Should a defense attorney be allow to use insanity as a defense for murder? Is this...

Should a defense attorney be allow to use insanity as a defense for murder? Is this defense strategy overused? Provide an example of a crime in which the “act” is visible but the “intent” may not be as clear.

Solutions

Expert Solution

According to me a defence attorney shouldn't be allowed to use insanity as a defence for murder. Though this defence strategy is used again and again which means that it is overused but it shouldn't be used. Since murder is a very serious crime so for only the cause that the murderer is suffering from mental problem, murder can't be taken lightly or can't be considered logical. If the murderer was suffering from the mental problem it was the duty of his family members or the police to take care of him and not leave him free. So now if he had committed the crime he needs to be punished, now or after he recovered and can't be defended.

One example of a crime where the act is visible, but the intent is not visible may be- If a person hits another person by car and he is dead. In this case the crime is visible that the person hit him and he died. But the intent is not clear here as it may have happened accidently or he may have murdered him knowingly because he must be his enemy or he must have taken contract to kill him from some third person.

Rahul Sunny answered 3 weeks ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Is the Insanity Defense necessary? What form should it take and the role of the forensic...

Is the Insanity Defense necessary? What form should it take and the role of the forensic psychiatrist in establishing whether an accused person can successfully use it.

Is the Insanity Defense necessary? Discuss what form it should take and the role of the...

Is the Insanity Defense necessary? Discuss what form it should take and the role of the forensic psychiatrist in establishing whether an accused person can successfully use it.

What impact does the insanity defense have on the criminal justice system? (Provide reasons)

If you were a defense attorney, would you defend a foreign national who had been charged...

If you were a defense attorney, would you defend a foreign national who had been charged with human trafficking and sex slavery? He had been convicted of similar crimes in the past and had done time in prison twice. You have two teenage daughters yourself. He offered you cash for your service. What would you do? Why? Be sure to consider legal ethics when making your decision.

What is “collective defense?” If, when and how do you believe "collective defense" should be used?

Should there be a death penalty for first-degree murder cases? make an argument that either supports...

Should there be a death penalty for first-degree murder cases? make an argument that either supports or opposes the use of the death penalty in first-degree murder cases

1. What should an attorney for the defendant do when the defendant in a criminal case...

1. What should an attorney for the defendant do when the defendant in a criminal case wants to lie to the court when on the witness stand? 2. Suppose an attorney writes a check that bounces from the attorney’s trust bank account. What are the attorney’s ethical responses? How could the attorney have avoided the situation? 3. When an attorney is representing multiple clients in the same cause of action, how can an attorney ensure that there are no conflicts...

This format should allow you more time to think about your answer. You can also use...

This format should allow you more time to think about your answer. You can also use the readings to support your answer. Be sure to cite the author and page number for all quotes or ideas taken from one of the authors (e.g. Chang, p. 81). The length of your answers should range from 1-3 paragraphs, depending on the complexity of the question. Interest in Heterodox economics is increasing. What events have taken place to bring more attention to heterodox...

Please use IRAC format to answer this question. Bob is tired of working as an attorney...

Please use IRAC format to answer this question. Bob is tired of working as an attorney and decides to open a pet shop. Although Bob knows nothing about dogs, he decides to specialize in retrievers. Bob calls up Dog Breeder and orders 10 Black Labrador retrievers, 10 Chocolate Labrador retrievers, and 10 Yellow Labrador retrievers. All dogs are to be pure bred and male. Breeder mistakenly sends Bob 5 male and 5 female retrievers of each category. Bob does not...

When should a person execute a durable power of attorney? What preferences does an advance directive...

When should a person execute a durable power of attorney? What preferences does an advance directive establish? When is CPR indicated, and when is it not? How would you explain the statement that “CPR should not be the standard of care for the chronically ill resident of a long-term care facility”? Explain the difference between starvation and the malnutrition/dehydration of the dying process.

Subjects