In: Finance
Exotic Rentals has four independent projects under consideration, each with a required rate of return of 14%. The total projects budget is $800,000. A table showing the investments and projected free cash flows follow:
Project/Year | Maserati | Lamborghini | Ferrari | BMW i8 Coupe |
0 (investment) | $150,380 | $221,320 | $286,550 | $175,500 |
1 | $40,000 | $85,000 | $100,000 | $52,000 |
2 | $80,000 | $110,000 | $125,000 | $90,000 |
3 | $60,000 | $110,000 | $125,000 | $90,000 |
4 | $60,000 | $92,000 | $125,000 | $70,000 |
5 | $95,000 | $125,000 | $150,000 | $135,000 |
No additional cash flows are expected from any of the five projects after year 5. The year 5 cash flow includes rentals and auction of the exotic vehicles into the secondary car market.
1- Which of the 4 projects has the highest IRR? The correct answer was determined using an Excel spreadsheet. Take answer to at least two decimal positions.
a) Ferrari
b) BMW i8 Coupe
c) Maserati
d) Lamborghini
2- Continuing with Exotic Rentals, the company has sufficient capital budget to fund three out of the four projects. Assuming that they do, what three projects should the firm select? Use highest NPV's to determine the projects to select.
a) BMW i8 Coupe, Maserati, Lamborghini
b) Ferrara, BMW i8 Coupe, Maserati
c) Lamborghini, Ferrari, BMW i8 Coupe
d) Maserati, Lamborghini, Ferrari
3- Continuing with Exotic Rentals, what is the combined NPV of these two projects: BMW i8 Coupe and Maserati
a) $448,464
b) $325,800
c) $509,182
d) $384,759
e) $183,302
4- Continuing with Exotic Rentals, what is the combined IRR of these two projects: Lamborghini and Ferrari?
a) 32.94%
b) 33.24%
c) 30.92%
d) 66.47%
e) 35.55%
5- Concluding Exotic Rentals, firm management is considering a loan to supplement the $800,000 set aside for the vehicles. The size of the loan would be approximately $34,000 and the interest rate would be 11.25%. Should Exotic Rentals take out the loan and fund all four projects? Base you decision only on the financial aspects of the deal.
a) No
b) Insufficient information to make a decision
c) Yes
Use IRR function in EXCEL to find the IRR
=IRR(Year0 to Year5 cashflows)
Use NPV function in EXCEL
=NPV(rate,Year1 to year5 cashflows)-Year0 cashflow
rate=14%
required return | 14% | |||
Maserati | Lamborghini | Ferrari | BMW i8 Coupe | |
Year0 | -150380 | -221320 | -286550 | -175500 |
Year1 | 40000 | 85000 | 100000 | 52000 |
Year2 | 80000 | 110000 | 125000 | 90000 |
Year3 | 60000 | 110000 | 125000 | 90000 |
Year4 | 60000 | 92000 | 125000 | 70000 |
Year5 | 95000 | 125000 | 150000 | 135000 |
NPV | 71628.25 | 131522.17 | 133639.51 | 111673.94 |
IRR | 30.51% | 35.55% | 30.92% | 35.05% |
1. Lamborghini will have higher IRR
2. Option C is correct
Lamborghini, Ferrari, BMW i8 Coupe have higher NPV's
3. Combined NPV of BMW i8 Coupe and Maserati=71628.15+111673.94=183302.19
Option e is correct
4. Combined Lamborghini and Ferrari IRR=35.55%+30.92%=66.47%
option d is correct
5. Option c, Yes.
They can fund beacuse the interest rate is lower than both cost of capital of 14% and IRR5's of all the projects.