Question

In: Psychology

Heinz's dilemma is a frequently used example in many ethics and morality classes. One well-known version...

Heinz's dilemma is a frequently used example in many ethics and morality classes. One well-known version of the dilemma, used in Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development, is stated as follows:

A woman was near death from a special kind of cancer. There was one drug that the doctors thought might save her. It was a form of radium that a druggist in the same town had recently discovered. The drug was expensive to make, but the druggist was charging ten times what the drug cost him to produce. He paid $200 for the radium and charged $2,000 for a small dose of the drug. The sick woman's husband, Heinz, went to everyone he knew to borrow the money, but he could only get together about $1,000 which is half of what it cost. He told the druggist that his wife was dying and asked him to sell it cheaper or let him pay later. But the druggist said: “No, I discovered the drug and I'm going to make money from it.” So Heinz got desperate and broke into the man's laboratory to steal the drug for his wife. Should Heinz have broken into the laboratory to steal the drug for his wife? Why or why not?

Heinz dilemma. (2017, August 4 ). Retrieved August 4, 2017, from https://mymission.lamission.edu/userdata/beltray/docs/HEINZ%20DILEMMA.doc

Theresa, Jose, and Darnell all have different opinions about the best option in the Heinz dilemma.

Theresa agrees with option 1: Heinz should steal the drug and not go to prison, because this is unfair.

Jose agrees with option 2: Heinz should not steal the drug because he would be breaking the law.

Darnell agrees with option 3: Heinz should steal the drug and accept any prison sentence.

Write a justification for all 3 possibilities in the Heinz Dilemma. This will require you to take 3 different perspectives on the dilemma, including ones that you may not personally agree with. For each possibility, include these points:

Solutions

Expert Solution

Theresa agrees with option 1: Heinz should steal the drug and not go to prison, because this is unfair.
No one can watch their loved ones die because the medicines are not affordable. This is partly the mistake of the government to let one of their citizens die by not providing the necessary medicines. So what Heinz had done is right and the state should pay the money to the shopkeeper and let Heinz walk free. He didn’t steal for pleasure but to save a life, so in all moral standards, his action is justified. If Heinz should be punished, so the shop keeper who sold the drug for 10 times more price.
Jose agrees with option 2: Heinz should not steal the drug because he would be breaking the law.
There is always a process or proper channel through which Heinz should have got the medicine. He should have gone to the local council, explained his situation and asked for their help. He should have even asked money as loan from some of his friends. Breaking into someone’s property may not be a good option and it is against the law. He also set a low moral standard by breaking into it.
Darnell agrees with option 3: Heinz should steal the drug and accept any prison sentence.
Heinz in a moral responsibility of saving a dying member of the family weighed both the option letting someone die or stealing something and saving the life. In his view point he chose the latter, otherwise he will regret his decision of not saving his wife which in his point of view is killing his own wife. So what’s crueller, killing someone or stealing something? He stole it and now he will accept the prison sentence because at least he could see his wife later in life.


Related Solutions

What is standard costing, and when is it used? Give an example of a well-known company...
What is standard costing, and when is it used? Give an example of a well-known company that you think would use standard costing methods and explain why.
What is standard costing, and when is it used? Give an example of a well-known company...
What is standard costing, and when is it used? Give an example of a well-known company that you think would use standard costing methods and explain why. It has to be 250 words. Please do not copy and paste from other websites. Thank you!
Problem: Ethics in Business The top management of Solar Electronics, Inc., is well known for “managing...
Problem: Ethics in Business The top management of Solar Electronics, Inc., is well known for “managing by the numbers.” With an eye on the company’s desired growth in overall net profit, the company’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) sets target profits at the beginning of the year for each of the company’s divisions. The CEO has stated his policy as follows: “I won’t interfere with operations in the divisions. I am available for advice, but the division vice presidents are free...
There are many ways to fund a company, but the most frequently used source is Venture...
There are many ways to fund a company, but the most frequently used source is Venture Capital. True or False?
Provide one example of a laboratory related ethical or professional dilemma and explain why the example...
Provide one example of a laboratory related ethical or professional dilemma and explain why the example presents dilemma.
.       Airlines are well known for using complex pricing structures. For example, it is often (but not...
.       Airlines are well known for using complex pricing structures. For example, it is often (but not always) less expensive to buy a ticket in advance than it is on the day of the flight. However, if the airline offered this lower (“discount”) fare for all seats, it could not remain in business. a)Why offer fares with different prices? b)What, if any, costs are different?
Cosmopolitan magazine (Cosmo as it's popularly known) publishes many of it's well-known quizzes on its Web...
Cosmopolitan magazine (Cosmo as it's popularly known) publishes many of it's well-known quizzes on its Web site. One quiz is titled "Are You Obsessed with Appearances?" Consider whether you want to use the quiz data to determine how obsessed women are with their appearance.(1) Describe the typical person who might respond to this quiz.(2) Indicate the danger of relying on volunteer samples in general.
Solve the scissors, paper, rock game. This game is well known in many parts of the...
Solve the scissors, paper, rock game. This game is well known in many parts of the world. Two players simultaneously present a hand in one of three positions: an open hand (paper), a closed fist (rock), or two open fingers (scissors). The payoff is 1 unit according to the rule “Paper covers rock, rock breaks scissors, and scissors cut paper.” If both players present the same form, the payoff is 0. Set up the payoff matrix for the game and...
Choose one or two well-known brands and describe and discuss their target market(s), as well as...
Choose one or two well-known brands and describe and discuss their target market(s), as well as how they established a competitive advantage in their marketplace. 2 page essay APA format
Modifiability comes in many flavors and is known by many names. Find one of the IEEE...
Modifiability comes in many flavors and is known by many names. Find one of the IEEE or ISO standards dealing with quality attributes and compile a list of quality attributes that refer to some form of modifiability. Discuss the differences.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT