Question

In: Economics

When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less pizza—the taxes...

When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less pizza—the taxes cause deadweight losses and make the allocation of resources less efficient. As we have already seen, much government revenue comes from the individual income tax in many countries. In a case study in Chapter 8, we discussed how this tax discourages people from working as hard as they otherwise might. Another inefficiency caused by this tax is that it discourages people from saving.

Consider a person 25 years’ old who is considering saving $1,000. If he puts this money in a savings account that earns 8 percent and leaves it there, he would have $21,720 when he retires at age 65. Yet if the government taxes one-fourth of his interest income each year, the effective interest rate is only 6 percent. After 40 years of earning 6 percent, the $1,000 grows to only $10,290, less than half of what it would have been without taxation. Thus, because interest income is taxed, saving is much less attractive.

Some economists advocate eliminating the current tax system’s disincentive toward saving by changing the basis of taxation. Rather than taxing the amount of income that people earn, the government could tax the amount that people spend.

Under this proposal, all income that is saved would not be taxed until the saving is later spent. This alternative system, called a consumption tax, would not distort people’s saving decisions.

Various provisions of the current tax code already make the tax system a bit like a consumption tax. Taxpayers can put a limited amount of their saving into special accounts—such as Individual Retirement Accounts and 401(k) plans—that escape taxation until the money is withdrawn at retirement. For people who do most of their saving through these retirement accounts, their tax bill is, in effect, based on their consumption rather than their income.

European countries tend to rely more on consumption taxes than does the United States. Most of them raise a significant amount of government revenue through a value-added tax, or a VAT. A VAT is like the retail sales tax that many U.S. states use, but rather than collecting all of the tax at the retail level when the consumer buys the final good, the government collects the tax in stages as the good is being produced (that is, as value is added by firms along the chain of production). Various U.S. policymakers have proposed that the tax code move further in direction of taxing consumption rather than income. In 2005, economist Alan Greenspan, then Chairman of the Federal Reserve, offered this advice to a presidential commission on tax reform: “As you know, many economists believe that a consumption tax would be best from the perspective of promoting economic growth—particularly if one were designing a tax system from scratch—because a consumption tax is likely to encourage saving and capital formation. However, getting from the current tax system to a consumption tax raises a challenging set of transition issues.”

Q1: What should be taxed - Personal Income or Personal Consumption and why? Provide your opinion based on the case given below. (200 words)                                                                                          [2.5 Marks]

Q2: How may it affect Saudi Economy if an income tax is imposed in KSA? (200 words)           [2.5 Marks]

Solutions

Expert Solution

1) Income tax-  An income tax is levied by the government on the income of people or when they receive interest, dividend from their investments.

Consumption tax- consumption tax is charged to people when they spend money .

According to case given, Personal Consumption should be taxed. Many economists believe that consumption tax would be best from the perspective of promoting economic growth and to encourage saving and capital formation.consumption tax makes economy more efficient while income taxation penalises savers and reward spenders .it's only fair that people are taxed on what they take out of limited resources pool through consumption rather than what they contribute to the pool using their income . However greeting from current tax system to consumption tax raises challenging set of transition issues.

2) Saudi Arabia has traditionally been tax free for individuals with oil revenue supporting a wide range of subsidies and benefits for citizens .

If income tax is imposed in kingdom of Saudi Arabians then it will bolster it's finances. Saudi Arabian by imposing income tax can raise funds needed for wide ranging reforms from fiscal and investment policy to social initiatives.

Income tax to on Saudis and non Saudis would raise a significant amount of oil revenue from the government. But it could also make luring expatraites to the conservative kingdom more difficult. It's tax free status attracts foreigners by imposing income tax it will will attract less foreigners


Related Solutions

Econ201 Please solve your personal solution and """do not copy""" Case Study When taxes induce people...
Econ201 Please solve your personal solution and """do not copy""" Case Study When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less pizza—the taxes cause deadweight losses and make the allocation of resources less efficient. As we have already seen, much government revenue comes from the individual income tax in many countries. In a case study in Chapter 8, we discussed how this tax discourages people from working as hard as they otherwise might. Another inefficiency...
The law of demand says that when the price of something goes down people buy less...
The law of demand says that when the price of something goes down people buy less of it (and vice versa), all other things being equal. Such a change is referred to as an increase in quantity demanded and is shown by a movement down along a given demand curve. By contrast, an increase in demand is shown by a rightward shift in the entire demand curve. 1. Some people seem to believe that there are goods for which the...
“If consumers buy less of a commodity when their incomes rise, they will surely buy less...
“If consumers buy less of a commodity when their incomes rise, they will surely buy less when the price of the commodity rises.” Explain this statement with the help of income and substitution effect?
When there is no clear correct behavior, people often feel pressure to imitate the behavior of...
When there is no clear correct behavior, people often feel pressure to imitate the behavior of those around them. This demonstrates the power of: unanimity. observation. public responses. ambiguity. 2. The _____ study was conducted to determine if group size influenced conformity. Gawkers Line Autokinetic Social conformity 3. _____ is a researcher of social influence who took advantage of the autokinetic phenomenon. Solomon Asch Karen Horney Abraham Maslow Muzafer Sherif 4. Which is NOT a condition increasing the likelihood of...
Changes in the treatment of people with abnormal behavior have coincided with social change and medical...
Changes in the treatment of people with abnormal behavior have coincided with social change and medical understanding. What changes do you think might happen in the next 10–20 years?
When the government taxes younger people to pay benefits to older people, how does this affect...
When the government taxes younger people to pay benefits to older people, how does this affect the amount of assistance that younger people might voluntarily choose to offer older people? How does this affect the size of the bequests that older people are likely to leave to their children or grandchildren when they die? How does it affect the decisions of the younger workers about how much leisure they consume (how they spend their disposable income)? How does the promise...
How consolidations change when a company acquires at least 50%, but less then 100% of another...
How consolidations change when a company acquires at least 50%, but less then 100% of another company. What new account/s are present? How are these accounts classified/reported. What consolidation entries change?
1. What assumption is made when considering the theory of consumer behavior? A. People do not...
1. What assumption is made when considering the theory of consumer behavior? A. People do not have preferences. B. Consumers always buy the lowest price item. C. There are no budget limits. D. People engage in rational behavior. 2. In a representative democracy, voters are _______ and politicians are _______. A. principals; agents B. employees; agents C. logrollers; principals D. agents; employees 3. On what assumption do neoclassical and behavioral economics disagree? A. People have motivations. B. People are almost...
Market equilibrium occurs when the amount of people that are willing to buy equals the amount...
Market equilibrium occurs when the amount of people that are willing to buy equals the amount of people that are willing to sell. A steadfast tenant in economics. As students here at Post let’s surmise that right now Post is at market equilibrium. We have enough Instructors to match the number of students. However, two scenarios occur; first, student enrollment falls, so Post decides it must now raise tuition. Not good…. Or, enrollment increases! And Post decides to, you guessed...
Reflect on the idea of product. What is a product? When people buy products, what are...
Reflect on the idea of product. What is a product? When people buy products, what are they really buying?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT