Fifteen years ago, most Americans had never heard of AFLAC, a
$26-billion insurance company based in Columbus, Georgia. Thanks to
AFLAC’s mascot, this is no longer the case. The company’s
attention-grabbing advertising campaign, which began in 2000,
features a helpful but frustrated duck that fails to get people to
acknowledge his presence or the company’s name. Nonetheless, the
duck’s efforts appear to be paying off. According to advertising
surveys, 94 percent of Americans are now aware of the AFLAC brand;
more importantly, policies in force have risen more than 50 percent
and annual premiums have more than doubled since the duck
commercials began in the United States. And the AFLAC duck has done
more than simply increase the company’s American sales. AFLAC now
sells the duck on its website and donates the proceeds to a
children’s cancer center in Atlanta. During the Christmas season,
AFLAC teams up with a major department store chain to sell
special-edition AFLAC holiday ducks. To date, $3 million has been
donated to 40 children’s hospitals around the country from their
sale.
Despite the duck’s efforts, AFLAC is still a small player in
the U.S. market. Its $5.6 billion of revenue in the United States
is dwarfed by such insurers as AIG, Prudential, or MetLife. Such is
not the case in Japan, where an estimated 25 percent of the
populace has purchased AFLAC insurance. AFLAC does more than 75
percent of its business in Japan. Its assets in Japan are huge—$114
billion—compared to only $17 billion in the United States. Thus,
AFLAC is a rar- ity among U.S. multinational corporations—its
dominant market is Japan, not the United States.
AFLAC specializes in supplemental insurance— insurance that
covers specific types of problems, such as cancer, disability, or
accidents. The company was founded on a shoestring in 1955 as the
American Family Life Assurance Company. The three founding
brothers—Paul, Bill, and John Amos—scraped together $40,000 to
launch the enterprise. In its early years the company struggled
through many crises; once the Amos brothers were so short of cash
they had to sell off the office furniture.
AFLAC’s big break came when John visited the Osaka World’s
Fair in 1970. He noticed that many Japanese walked around in
surgical masks to reduce the spread of respiratory infections. Amos
believed that such health-conscious consumers would be prime
candidates for supplemental insurance. Entering the Japanese market
was no picnic, however. It took AFLAC four years to receive
regulatory clearance to begin marketing its products there.
AFLAC initially focused on selling cancer life insur- ance in
Japan. As its knowledge of the market grew, it added accident,
nursing care, medical, and other spe- cialty policies to its
product line. It has enjoyed continual growth in the years it has
operated in Japan. AFLAC’s competitive strength lies in its
distribution network. Its products are sold by an army of licensed
sales associates, some 125,000 strong, working through 18,400
indepen- dent insurance agencies. Ninety-one percent of the com-
panies listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange offer AFLAC products to
their employees through payroll deduction programs.
AFLAC strives to deliver high-quality service to its cus-
tomers. In 2010, the average claim was settled by AFLAC in four
business days. The company has also adapted its oper- ating
procedures to the needs of the local market. Consider its human
resource practices. When the company first ventured into Japan, it
copied the lifetime employment and seniority-based pay and
promotion policies then current in Japan. In the past several
years, some Japanese companies have switched to job-based reward
systems, in which sala- ries are based on the skill requirements
and difficulties of the job. So too has AFLAC.
AFLAC has added some “made in U.S.A.” features to its Japanese
operations. Nearly half of its Japanese employees have been granted
stock options, reinforcintg their commitment to the company’s
future. It has funded AFLAC Parents’ House in Tokyo, providing a
place to stay for families whose children have been sent to Tokyo
to receive medical treatment for pediatric cancer and other
life-threatening diseases. AFLAC also funds college scholarships
for Japanese high school students who have lost a parent to
cancer.
AFLAC is the largest provider of supplemental insurance in
Japan. Its Japanese revenues reached $20 billion in 2012. Given the
graying of the Japanese market— older folks tend to buy more
insurance—the high profit margins of its product line, and an
overburdened Japanese healthcare system that is shifting costs to
consumers, AFLAC believes that the profitability of its Japanese
opera- tions will continue to grow.
AFLAC does face numerous challenges, of course. For many years
it benefited from the Japanese government’s restrictive regulation
of the country’s financial services sector, which discouraged
competition and price-cutting. To combat Japan’s decade-long
economic slump, the government relaxed its regulation of financial
services, a process known as the Regulatory Big Bang. In 2001, the
Ministry of Finance allowed additional firms to begin selling
supplemental insurance, including domestic giants like Tokio Marine
& Fire and Nippon Life. To date, the increased competition has
not dethroned AFLAC from its market-leading perch. Its operating
costs are less than those of its rivals. To maintain this edge,
AFLAC has streamlined its operations, allowing sales agents to
submit policy applications online and introducing new online
billing techniques. To bolster its sales position, AFLAC stepped up
its recruitment and training of sales agents and developed new
products for them to sell. It entered into a strategic alliance
with Dai-ichi Mutual Life, the second- largest life insurance
company in Japan. Dai-ichi Mutual’s 50,000-person sales force helps
market AFLAC’s supple- mental policies to retail customers. In
addition, AFLAC products are available at 372 Japanese banks and at
1,000 branches of Japan Post.
In 2001, AFLAC took another bold step—it brought the duck to
Japan! The Japanese translation for “quack” is ga-ga, and Japanese
consumers proved to be as “gaga” for the duck as Americans were.
Surveys of Japanese consumers report that TV commercials featuring
the AFLAC duck consistently rank first or second in popular- ity in
the insurance category. In 2009, AFLAC tinkered with the duck’s
design, blending it with the traditional maneki neko cat (the
ceramic figurine of a cat with a raised paw) to create the maneki
neko duck, which AFLAC now features in many of its advertisements
for family-oriented insurance products. In other commercials, the
familiar duck cavorts with a live-action version of the maneki neko
cat. (You can see a sample of its Japanese ads by entering “AFLAC
Japanese commercials” in You Tube’s search box. You will observe
that they are more gentle and less “in your face” than the
company’s U.S. commercials.)
1. AFLAC introduced the AFLAC duck in the U.S. market to build
brand awareness there. However, AFLAC’s brand awareness is high in
Japan. Should AFLAC use the same advertising campaign in Japan as
it does in the United States? Is there any value to having
identical advertising in both markets? Having introduced the maneki
neko duck in Japan, should it now introduce it in the U.S. market
as well?
2. How important is it for AFLAC to adapt its business
practices to the Japanese way of doing things? Should AFLAC act
more Japanese or more American in doing business in Japan?
3. AFLAC built its dominant position in the Japanese
supplemental insurance market because Japanese regulators actively
discouraged new entrants into this market. The Financial Big Bang
policy now encourages new entrants into the supplemental insurance
market. What has AFLAC done to protect
4. AFLAC is a rarity among U.S. companies in as much as the
Japanese market accounts for more than 75 percent of its business.
Does this reliance on the Japanese market create any special
challenges for AFLAC? Does it present any unique opportunities for
the company?