In: Statistics and Probability
Which insect repellents protect best against mosquitoes?
Consumer reports (June 2000) tested 14 products that all claim to
be an effective mosquito repellent. Each product was classified as
either lotion/cream or aerosol/spray. The cost of the product (in
dollars ) was divided by the amount of the repellent needed to
cover exposed areas of the skin *about 1/3 ounce) to obtain a
cost-oer0use value. Effectiveness was measured as the maximum
number of hours of protection (in half-hour increments) provided
when human testers exposed their arms to 200 mosquitoes. The data
from the report:
Insect
Repellent                             
Type   Cost/Use Maximum Protection
Away HourGuard
12           
Lotion/Cream       $2.08
     13.5 hours
Avon Skin-So-Soft       Aerosol/Spray
    
0.67                  
0.5
Avon BugGuard
Plus           
Lotion/Cream      
1.00         
         2.0
Ben's Backyard Formula Lotion/Cream
0.75                 
7.0
Bite
Blocker                      
Lotion/Cream        
0.46                 
3.0
BugOut                  
  
Aerosol/Spray         0.11
      6.0
Cutter
Skinsations              
Aerosol/Spray        0.22
   3.0
Cutter UNscented    Aerosol/Spray    
0.19       
       5.5
Musko1l
Ultra6Hours           
Aerosol/Spray    
0.24                 
6.5
Natrapel                  
     
Aerosol/Spray      0.27
               
1.0
Off! Deep Woods      
Aerosol/Spray      
1.77                 
14.0
Off! Skintastic     Lotion/Cream   
0.67  
          
3.0
Sawyer Deet
Formula         
Lotion/Cream 0.36    7.0
Repel
Permanone              
Aerosol/Spray      2.75    24.0
a. Suppose you want to use repellent type to model the cost per use
(y). Create the appropriate number of dummy variables for repellent
type, and write the model.
b. Fit the model you wrote in part a to the data.
c. Give the null hypothesis for testing whether repellent type is a
useful predictor of cost per use (y).
d. Conduct the test suggested in part c and give the appropriate
conclusion. Use alpha=.10.
e. Repeat parts a-d if the dependent variable is maximum number of
hours of protection (y).