Question

In: Economics

Does Modern Monetary Theory prove that budget deficits are not of concern to the longterm health...

Does Modern Monetary Theory prove that budget deficits are not of concern to the longterm health of the economy? Explain.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Modern Monetary Theory adopst an older view, known as the endogenous money theory, that rejects the idea that there’s a supply of loanable funds out there that private businesses and governments compete over. Instead, they believe that loans by banks themselves create money in accordance with market demands for money, meaning there isn’t a firm trade-off between loaning to governments and loaning to businesses of a kind that forces interest rates to rise when governments borrow too much.

MMTers go beyond endogenous money theory, however, and argue that government should never have to default so long as it’s sovereign in its currency: that is, so long as it issues and controls the kind of money it taxes and spends. The US government, for instance, can’t go bankrupt because that would mean it ran out of dollars to pay creditors; but it can’t run out of dollars, because it is the only agency allowed to create dollars. It would be like a bowling alley running out of points to give players.

A consequence of this view, and of MMTers’ understanding of how the mechanics of government taxing and spending work, is that taxes and bonds do not and indeed cannotdirectly pay for spending. Instead, the government creates money whenever it spends.

The purpose of bond issuances is to prevent interest rates in the private economy from falling too low. When the government spends, they argue, that adds more money to private bank accounts and increases the amount of “reserves” (cash the bank has stocked away, not lent out) in the banking system. The reserves earn a very low interest rate, pushing down interest rates overall. If the Fed wants higher interest rates, it will sell Treasury bonds to banks. Those Treasury bonds earn higher interest than the reserves, pushing overall interest rates higher.

But the basic upshot of all this is that taxing less than the government spends, and issuing bonds in tandem, isn’t a problem under most prevailing circumstances, per MMT. The main constraint on government deficits is inflation, but at a time like now when inflation is low, that’s not a serious concern.

When the US is importing more stuff than it exports (as is normally the case), and the domestic US economy is overwhelmed with debt that it’s trying to get rid of (as was the case after the 2008 crash, as private homeowners and others were left underwater), the government, as a matter of arithmetic, has to run deficits if it wants to help the private sector recover. the 2001 recession was the result of the US fiscal surplus at that time forcing the private sector into deficit: “In most advanced economies, sharp, severe economic downturns typically follow a period when fiscal surpluses are accompanied by large private sector deficits.

In the long term,the only sustainable position is for the private domestic sector to be in surplus. As long as the US runs a current account deficit with other countries, that means the government budget has to be in deficit. It isn’t “crowding out” investment in the private sector, but enabling it.


Related Solutions

How does expansionary monetary policy affect the economy in theory?
How does expansionary monetary policy affect the economy in theory?
.According to the credit channel theory of monetary policy transmission, how does expansionary monetary policy affect...
.According to the credit channel theory of monetary policy transmission, how does expansionary monetary policy affect adverse selection problems in credit markets? Explain.  
Comment on the theory underlying the use of a monetary rule by the Federal Reserve. Does...
Comment on the theory underlying the use of a monetary rule by the Federal Reserve. Does the use of such a rule seem appropriate under current economic conditions? Explain.
Modern microeconomics, specifically consumer theory, is based on utility theory—consumers maximize their utility. Where does our...
Modern microeconomics, specifically consumer theory, is based on utility theory—consumers maximize their utility. Where does our modern conception of utility theory come from? (Hint: there are multiple sources.) What is the empirical basis for utility theory? Can utility theory be considered scientific according to Karl Popper’s conception of science? How about Kuhn or Lakatos? What are the criticisms of utility theory and how would its supporters (e.g., Gary Becker) respond? Are there any alternative paradigms? What are the flaws/limitations in...
Present the "monetary rule" of the Monetarists. How does this rule depend on the Quantity Theory...
Present the "monetary rule" of the Monetarists. How does this rule depend on the Quantity Theory of Money?
Present the "monetary rule" of the Monetarists. How does this rule depend on the Quantity Theory...
Present the "monetary rule" of the Monetarists. How does this rule depend on the Quantity Theory of Money?
A full page answer Where does our modern conception of utility theory come from?
A full page answer Where does our modern conception of utility theory come from?
Does expansionary monetary policy impact the federal budget? Briefly explain why or why not.
Does expansionary monetary policy impact the federal budget? Briefly explain why or why not.
How does the theorist Madeleine Leininger's view each of the four phenomena of concern? (Person, Health,...
How does the theorist Madeleine Leininger's view each of the four phenomena of concern? (Person, Health, Environment & Nursing) Please explain the theorist's view of each phenomenon of concern on a separate slide with at least three bullet points on each slide. For instance, if you are talking about the theorist's view on person, use one slide with at least three bullet points.
How does the Generalized Comparative Advantage (Modern Theory of International Trade) differ from David Ricardo’s classical Principle of Comparative Advantage?
How does the Generalized Comparative Advantage (Modern Theory of International Trade) differ from David Ricardo’s classical Principle of Comparative Advantage? 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT