning. Explain how they are related. What is the relationship among corporate, business, and functional-level strategies, and how do they create value for an organization? What is the difference between vertical integration and related diversification?
Describe examples from the film that illustrate how racism imposes an additional health burden on people...
Describe examples from the film that illustrate how racism imposes an additional health burden on people of color. Give examples of both “everyday” racism (being treated unfairly) and “structural” racism (access to resources, power, status and wealth) and describe how these might affect health in different ways. What did the Macaque monkey research teach primatologist Carol Shively about the connections between power, subordination and health? What parallels can we draw to human society? What did we learn from the cortisol...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. Note that...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. Note that identical twins are genetically the “same” person. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group and this group participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child was placed in a control group where no training was provided. At the end of the program, each group was given a creative problem-solving test with the results...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group. These children participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child from each pair was part of the control group that did not participate in the program to promote creative thinking. At the end of the program, a creative problem-solving test was given, with the results shown in the...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group. These children participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child from each pair was part of the control group that did not participate in the program to promote creative thinking. At the end of the program, a creative problem-solving test was given, with the results shown in the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT