Question

In: Economics

David Hume articulated an “Iron Law of Wages” whereby if the market wage rises above the...

David Hume articulated an “Iron Law of Wages” whereby if the market wage rises above the subsistence wage, the population increases and wages fall back to their subsistence level. Was David Hume’s Theory of wages consistent with Thomas Malthus’ theory of wages? Why or why not? (typed, 3 paragraphs)

Solutions

Expert Solution

the iron law of wages articulated by david ricardo is consistent with the theory of wage given by thomas malthus. malthusian theory of wage is from the population point of view and ricardos wage rate that is the subsistence wage theory is also based on population, labour supply and labour demand so both the theories in general talk about the same thing.

malthus in his theory stated that when wage rate is high people tend to enjoy a luxurious life and they start to have more children. this practice will make the popyuation in the country to rise and then the competitiveness among people for job will rise. as the labour supply increase the wage rate will decline and will come back to the subsistence level. on the other hand when the wage rate is below the subsistence level, people starve for food and they will not indulge in producing more children. this will make the population rate to go down and this will in turn decrease the supply of labour in the economy. the wage rate will rise to the subsistence level again. as described by ricardo the wage rate will always follow the subsistence level in the long run no matter wahat so that is why its called the iron law of wages.

as both the theories are talking about the wage rate from the population point of view and that the demand and supply of labour plays a great part deciding the wage rate, both the theories are consistent with each other explaining why the wage rate will always be at the subsistence levle in the long run.


Related Solutions

John Locke George Berkeley David Hume David Hartley Which one of the philosophers listed above do...
John Locke George Berkeley David Hume David Hartley Which one of the philosophers listed above do you find the most interesting and who do you think had the biggest influence on the future discipline of psychology. Explain
Efficiency wages are defined as wages that are intentionally above market rates. This practice is sometimes...
Efficiency wages are defined as wages that are intentionally above market rates. This practice is sometimes cited within the macroeconomics literature as a basis for sticky wages in the short run. One explanation for efficiency wages derives from incomplete information. In a world of complete information, firms could structure compensation contracts to directly reward high effort and punish low effort. However, in a world of incomplete information, monitoring is difficult and costly. Consider a worker that must make a choice...
According to the efficiency wage theory, firms operate more efficiently if wages are above the equilibrium...
According to the efficiency wage theory, firms operate more efficiently if wages are above the equilibrium level. Why would firms want to keep wages high? Explain by referring to the four variants of this theory.
2. The minimum wage law specifies a minimum price for hourly wages of the most of...
2. The minimum wage law specifies a minimum price for hourly wages of the most of the workers. Assume that the minimum effective wages (that is, above equilibrium) for workers who are not highly qualified. Analyze the impact of said law on the salary and employment of said workers, particularly the employment of foreigners. (14 points)
If a union establishes a wage floor above the equilibrium wage in a typical,competitive labor market,...
If a union establishes a wage floor above the equilibrium wage in a typical,competitive labor market, what will be the result? Question 22 options: an increase in wages and an increase in the quantity of workers employed an increase in wages and a decrease in the quantity of workers employed a decrease in wages and an increase in the quantity of workers employed a decrease in wages and a decrease in the quantity of workers employed
1) According to the theory of efficiency wages, paying an above-equilibrium wage may increase all of...
1) According to the theory of efficiency wages, paying an above-equilibrium wage may increase all of the following except worker effort. the natural rate of unemployment. worker turnover. the quality of a firm's workforce. 2) The main cause of the decline in labor force participation since 2007 is an increase in the number of people in school. retired workers. discouraged workers. disabled workers. 3) Complete the following statement. If an economy has a large number of discouraged workers, the unempoyment...
Draw the labor market for workers with a minimum wage above the market rate. Label on...
Draw the labor market for workers with a minimum wage above the market rate. Label on your graph the minimum wage, quantity demanded, quantity supplied, and the price set by the market. Is there a shortage or surplus of workers? How do you know? Show on your graph. Show the area of consumer surplus. Show the area of producer surplus. Show the area of the DWL. Show the area of the potential loss from job search.
In a competitive labor market, if the Illinois government imposes a minimum wage that is above...
In a competitive labor market, if the Illinois government imposes a minimum wage that is above the market equilibrium wage, how does the minimum wage affect the amount of labor hours done by workers?
How are wages set in the labor market? Are workers and companies Wage (price) setters or...
How are wages set in the labor market? Are workers and companies Wage (price) setters or wage (price) takers or both? Explain how a company or a worker can be a wage setter, while other companies and workers are wage takers. Hint: A wage setter is where the company/worker decide how much to pay/how much the wages should be and wage taker is where the company pays what the market wages are, no more or less.
When the prevailing market wage is above equilibrium, we say: Multiple Choice there is no unemployment....
When the prevailing market wage is above equilibrium, we say: Multiple Choice there is no unemployment. there is a surplus of labor. the quantity of labor demanded is more than the quantity supplied. All of these are true.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT