Suppose you read the following headline: “Taking an aspirin a day can cut your risk of...

Suppose you read the following headline: “Taking an aspirin a day can cut your risk of heart attack by almost half!” Suppose the news report goes on to tell you that the research is based on a very large well-designed randomized experiment with a p-value less than 0.0001. Assume this information is technically correct, given the results of the study. Which of the following statistics could actually represent the results of this study?

The rates of heart attack were 9.4 per thousand for the aspirin group and 17.1 per thousand for the placebo group (non aspirin).

94 people in the aspirin group had a heart attack, compared to 171 people in the non-aspirin group.

The risk of a heart attack for the aspirin group was 45% of the risk of a heart attack for the non-aspirin group.

Any of the above could have been possible.

Answer is: any of above are possible. Please explain why as that is what I am confused on.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Since the p value for the test “Taking an aspirin a day can cut your risk of heart attack by almost half!” is 0.0001

that means the result is almost sure

The rates of heart attack were 9.4 per thousand for the aspirin group and 17.1 per thousand for the placebo group (non aspirin).

Here, if you will calculate people taking aspirin / people not taking aspirin = 9.4/17.1 = 0.549

Which is close to 0.5 ( as in hypothesis certain range around the hypothesized value is accepted )

94 people in the aspirin group had a heart attack, compared to 171 people in the non-aspirin group.

Again take the ratio taking aspirin / people not taking aspirin = 94/171 = 0.549

Which is close to 0.5 ( as in hypothesis certain range around the hypothesized value is accepted )

The risk of a heart attack for the aspirin group was 45% of the risk of a heart attack for the non-aspirin group

Here 45% mean = 0.45 again the number closed to 0.5

Which is close to 0.5 ( as in hypothesis certain range around the hypothesized value is accepted )

In all the three scenario the ratio is close to 0.5

orchestra answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Suppose you’re a doctor and you read a headline in a newspaper that says a particular...

Suppose you’re a doctor and you read a headline in a newspaper that says a particular dietary supplement decreases blood pressure with p = 0.01. The supplement is generally safe but sometimes causes unpleasant side effects. Assuming this is all you know, answer the questions below. a) What does this headline mean? Incorporate the definition of p-value into your answer. b) Should you recommend the supplement to patients with high blood pressure? Why or why not? Give at least two...

Prove the following MST algorithm is correct. You can use the cut property in your proof...

Prove the following MST algorithm is correct. You can use the cut property in your proof if you want, but it's not clear it's the best approach sort the edges according to their weights for each edge e ∈ E, in decreasing order of weight : if e is part of a cycle of G: G = G − e (that is, remove e from G) return G

Suppose that one day you read a news story reporting that result of a survey indicate...

Suppose that one day you read a news story reporting that result of a survey indicate that 40% of women and 30% of men have little or no interest in sex . How could you use critical thinking to interpret this report? What kinds of questions would you ask about the source of the data, the way the study was conducted ,and the background of the participants?

Suppose one day after taking care of some errands, you friend reached home in the evening....

Suppose one day after taking care of some errands, you friend reached home in the evening. After she got home, her sister asked “Where have you been?! We were worried sick about you! We couldn’t reach you through your phone and some very embarrassing and uncomfortable contents are being shared from your facebook account!” After hearing that she quickly searched her bag for her phone but it wasn’t there. She realized at some point of the day, her phone went...

a. You sprained your ankle. What two things can be done to aspirin to reduce stomach...

a. You sprained your ankle. What two things can be done to aspirin to reduce stomach bleeding and explain why it works. b. Explain how taking Aspirin reduces one's risk of heart attacks. NOTE: Include in your answer the physiology of the systems involved. HOW? The salicylic portion of aspirin INHIBITS the synthesis of PROSTAGLANDINS by INHIBITING CYCLOOXYGENASE - this does not allow prostaglandin to do its job - blood clotting (plateletts aggregate). c. What is the general relationship between...

Your day as the chair of the FED: Suppose you are appointed as the chair of...

Your day as the chair of the FED: Suppose you are appointed as the chair of the US Federal Reserve. “With the sole goal of stabilizing output”, explain how and why you would change the interest rate in response to the following shocks. Show the effects on the economy in the short run using the IS-MP diagram. Be sure to discuss what changes in the model specifically. Provide detailed intuitive explanation in words as well. (You can assume that the...

Q#5 Design an experiment to answer the following question: Does aspirin keep cut roses fresher longer?...

Q#5 Design an experiment to answer the following question: Does aspirin keep cut roses fresher longer? 1. What is your hypothesis? 2. What is your experimental group? 3. What is your control group? 4. Discuss how you will perform the experiment. What is your independent variable? What is your dependent variable?

1)Suppose you own a cupcake bakery. Your revenue is $400/day and your operating costs are $100/day....

1)Suppose you own a cupcake bakery. Your revenue is $400/day and your operating costs are $100/day. If you could make $300/day bartending for someone else, then economic profits of your cupcake bakery are $__________ and your accounting profits are $__________ . a $0; $0 b $0; $300 c $100; $0 d $100; $100 2) A bakery can produce 150 donuts per hour when they hire 10 workers and 165 donuts per hour when they hire 11 workers. Based on this...

Suppose that the market can be described by the following threesources of systematic risk with...

Suppose that the market can be described by the following three sources of systematic risk with associated risk premiums.FactorRisk PremiumIndustrial production (I)8%Interest rates (R)4%Consumer confidence (C)7%The return on a particular stock is generated according to the following equation:r = 17% + 0.9I + 0.5R + 0.70C +ea-1. Find the equilibrium rate of return on this stock using the APT. The T-bill rate is 3%. (Do not round intermediate calculations. Round your answer to 1 decimal place.)a-2. Is the stock over-...

If a hurricane was headed your way, would you evacuate? The headline of a press release...

If a hurricane was headed your way, would you evacuate? The headline of a press release states, "Thirty-two Percent of People on High-Risk Coast Will Refuse Evacuation Order, Survey of Hurricane Preparedness Finds." This headline was based on a survey of 5237 adults who live within 20 miles of the coast in high hurricane risk counties of eight southern states. In selecting the sample, care was taken to ensure that the sample would be representative of the population of coastal...

Subjects