Question

In: Statistics and Probability

M. S. Kanarek and associates studied the relationship between cancer rates and levels of asbestos in...

M. S. Kanarek and associates studied the relationship between cancer rates and levels of asbestos in the drinking water, in 722 Census tracts around San Francico Bay. They tested over 200 relationships – different types of cancer, different demographic groups, different ways of adjusting for possible confounding variables. After adjusting for age and socioeconomic status (but not smoking), they found a “strong relationship” between the rate of lung cancer among white males and the concentration of asbestos fibers in the drinking water: p < .001.

They found that a 100-fold increase in asbestos concentration was associated with a 1.05-fold in- crease in the lung cancer rate, on average. (This means: If tract B has 100 times the concentration of asbestos fibers in the water as tract A, and the lung cancer rate for white males in tract A is 1 per 1,000 persons per year, then tract B is predicted to have a rate of 1.05 per 1,000 persons per year.)

Are you convinced that asbestos in the drinking water causes lung cancer among white males, to a degree that steps should be taken to reduce it? Please point to at least three distinct flaws in this analysis.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The results here are statistically significant. However, the rate of lung cancer is not substantially significant. The fold change difference is only 0.05 males per 1000 persons. Hence, the results do not suggest to take steps to reduce the effect.

There are several flaws in the experiment.

1. There are several hypotheses being tested on the same dataset and hence it is possible by random chance to find out one hypothesis that would significant. Hence, to ensure that this hypothesis is not just detected by a chance event, it is essential to correct the p-value using multiple hypothesis testing tools like the Bonferroni test.

2. The parameters were tweaked to obtain a significant result. This does not make sense. In a scientific method, things begin with a hypothesis before even the data is collected, and hence the results are simply being tweaked to obtain significance. There is no rationale to choose some parameters over others.

3. As pin-pointed earlier, the difference though significant statistically (without correcting for multiple hypothesis) does not exhibit substantial significance.


Related Solutions

M. S. Kanarek and associates studied the relationship between cancer rates and levels of asbestos in...
M. S. Kanarek and associates studied the relationship between cancer rates and levels of asbestos in the drinking water, in 722 Census tracts around San Francico Bay. They tested over 200 relationships – different types of cancer, different demographic groups, different ways of adjusting for possible confounding variables. After adjusting for age and socioeconomic status (but not smoking), they found a “strong relationship” between the rate of lung cancer among white males and the concentration of asbestos fibers in the...
A cancer researcher wonders if there is a relationship between rates of death from skin cancer...
A cancer researcher wonders if there is a relationship between rates of death from skin cancer and latitude of residence. She collects data from each of the contiguous U.S. states: the state’s approximate latitude (measured at the center of the state) and the number of deaths from skin cancer out of every 1 million people in the state. Here is a summary of her findings: Latitude: AVG = 39.5 degrees, SD = 4.6 degrees Deaths per million: AVG = 15.3...
Describe the relationship between inflation levels in prices and inflation levels, wages and interest rates with...
Describe the relationship between inflation levels in prices and inflation levels, wages and interest rates with respect to their ability to affect people's economic status and business outcomes.
what is the relationship between calcium and cancer? vitamin D and cancer ? please I need...
what is the relationship between calcium and cancer? vitamin D and cancer ? please I need a long answer about 2 pages in details and citation .
Summarize the relationship between diet and cancer. Include in your discussion cancer promoters, antipromoters and dietary...
Summarize the relationship between diet and cancer. Include in your discussion cancer promoters, antipromoters and dietary practices to reduce cancer risks.
Describe the relationship between interest rates set by the Fed and inflation rates.
Describe the relationship between interest rates set by the Fed and inflation rates.
Briefly explain the relationship between inflation, interest rates and exchange rates.
Briefly explain the relationship between inflation, interest rates and exchange rates.
A nurse is interested in whether there is a relationship between daily levels of stress and...
A nurse is interested in whether there is a relationship between daily levels of stress and likelihood of a heart attack. The stress scores (predictor variable) and risk of heart attack values (criterion variable) from a small sample of participants are depicted below. Stress Score                                Risk of Heart Attack (Higher values = more stress)     (Higher values = greater risk)         1                                                     9       5                                                     8       2                                                     6       5                                                     8 Set up the regression equation and use to predict the risk of heart attack for a person with...
Why must the relationship between spot rates and forward rates hold? A) Because there is an...
Why must the relationship between spot rates and forward rates hold? A) Because there is an assumption of arbitrage-free valuation in the market. B) Because we need a reliable yield curve to price fixed-income securities C) Because investors require multiple methodologies to invest their savings D) Because the law of one price does not hold in all situations
Explain the relationship between bond prices and interest rates? How does the relationship between coupon yields...
Explain the relationship between bond prices and interest rates? How does the relationship between coupon yields and interest rates determine the bond price?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT