Question

In: Accounting

(This is a law/legal related question, the answer must be based on IRAC model) QUESTION THREE...

(This is a law/legal related question, the answer must be based on IRAC model)

QUESTION THREE

“Judges don’t make law, they only apply it”.

REQUIRED:

Discuss this statement using case examples.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The view that “judges don’t make law, they just apply the law to the facts,” appears simply preposterous to one who has studied the Anglo-American common law system. Certainly judges “make law,” chiefly judges who sit on courts of last resort.

A clear line does not exist, but the main disagreement appears to be more on the extremes, not at the blurry middle. Not, for example, when a judge interprets the meaning of the words in a statute, attempts to determine legislative intent, or when he applies the broad requirements of the constitution to policy questions frequently presented to courts; but rather when judges rely on the “invisible constitution” and inherent or implied rights to push the law where it perhaps needs to go, but hasn’t quite reached.

Case Law Example in Civil Lawsuit Against Child Services

In 1996, the Nevada Division of Child and Family Services (“DCFS”) removed a 12-year old boy from his home to protect him from the horrible physical and sexual abuse he had suffered in his home, and to prevent him from abusing other children in the home. The boy was placed in an emergency foster home, and was later shifted around within the foster care system. The DCFS social worker in charge of the boy’s case had the boy made a ward of DCFS, and in her 6-month report to the court, the worker elaborated on the boy’s sexual abuse history, and stated that she planned to move him from a facility into a “more homelike setting.” The court approved her plan.

In 1997, the boy was placed into the home of John and Jane Roe as a foster child. Although the couple had two young children of their own at home, the social worker did not tell them about the boy’s history of both being abused, and abusing other children. When she made her report to the court the following day, the worker reported the boy’s placement in the Roe’s home, but didn’t mention that the couple had young children. She did note that the boy still needed extensive therapy in order to cope with his abusive past, and “to reach the point of being safe with other children.” The boy was receiving counseling with a DCFS therapist. Again, the court approved of the actions.

The Roes accompanied the boy to his therapy sessions. When they were told of the boy’s past, they asked if their children were safe with him in their home. The therapist assured them that they had nothing to worry about. Unfortunately, that was not true. Just two months after being placed with the Roe family, the Roe’s son told his parents that the boy had molested him. The boy was arrested two days later, and admitted to having sexually molested the couple’s son several times.

On June 16, 1999, a lawsuit was filed on behalf of the boy by a guardian ad litem, against DCFS, the social worker, and the therapist. A similar lawsuit was also filed on behalf of the Roe’s victimized son by a different guardian ad litem. The defendants petitioned the trial court for a dismissal based on absolute immunity, as they were all acting in their jobs with DCFS. If granted absolute immunity, the parties would not only be protected from liability in the matter, but could not be answerable in any way for their actions. When the court delayed making such a ruling, the defendants took their request to the appellate court.

In determining whether employees of DCFS are entitled to absolute immunity, which is generally held by certain government officials acting within the scope of their employment, the appellate court referred to case law previously rendered on similar cases. The appellate court determined that the trial court had not erred in its decision to allow more time for information to be gathered by the parties – specifically regarding the issue of absolute immunity.

Please give the good feedback(Thumbup)


Related Solutions

Contract law?using IRAC method to answer the question. David owns a music store. He wants to...
Contract law?using IRAC method to answer the question. David owns a music store. He wants to encourage more customers to visit the store so he decides that he will put in massage chairs for customers to use when listening the samples of music. David enters a contract where he will hire 5 massage chairs from Emily for a price of $300/month for six months. Three months later, David discovers that the massage chairs are not bringing any additional business. David...
describe the relationship of the principles of law, ethics, and the legal system as related to...
describe the relationship of the principles of law, ethics, and the legal system as related to the U. S. public healthcare system
Please answer the multiple choice question. Only choose one answer choice. Then write an IRAC answer...
Please answer the multiple choice question. Only choose one answer choice. Then write an IRAC answer about the issue that is being tested. Peter built a small pond in front of his house for his prize koi fish. The pond was visible from the sidewalk. To keep people and animals away, Peter constructed an eight-foot high chain link fence between the sidewalk and the pond. One day, Stewie, a six-year­ old who lived next door, struggled over the fence to...
Based on the following facts stated below draft an IRAC answer on the torts you identify...
Based on the following facts stated below draft an IRAC answer on the torts you identify and Make sure your answer is following the IRAC format. Art attended a backyard party at Barb’s house where friends from his class were celebrating their college graduation. While Barb was grilling steaks in the corner of her backyard, smoke from the grill drifted into the adjacent yard of her neighbor Carol, irritating Carol’s eyes and causing her to suffer a painful cough. Carol...
Answer the following question in the IRAC format: Jean operated a restaurant in a building her...
Answer the following question in the IRAC format: Jean operated a restaurant in a building her son Sal owned in Oswego County, New York. Jean intentionally burned down her son’s building so that her son could collect the insurance money. Sal had nothing to do with causing this fire. The insurance company paid Sal and commenced a legal action against Jean to get the money back it paid to Sal. Jean obtained a personal loan of $20,000 from Key Bank...
Please use IRAC format to answer this question. Bob is tired of working as an attorney...
Please use IRAC format to answer this question. Bob is tired of working as an attorney and decides to open a pet shop. Although Bob knows nothing about dogs, he decides to specialize in retrievers. Bob calls up Dog Breeder and orders 10 Black Labrador retrievers, 10 Chocolate Labrador retrievers, and 10 Yellow Labrador retrievers. All dogs are to be pure bred and male. Breeder mistakenly sends Bob 5 male and 5 female retrievers of each category. Bob does not...
IRAC must be followed in answering each question. Perhaps, multiple IRACs may have to be used...
IRAC must be followed in answering each question. Perhaps, multiple IRACs may have to be used in answering one question, in case of multiple issues. 12. Oliver contracted with an insurance company to insure his apartment for $100K against loss by fire. The company policy provided that “the proceeds shall be payable only if Oliver gives written notice of any loss within 20 days after its occurrence.” A fire destroyed the building, but Oliver gave his notice after a month...
Busines LAW - Privacy and Personal Rights (ANSWER IRAC FORMAT) Beth IsraelMedicalCenter (BI) email policy stated:...
Busines LAW - Privacy and Personal Rights (ANSWER IRAC FORMAT) Beth IsraelMedicalCenter (BI) email policy stated: All information and documents created, received, saved or sent on the MedicalCenter’s computer of communications systems are the property of the MedicalCenter. Employees have no personal privacy right on any material created, received, saved or sent using Medical Center communication or computer systems.  The MedicalCenterreserves the right to access and disclose such material at any time without prior notice. Dr. Norman Scott was head of...
Answer the following question in IRAC form: Hank worked for HGC Corporation as the Treasurer. Before...
Answer the following question in IRAC form: Hank worked for HGC Corporation as the Treasurer. Before leaving the Corporation Hank embezzled $500,000 from HGC. Thus far Clarence, the Chairman of the Board and Hank's uncle, has kept the Board from "going after" Hank. Only a year remains in the statute of limitations before HGC can not legally pursue action against Hank. A) Allison is a shareholder. She and other shareholders come to you for advice as to what they may...
BUSINESS LAW (critical thinking legal question) Proffesional products, inc. (PPI), bought three pallets of computer wafers...
BUSINESS LAW (critical thinking legal question) Proffesional products, inc. (PPI), bought three pallets of computer wafers from Omneon Video Graphics. (A computer wafer is a thin, round slice of silicon from which microchips are made) Omneon agreed to ship the wafers to the City University of New York “FOB Omneon’s dock”. Shipment was arranged through Haas Industries, Inc. The “conditions of carriage” on the back of the bill of lading stated that Haas’s liability for lost goods was limited to...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT