Question

In: Physics

According to Newton, spacetime was like a stage, or a container. It existed independently of matter,...

According to Newton, spacetime was like a stage, or a container. It existed independently of matter, and its properties were absolute: they did not depend on inertial observers.

Do you think one could salvage a view like Newton's, where spacetime and some of its properties are absolute, for Minkowski spacetime? Why or why not?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Newton physics was  on the the absoluteness of things under Gallelian transformation, with time as the absolute quantity. Length, mass,time etc. remained to be same irrespect of the space you are in.In classical domian where relative speed involed is very much low, the space and time had any noticible effects. The variations involved are very much feeble to bother anyone. So,to common people Newtonian physics works very well.

Howevere science is science like truth is truth, the space and time varies for an observer with different relative velocities. Einstein came up with theory of relativity formulated on minkowski space(flat space-time) taking the use of Loretz transformation, in this paradigm mass, length, time etc remains no more absolute.this is how space and time behaves. The results obtained from the theory where well tested from time to time and eveything in it till now, agreed with the experiments.  So what bothers one to accept it a clear cut and beautiful theory.

Differences are there however, there things like speed of light which is simultaneously agreed by both the theories

Physical laws remain same for every inertial frame of refrence. etc


Related Solutions

What are Matter (de Broglie) Waves? If matter has a wave nature, why is this wave-like...
What are Matter (de Broglie) Waves? If matter has a wave nature, why is this wave-like characteristic not observable in our daily experiences? How can matter have a dual wave-particle nature?
According to Cooper & Zmud (1990), in which stage is an IT application installed, and are...
According to Cooper & Zmud (1990), in which stage is an IT application installed, and are organizational processes revised and developed? Initiation Adoption Adaption Acceptance Routinization According to Cooper & Zmud (1990), in which stage is increased organizational effectiveness obtained by using the IT application? Adoption Adaption Acceptance Routinization Infusion Deciding who and when to hire, creating a budget, setting up ways to measure the project outcomes occurs during this specific part of implementing an ERP system. Coding Implementation Planning...
According to Mendel’s law, phenotypical characteristics are determined by pairs of factors (alleles) that separate independently...
According to Mendel’s law, phenotypical characteristics are determined by pairs of factors (alleles) that separate independently in gametes. What are the main types of inheritance that are exceptions to Mendel’s rules?
(based on 8.38) A stack is a sequence container type that, like a queue, supports very...
(based on 8.38) A stack is a sequence container type that, like a queue, supports very restrictive access methods: all insertions and removals are from one end of the stack, typically referred to as the top of the stack. A stack is often referred to as a list-in first-out (LIFO) container because the last item inserted is the first removed. Implement a Stack class. It should support the following methods/functions: _init__ - Can construct either an empty stack, or initialized...
According to data released by the World Bank, the mean PM10 (particulate matter) concentration for the...
According to data released by the World Bank, the mean PM10 (particulate matter) concentration for the city of Kabul, Afghanistan, in 1999 was 46. Suppose that because of efforts to improve air quality in Kabul, increases in modernization, and efforts to establish environmental-friendly businesses, city leaders believe rates of particulate matter in Kabul have decreased. To test this notion, they randomly sample 12 readings over a one-year period with the resulting readings shown below. Do these data present enough evidence...
According to data released by the World Bank, the mean PM10 (particulate matter) concentration for the...
According to data released by the World Bank, the mean PM10 (particulate matter) concentration for the city of Kabul, Afghanistan, in 1999 was 46. Suppose that because of efforts to improve air quality in Kabul, increases in modernization, and efforts to establish environmental-friendly businesses, city leaders believe rates of particulate matter in Kabul have decreased. To test this claim, they randomly sampled 12 readings from the city over a one-year period and the sample mean PM10 concentration rate was found...
How are the main classes of arthropods classified according to the presence of a larval stage...
How are the main classes of arthropods classified according to the presence of a larval stage during their embryonic development?
For the retail investor who would like to participate in a stock market, does it matter...
For the retail investor who would like to participate in a stock market, does it matter whether they choose to hold a ETF or an index fund? Which key variable drives the decision between either instrument
I'd like some suggestions for good reading materials on the Keldysh formalism in a condensed matter...
I'd like some suggestions for good reading materials on the Keldysh formalism in a condensed matter context. I'm familiar with the imaginary time, coherent state, and path integral formalisms, but lately I've been seeing Keldysh more and more in papers. My understanding is that it is superior to the imaginary time formalism at least in that one can evaluate non-equilibrium expectations.
If matter has a wave nature, why is this wave-like characteristic not observable in our daily...
If matter has a wave nature, why is this wave-like characteristic not observable in our daily experiences? Any object of macroscopic size—including a grain of dust—has an undetectably small wavelength, so any diffraction effects it might exhibit are very small, effectively undetectable. Recall historically how the diffraction of sound waves was at one time well known, but the diffraction of light was not. Only objects of macroscopic size, like an ocean wave, actually exhibit a wave nature. Smaller, microscopic objects—including...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT