Question

In: Physics

The most basic explanation for the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is that the momentum and position of...

The most basic explanation for the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is that the momentum and position of a quantum particle is not very distinct when an attempt is made to measure them together. But what is it that causes the uncertainty? Because if there is no change in the momentum, then it would be the same as measuring the two separately. So what causes this change in the instantaneous perceived momentum. A change in mass? Velocity? Or net composition of the particle?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The Heisengberg uncertainty principle is a mathematical formulation of how nature is in the microcosm: in distances of the order of Angstrom the value of some pairs of observables can only be bounded and not measured to the accuracy we might want.

What does a position measurement mean?

It means setting up an experiment that will measure the location of a particle. The uncertainty principle states that if you want in the same experiment for the same particle to measure the momentum, you cannot measure it more accurately than the uncertainty principle allows. It is a fact of the quantum mechanical nature of reality at the microscopic level ( mostly, there are a few macroscopic quantum effects also).

This sentence in your link:

The particular eigenstate of the observable A may not be an eigenstate of another observable B. If this is so, then it does not have a single associated measurement as the system is not in an eigenstate of the observable.

describes the quantum mechanical situation well. The pairs of observables falling under the HUP cannot both have unique eigenvalues of the system's quantum mechanical solutions .If an observable is not an eigenstate of the system the only constraint on its value comes from the uncertainty principle.

So it is not that p changes, it is that we measure a different px for the particle when we know its x position accurately, and vice verso.


Related Solutions

Use the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to estimate the uncertainty in momentum resulting from confining an electron...
Use the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to estimate the uncertainty in momentum resulting from confining an electron to an atom (~10-10 m) and to the size of an atomic nucleus (~10-15 m). Calculate the corresponding uncertainty in the energy (in eV) of the confined electron and briefly comment on the physical implications of your results.
Exercise 6: A) How does the Heisenberg Uncertainty (with momentum and position) force us to abandon...
Exercise 6: A) How does the Heisenberg Uncertainty (with momentum and position) force us to abandon a deterministic universe? B) In what important ways is the Bohr model of the atom incompatible with quantum theory? Include the concept of orbits and what is known about angular momentum.
particle in a well 1. Using the uncertainty principle for position and momentum, estimate the ground...
particle in a well 1. Using the uncertainty principle for position and momentum, estimate the ground state energy for an infinite well of width a, compare the obtained result with the one found in the lecture. 2. Compute <p> and <x> for the particle in a box. 3. Prove that the eigenfunctions ψn(x) are orthogonal . 4. What are the energies of the ground state, first excited and second excited states for an electron trapped in an infinite well of...
Quantum Mechnics Why Heisenberg Uncertianty Principle is applies for only certain pairs like position and momentum,...
Quantum Mechnics Why Heisenberg Uncertianty Principle is applies for only certain pairs like position and momentum, Energy and time, Angular momentum and theeta?
One form of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is ΔxΔpx ≥ h/4π, where Δx is the uncertainty...
One form of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is ΔxΔpx ≥ h/4π, where Δx is the uncertainty in the system’s location and Δpx is the uncertainty in the system’s momentum along the same coordinate axis. Use this equation to show that exact knowledge of the system is not possible.
Concept: Engergy & momentum of light? Uncertainty Principle?
Concept: Engergy & momentum of light? Uncertainty Principle?
True or False. (a) According to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it is impossible to know simultaneously...
True or False. (a) According to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it is impossible to know simultaneously both the exact momentum of the electron and its exact location in space. Answer: ____________ (b) According to Born, taking the square root of ψ would give the probability of finding the electron in a certain region of space at a given time. Answer: ____________ (c) Based on the results from blackbody radiation, Max Planck assumed that energy can only be emitted in discrete...
Use the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to calculate Δx for an electron with Δv = 0.380 m/s....
Use the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to calculate Δx for an electron with Δv = 0.380 m/s. By what factor is the uncertainty of the (above) electron's position larger than the diameter of the hydrogen atom? (Assume the diameter of the hydrogen atom is 1.00×10-8 cm.) Use the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to calculate Δx for a ball (mass = 108 g, diameter = 7.90 cm) with Δv = 0.380 m/s. The uncertainty of the (above) ball's position is equal to what...
Which experiment setup can you demonstrate the existence of the "Heisenberg uncertainty principle" in the Laboratory...
Which experiment setup can you demonstrate the existence of the "Heisenberg uncertainty principle" in the Laboratory you work? Describe in detail how you can demonstrate the principle in question.
If a particle’s momentum uncertainty, what is the uncertainty in its position. Very briefly, what does...
If a particle’s momentum uncertainty, what is the uncertainty in its position. Very briefly, what does this result mean? What is the Compton effect? What is measured in observations of the Compton effect? How does this differ from the expectations of classical physics? At what condition for incident radiation can the effect be observed? What important property of light does the Compton effect demonstrate? How does it give evidence of electromagnetic radiation`s particle nature?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT