Question

In: Operations Management

Consulting firm Deloitte works with many organizations to improve their business practices. Recently, the firm looked...

Consulting firm Deloitte works with many organizations to improve their business practices. Recently, the firm looked at its own internal processes and determined that its performance management system needed some new life. With over 65,000 employees to rate, the goal was to make the process faster, continuous, and simpler. After gathering information on its current practice and investigating the science behind performance evaluation, Deloitte came up with a revolutionary way forward.

The current practice was a traditional method of cascading objectives from the organizational strategic level down to the individual contributor level. Managers would rate each employee at the end of a rating period based on how well he or she met those objectives. However, annual goal-setting did not coincide with business operations schedules, and the process consumed nearly 2 million hours a year. Since Deloitte is in the business of improving efficiencies and productivities for clients, it only made sense to radically change its own performance management system.

The science behind evaluations shows that ratings are often affected by unconscious rater biases and perceptions rather than factual performance outcomes. Deloitte’s employees often work in teams, and individuals believe that they are able to use their skills and strengths effectively at work. The firm’s new approach asks team leaders to specify what future actions they plan to take regarding each member of the team. This shift in thinking recognizes that raters’ assessments of performance may be inaccurate, but the way they plan to work with someone in the future says more about that individual’s actual performance.

Team leaders now report their future-oriented intentions, from endorsing that they would like to keep the individual on their team to recommending that the individual poses a performance risk that might endanger client relationships or team performance. Since an essential component of performance management is to facilitate improvements in performance, team leaders now check in with each team member once a week to review project status and priorities, provide feedback on recently completed work, and provide any needed course corrections. This frequent communication is initiated by the team member rather than the leader. In this way, each individual takes ownership of their performance and seeks out feedback and input on their performance. Deloitte has moved away from assigning each employee a single performance rating score in favor of ongoing feedback.

Questions

  1. What is your overall opinion of Deloitte’s new approach to performance management? What type of training would you recommend for managers, team leaders, and team members before switching to a system like this?

  2. What actions should be taken if an employee is ranked as a potential performance risk? How would compensation decisions be made without a performance score for each employee?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer = If we look at the present performance management approach of the company, it seems that the company is more driven by the motive of gaining the greater customer relationship experience and it is more directed towards the development of the team goals with the help of consulting with the team leaders so that they can be a common area between the expectation of the management and the expected performance by the team leader. The new system is more practical as the team leaders are responsible for managing their own teams and thus they must be given free hand during establishing the team goals and selection of the team members.

Before switching to the new system it is important that the managers and team leaders are given intense training on the measurement of the performance, determining the team goals, and how to judge the performance of the employees on regular basis.

Answer= If a certain employee is characterized as the potential performance risk, it is important tom train that employee on those areas where he is lacking or where the improvement is desired. The team leader needs to facilitate the expected feedback about his performance and how the performance can be improved.

In this situation, in place of the individual compensation plan, the organization can think of implementing the team-based compensation plan that will motivate the entire team and ensure that all the members of the team are putting their efforts.


