In: Finance
Develop an economic feasibility analysis, using payback analysis, ROI, and present value (assume a discount rate of 10%) using the table below
| 
 System in place  | 
 In-House System  | 
 Vertical Software  | 
|
| 
 Year 1  | 
 6 hours overtime total $6,480 per employee Support Staff 7 People Plus, new staff member  | 
 12 weeks, hourly salary $35 total $16,800 Commercial package $2,500 10 hrs. weekly training $4200 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320 Hardware Cost $12,500  | 
 Vertical package $12,000 4 weeks to install $5,600 10hrs weekly training $4,200 Free Support first year 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320 Hardware Cost $12,500  | 
| 
 Year 2  | 
 6 hours overtime total $6,480 per employee  | 
 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
 Technical Support $600 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
| 
 Year 3  | 
 6 hours overtime total $6,480 per employee  | 
 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
 Technical Support $600 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
| 
 Year 4  | 
 6 hours overtime total $6,480 per employee  | 
 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
 Technical Support $600 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
| 
 Year 5  | 
 6 hours overtime total $6,480 per employee  | 
 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
 Technical Support $600 4 hrs. weekly maintenance $22.5 total of 4,320  | 
| 
 Total  | 
 $259,200  | 
 $57,600  | 
 $58,300  | 
| 
 Saved in 5 years  | 
 $201,600  | 
 $200,900  | 
| System in place | In-House System | Vertical Software | ||||||
| year 1 | 51,840 | 12 weeks, hourly salary | 16800 | vetical package | 12000 | 5 | ||
| commercial package | 2500 | installation | 5600 | |||||
| weekly training | 4200 | weekly training | 4200 | |||||
| weekly maintenace | 4320 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | |||||
| hardware | 12500 | hardware | 12500 | |||||
| 40,320 | 38,620 | |||||||
| year 2 | Technical Support | 600 | ||||||
| 51,840 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | ||||
| 4920 | ||||||||
| year 3 | ||||||||
| 51,840 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | Technical Support | 600 | ||||
| weekly maintenace | 4320 | |||||||
| 4920 | ||||||||
| year 4 | Technical Support | 600 | ||||||
| 51,840 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | ||||
| 4920 | ||||||||
| year 5 | 51,840 | Technical Support | 600 | |||||
| weekly maintenace | 4320 | weekly maintenace | 4320 | |||||
| 4920 | ||||||||
| 2,59,200 | 57,600 | 58,300 | ||||||
| saved | - | 2,01,600 | 2,00,900 | compared with system in place | ||||
| Payback period | 5 years | 3.50 | 3.45 | |||||
| ROI | 64% | 63% | ||||||
| Present value | 49,103.47 | 49,287.03 | ||||||
| Net Present Value | 8,496.53 | 9,012.97 |