Question

In: Psychology

What are the differences between people in preconventional, conventional, and principled levels of moral development?

What are the differences between people in preconventional, conventional, and principled levels of moral development?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Lawrence Kohlberg, developed a theory to understand the moral reasoning of individuals. Every individual goes through different stages of moral reasoning. Each stage has a different phase. Kohlberg introduced the theory to understand the rationale behind an individual's reasoning, when put in a moral dilemma. In his experiment, he constructed a hypothetical situation where an individual was asked how would have they made a moral decision if they were in place of the character in the story narrated to them. One such dilemma posed by Kohlberg was:

A man had a sick wife who was suffering from a rare kind of cancer. However, it was curable, but the drug that would have saved her was extremely expensive. The pharmacist insisted on selling it for $ 2,000 but the man had only $1,000 with him. The man told the pharmacist that he would pay him the money that he has now, and would pay the remaining amount in a few days. The pharmacist refused to budge into the man's plea. The man was so desperate to save his wife that he chose to steal the drug instead.

Individuals who were a part of the experiment were asked what should have the man done and why?

A child at the Preconventional stage of moral development, basis his moral decision or judgment on the repercussions that would follow. At this stage, a child says that the man should have not stolen the drug because it would lead to punishment. The rationale behind concluding the above is, a child l feels that actions that lead to positive reinforcements are good and the ones that lead to punishments are bad. The intention is not considered, it is about bad behaviour being unacceptable.

A child's ability to make judgments increases at the Coventional stage of moral development. At this stage they arrive to an understanding that the society runs according to some set norms, social orders and law. The child rationalised the doings of the man and concludes that 'it's alright for the man to steal because he would not be seen bad in the eyes of people, but if he does not save his wife, then he will never be able to look into anybody's eye again'.

In the last stage of moral development at the Postconventional level, Kohlberg suggested that most individuals enter adolescence and adulthood and it is at this stage an individual's ability to rationalise without any preconceived thoughts attached to society or law, increases. An individual arrives at a judgment that there wasn't anything wrong with the man stealing the drug for his wife as there is nothing above humanity.


Related Solutions

Explain how children reason in Kohlberg’s three levels of moral thought: preconventional moral thought, conventional moral...
Explain how children reason in Kohlberg’s three levels of moral thought: preconventional moral thought, conventional moral thought, and postconventional moral thought. For each level, report a) what children emphasize as important as their basis for their moral beliefs and b) provide an example from the Heinz dilemma that reflects that type of moral reasoning. Explain the roles of at least THREE of the following factors on gender role development: a) prenatal hormones, b) different socialization for boys and girls, c)...
At this stage of moral development people rely on society todetermine what rules and guidelines...
At this stage of moral development people rely on society to determine what rules and guidelines distinguish between right and wrong. As a result, in this stage of moral development, people believe that they are obligated to obey the rules, which creates a stable and functioning society.A Law and order.B Punishment, avoidance and obedience.C Social contractD Universal ethical principleEthics becomes a more complicated issue when a situation dictates that one value overrules others. An ethical dilemma is a situation, problem,...
What are the differences between cognitive and psychosocial development
What are the differences between cognitive and psychosocial development
What are the similarities and differences between the conventional waterfall model and the Unified Process model?...
What are the similarities and differences between the conventional waterfall model and the Unified Process model? Identify and explain three advantages and three disadvantages of each of these two models. combines below questions together too Explain in an essay why the waterfall process is a process for solving tame problems. also Explain in an essay how agile development tackles application software development as a wicked problem.
Distinguish between adult and embryonic stem cells. What are the moral differences between adult and embryonic...
Distinguish between adult and embryonic stem cells. What are the moral differences between adult and embryonic stem cells? Are there any moral problems with adult stem cell research?
What are the differences between basal, activated, and repressed levels of transcription of a gene?
What are the differences between basal, activated, and repressed levels of transcription of a gene?
Discuss the differences between Takaful and conventional insurance. ( in 100 words)
Discuss the differences between Takaful and conventional insurance. ( in 100 words)
Kohlberg's Three Levels of Morality This week’s lecture focused on moral development and ethical reasoning. As...
Kohlberg's Three Levels of Morality This week’s lecture focused on moral development and ethical reasoning. As part of your readings for the week, Kohlberg’s three levels of morality were discussed. How would you have answered Heinz’s dilemma? (See readings for the week for the full dilemma). Which of Kohlberg’s three levels of morality do you feel you are in? Do you feel you are in a different level of morality in different settings (i.e. work vs. personal life?) How has...
Kohlberg's Three Levels of Morality This week’s lecture focused on moral development and ethical reasoning. As...
Kohlberg's Three Levels of Morality This week’s lecture focused on moral development and ethical reasoning. As part of your readings for the week, Kohlberg’s three levels of morality were discussed. How would you have answered Heinz’s dilemma? (See readings for the week for the full dilemma). Which of Kohlberg’s three levels of morality do you feel you are in? Do you feel you are in a different level of morality in different settings (i.e. work vs. personal life?) How has...
2. a) What are the differences between Conventional Commercial Bank and Islamic Commercial Bank? 4 b)...
2. a) What are the differences between Conventional Commercial Bank and Islamic Commercial Bank? 4 b) How does Islamic Bank contribute to socio-economic development? 6
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT