Is the happiness of the greater number (as Mill conceives it) a good criterion for judging...

Is the happiness of the greater number (as Mill conceives it) a good criterion for judging right and wrong actions?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The happiness of the greater number is not a good criterion for judging right and wrong actions. Because happiness is the consequence of the action but that is not the procedure of action. We must consider the procedure to judge the action. What if we followed the wrong procedure to produce happiness for the greater number? For example: Are you ready to lie to save 10 criminals and kill one good person. Probably nobody is ready for that. But utilitarians will do that and how stupid they are. That's why the happiness of the greater number is not a good criterion for judging right and wrong actions.

We must consider how sincerely the person doing that action rather than considering happiness in output. Because most of the time, we don't have any control over our consequences. We only have control over our sincerity. So that we must consider the sincerity of the person. This concept is explained by Immanuel Kant in his categorical imperative theory. I vote categorical imperative theory rather than utilitarianism because it is considering the sincerity of the person.

Hayet Jeridi answered 8 months ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

In general the greater the number of Substitutes a good has... a. The More Normal the...

In general the greater the number of Substitutes a good has... a. The More Normal the good is in terms of Income Elasticity of Demand b. The more negative the Cross Price Elasticity of Demand will be c. The More Inelastic it is in terms of Price Elasticity of Demand d. The More Elastic it is in terms of Price Elasticity of Demand

Do you believe that working at Lowell Mill was a good position for a female in...

Do you believe that working at Lowell Mill was a good position for a female in the 1830's? Why or why not? Many of the mill girls were working to help support the education of a male family member. How do you think this affected their attitude towards work and their working conditions?

Which of the following claims about the relationship between a good will and happiness does Kant...

Which of the following claims about the relationship between a good will and happiness does Kant agree with? (Select all that apply.) It is not worth cultivating a good will if it gets in the way of being happy. All persons with a good will have lives that are happy. No one who is happy can possibly have a good will. A good will is the condition of the worthiness to be happy. A good will is good in itself,...

What is the biological rationale for parsimony to use as an optimality criterion the minimum number...

What is the biological rationale for parsimony to use as an optimality criterion the minimum number of changes? Please provide your answer in the form of a written statement.

What are number of lanes required to meet the criterion of LOS B for a new...

What are number of lanes required to meet the criterion of LOS B for a new 3.5 km segment of undivided multilane highway, if design hour volume is 70000 v/h, 85 km/h speed limit, peak hour volume is 20% of daily traffic, the terrain is level, PHF= 0.8, and 2.2 m lateral , 15 access points in the segment, SRV 5% trucks, 3%clearance from the right edge.

For any given price, the more elastic is the demand for a good, the greater will...

For any given price, the more elastic is the demand for a good, the greater will be the consumer surplus. Select one: True False A free good will be consumed up to the point at which its marginal utility is positive. Select one: True False As price falls along the demand curve for pretzels, _____. Select one: a. consumer surplus remains unchanged b. consumer surplus decreases c. total utility decreases d. consumer expenditure changes e. marginal utility increases Arnold is...

If the tax is imposed on a good where the elasticity of demand is greater than...

If the tax is imposed on a good where the elasticity of demand is greater than elasticity of supply show with the help of an illustration whether the producer or consumer will bear greater burden of the tax.

A prime number (or prime) is a natural number greater than 1 that has no posítive...

A prime number (or prime) is a natural number greater than 1 that has no posítive divisors other than 1 and itself. Write a Python program which takes a set of positive numbers from the input and returns the sum of the prime numbers in the given set. The sequence will be ended with a negative number.

A number of different capital budgeting decision criterion were presented. Which one has a tendancy to...

A number of different capital budgeting decision criterion were presented. Which one has a tendancy to favor projects with a shorter life? Internal rate of return Profitability index Payback period Net present value Average accounting return

A prime number is an integer greater than 1 that is evenlydivisible by only 1...

A prime number is an integer greater than 1 that is evenly divisible by only 1 and itself. For example, the number 5 is prime because it can only be evenly divided by 1 and 5. The number 6, however, is not prime because it can be divided by 1, 2, 3, and 6.Write a Boolean function named isPrime, which takes an integer as an argument and returns true if the argument is a prime number, and false otherwise. Demonstrate...

Subjects