In: Finance
Project Size Rate of Return
A $1M 12%
B $2M 11.5%
C $2M 11.2%
D $2M 11%
E $1M 10.7%
F $1M 10.3%
G $1M 10.2%
Which set of projects should be accepted:
Please note the solution:
1) Bond Market Price Calculation
> Formula
Price = Coupen Amount * PVAF (r, n) + Face Value * PVIF (r, n)
where, PVAF = Present Value annuity factor at "r " rate of interest for "n" period
PVIF = Present Value interest factor at "r " rate of interest for "n" period
Price = [ 1000 * 7% ] * PVAF (10%, 25) + 1000 * PVIF (10%, 25)
= 70 * [ 1/1.1 + 1/(1.1)2 + 1/(1.1)3 + 1/(1.1)4 + ..... +1/(1.1)25 ] + 1000 * [1 / (1.1)25]
= 70 * 9.07704 + 1000 * 0.0923
= $ 727.69
Option b is correct.
b) Expected return - Preferred stock
> Formula = [ Expected Dividend / Issue Price ]
> Calculation
Cost = 10 / 200
= 5%
Option (e) is correct
c) While calculating WACC, cost of preferred stock, common stock, retained earnings and debt is considered only. But the Net capital spending/capital expenditure is not considered.
Hence option (e) is the answer.
d) Cost of equity calculation
> Formula = [ D1 / P0 ] + g
> Calculation = [ 1.45 / 22.50 ] + 0.065
= 0.1294 or 12.94 %
Option (d) is correct
e) Decision rule : The project whose rate of return is more than the WACC will be selected. Becaused project with lower required return than WACC will lead to Negative NPV and hence not selected.
Project | Rate of return | Selected or not |
A | 12 | Selected since return is more than 10.5 |
B | 11.50 | Selected since return is more than 10.5 |
C | 11.20 | Selected since return is more than 10.5 |
D | 11 | Selected since return is more than 10.5 |
E | 10.70 | Selected since return is more than 10.5 |
F | 10.30 | Not Selected since return is less than 10.5 |
G | 10.20 | Not Selected since return is less than 10.5 |
Thus, Project A B C D E is selected
Option ( D) is correct.