Question

what are the different opinions regarding social work between Jane Addams and Mary Richmond?

Answer 1

Mary Richmond and Jane Addams are two of the most influential persons in the profession of social work .

JANE ADDAMS :   Her philosophy was to serve the poor and the needy within the community . Her ideology was more of practical ;  She instead surrounded herself with the people she served; she lived in the neighborhood. Addams did not refer to her neighbors as clients or cases. she disregarded the younger social workers who served the community but stayed in homes far away from the slum or poor.

MARY RICHMOND :  General Secretary in the Charity Organization Society (COS). their approach was responding the poor and needy through friendly visits which was not so personal like addams approach to be with poor in their enviornment. She condemned addams service as oldfashioned mission which provided cheap charity.  Richmond assessed the characteristics of those who were seeking help, which contrasted with Addams’ socialization as a means of helping.

Richmond s mission was as a gatekeeper for the welfare system rather than truly caring for the needs of the poor and destitute ike addams.

Addams’ influenced on human rights as an social work curriculum, and its core values such as dignity or human worth and social justice were established.

Richmond was driven by the need for practical experiences, assessment and evidence, and accountability for work with clients – setting rules for predicting experiences.