Related Solutions

Marshall Inc. recently hired your consulting firm to improve thecompany's performance. It has been highly...
Marshall Inc. recently hired your consulting firm to improve the company's performance. It has been highly profitable but has been experiencing cash shortages due to its high growth rate. As one part of your analysis, you want to determine the firm's cash conversion cycle. Using the following information and a 365-day year, what is the firm's present cash conversion cycle?Average inventory = $75,000Annual sales = $600,000Annual cost of goods sold = $360,000Average accounts receivable = $180,000Average accounts payable = $54,000
Marshall Inc. recently hired your consulting firm to improve the company's performance. It has been highly...
Marshall Inc. recently hired your consulting firm to improve the company's performance. It has been highly profitable but has been experiencing cash shortages due to its high growth rate. As one part of your analysis, you want to determine the firm's cash conversion cycle. Using the following information and a 365 day year, what is the firm's present cash conversion cycle? Enter your answer rounded to two decimal places. For example, if your answer is 123.45% or 1.2345 then enter...
scenario You are a successful software development consultant in a large consulting firm (e.g. Deloitte, EY,...
scenario You are a successful software development consultant in a large consulting firm (e.g. Deloitte, EY, KPMG, PWC, Boston Consulting Group). Given your success as a knowledgeable and creative software development professional, your portfolio of clients has grown to include a diverse range of organisations. These include large multi-national companies and government agencies through to small to medium sized enterprises (SMEs). Part A Short Answer Questions Part A includes 9 questions. You should attempt all the questions (5 marks for...
THE CASE: Kaizer Consulting Kaizer Consulting is an international management consulting firm that specializes in business...
THE CASE: Kaizer Consulting Kaizer Consulting is an international management consulting firm that specializes in business strategy and serves as a key advisor to the world’s leading companies. It provides its clients with the unique insight to drive critical decision-making and solve their most pressing problems. Every year, the majority of Kaizer’s business comes from clients with whom they have worked in the previous year – an indicator of Kaizer’s ability to achieve lasting results for its clients. Kaizer’s client...
You have recently been employed by a consulting firm as a management accounting specialist. The firm...
You have recently been employed by a consulting firm as a management accounting specialist. The firm specialises in the provision of information to companies that have discrete, short term problems. Your first assignment is to a company called Malvern who specialises in construction equipment and is having trouble identifying the reasons for volatility in the profitability of its main product: The Hammer. The managers of Malvern are aware that there are a number of factors which are potentially causing them...
A consulting firm hired you to improve the network security of a Hospital by adding extra...
A consulting firm hired you to improve the network security of a Hospital by adding extra services for defence against external attacks. 1. In order to protect classified encrypted data from disclosure and transmission outside of the Hospital network, you need to choose among the following: proper configuration of DMZ, use of strong encryption algorithms, safeguards over keys. State your selection and justify your choice. 2. You want to use a packet firewall to protect the Hospital network but you...
A consulting firm hired you to improve the network security of a Hospital by adding extra...
A consulting firm hired you to improve the network security of a Hospital by adding extra services for defence against external attacks. 1. In order to protect classified encrypted data from disclosure and transmission outside of the Hospital network, you need to choose among the following: proper configuration of DMZ, use of strong encryption algorithms, safeguards over keys. State your selection and justify your choice. 2. You want to use a packet firewall to protect the Hospital network but you...
Mr. D works full-time as a systems analyst for a consulting firm. In addition, he sells...
Mr. D works full-time as a systems analyst for a consulting firm. In addition, he sells plants that he raises himself in a greenhouse attached to his residence. During the past 5 years, the results from raising and selling the plants have been as follows: Year Net Profit (Loss) from Scenario 1: Scenario 1 Year 1         (2,000) Year 2         (1,200) Year 3          1,000 Year 4          2,500 Total Years 1-4             300 Year 5            (500) 2....
Mr. D works full-time as a systems analyst for a consulting firm. In addition, he sells...
Mr. D works full-time as a systems analyst for a consulting firm. In addition, he sells plants that he raises himself in a greenhouse attached to his residence. During the past 5 years, the results from raising and selling the plants have been as follows: Year Net Profit (Loss) from Scenario 1: Scenario 1 Year 1         (2,000) Year 2         (1,200) Year 3          1,000 Year 4          2,500 Total Years 1-4             300 Year 5            (500) 2....
1.Jones works for a consulting firm and gets remunerated a monthly wage of $500.00. He always...
1.Jones works for a consulting firm and gets remunerated a monthly wage of $500.00. He always spends all the $500.00 on buying 5kg of potatoes  only which he buys at $100/kg. One day, amidst of Covid 19 pandemic, the price of potatoes increased to $120/kg. Due to the snap change in the price, Jones supervisor approached him and gave him two options to choose from: i). Reduce Jones wage to $400.00 and supplying him with 30kg of potatoes at $80/kg monthly....
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT