In: Operations Management
Scott writes a software program for Central Bank that, when installed, makes Central’s computers crash. Central loses all of its customers’ data in the crash. The bank’s employees, including Cara, work overtime to reenter the data. As a consequence, Cara is late to pick up her brother James at the intersection of First Avenue and Main Street. While waiting for the ride, James is injured on being hit by a truck driven by Warren when the truck’s brake fails. To collect for his injury, James files a suite against Scott. Discuss whether Scott is a cause-in-fact and a proximate cause of James' injury.
Scott writes a software program for Central Bank that, when installed, makes Central’s computers crash. Central loses all of its customers’ data in the crash. The bank’s employees, including Cara, work overtime to reenter the data. As a consequence, Cara is late to pick up her brother James at the intersection of First Avenue and Main Street. While waiting for the ride, James is injured on being hit by a truck driven by Warren when the truck’s brake fails. To collect for his injury, James files a suit against Scott. Discuss whether Scott is a cause-in-fact and a proximate cause of James' injury.
ANSWER:
As I would see it, Scott is a proximate reason for James' physical issue. This is on the grounds that however James was harmed on being hit by a truck driven by Warren when the truck's brake failed, yet the lawful and genuine reason for James injury was Scott who composed a product program for Central Bank which slammed and focal lost the entirety of its clients' information in the accident because of which Cara needed to stay at work longer than required to reemerge the information which made her late to get her sibling James. Since Cara couldn't be there on schedule, she was unable to save James from the mishap for which Scott is at risk.