Question

In: Accounting

Should the sec/PCAOB provide a complete list of non-audit services that independent auditor are prohibited from...

Should the sec/PCAOB provide a complete list of non-audit services that independent auditor are prohibited from providing to their public company audit clients? defend your answer

Solutions

Expert Solution

The audit committee should consider whether a relationship with or service provided by an auditor:

(a) creates a mutual or conflicting interest with their audit client;
(b) places them in the position of auditing their own work;
(c) results in their acting as management or an employee of the audit client; or
(d) places them in a position of being an advocate for the audit client.

The Commission rules also address specific auditor independence issues, some of which are:

Specific Prohibited Non-audit Services

The auditor is prohibited from providing the following non-audit services to an audit client including its affiliates:

  • Bookkeeping
  • Financial information systems design and implementation
  • Appraisal or valuation services, fairness opinions, or contribution-in-kind reports
  • Actuarial services
  • Internal audit outsourcing services
  • Management functions or human resources
  • Broker-dealer, investment adviser, or investment banking services
  • Legal services and expert services unrelated to the audit

In addition to the specific prohibited services, audit committees should consider whether any service provided by the audit firm may impair the firm's independence in fact or appearance.

Pre-approval of Permitted Services

Subject to certain limited exceptions, the audit committee must pre-approve all permitted services provided by the independent auditor (i.e., tax services, comfort letters, statutory audits or other). The Commission rules include certain pre-approval requirements that the audit committee must follow. In addition, the audit committee should be informed about the services expected to be provided by the audit firm to understand whether the audit firm's independence will be impaired.

The audit committee should consider whether company policies and procedures require that all audit and non-audit services are brought before the committee for pre-approval.

Also, listing company standards require audit committees to pre-approve all audit, review and attest services regardless of whether the firm performing the services is the company's principal auditor.

Prohibited Relationships

Certain relationships between audit firms and the companies they audit are not permitted. These include:

  • Employment relationships. A one-year cooling off period is required before a company can hire certain individuals formerly employed by its auditor in a financial reporting oversight role. The audit committee should also consider whether the hiring of personnel that are or were formerly employed by the audit firm might affect the audit firm's independence.
  • Contingent Fees. Audit committees should not approve engagements that remunerate an independent auditor on a contingent fee or a commission basis. Such remuneration is considered to impair the auditor's independence.
  • Direct or material indirect business relationships. Audit firms may not have any direct or material indirect business relationships with the company, its officers, directors or significant shareholders. Thus, audit committees should consider whether the company has implemented processes that identify such prohibited relationships.
  • Certain Financial Relationships. Audit committees should be aware that certain financial relationships between the company and the independent auditor are prohibited. These include creditor/ debtor relationships, banking, broker-dealer, futures commission merchant accounts, insurance products and interests in investment companies.

Communications Between the Audit Committee and the Independent Auditor

Independence Standards Board Standard No. 1 requires that the auditor disclose to the audit committee in writing all relationships between the audit firm and the company that may reasonably be thought to bear on the audit firm's independence. Standard No. 1 also requires the auditor to confirm and discuss its independence with the audit committee. The audit committee should consider discussing the following issues with the auditor in regards to the firm's independence disclosure:

  • Processes the audit firm uses to ensure complete disclosure of all relationships with the company and its affiliates
  • Relationships the audit firm may have with officers, board members and significant shareholders
  • Relationships not included in the communication because they were deemed immaterial

Related Solutions

Why did the SEC ban certain non-audit services from being offered to SEC-registrant audit clients even...
Why did the SEC ban certain non-audit services from being offered to SEC-registrant audit clients even though it has been possible to effectively manage such conflict of interest situations?
research and discuss the top 5 audit concerns of the PCAOB.  If you are an auditor ,...
research and discuss the top 5 audit concerns of the PCAOB.  If you are an auditor , what would your top concerns be. Are there any examples of these audit concern issues in the news ?
Should accounting firms be permitted to provide lobbying or legislative advisory services to non-audit clients? why...
Should accounting firms be permitted to provide lobbying or legislative advisory services to non-audit clients? why or why not? should accounting firms be permitted to lobby rule- making bodies regarding proposed account standards? Defend your answer
How should non-audit services previously performed for a client should be considered when planning the audit?
How should non-audit services previously performed for a client should be considered when planning the audit?
The debate of whether an auditor who performs non-attest services (e.g. Consulting) for an audit client...
The debate of whether an auditor who performs non-attest services (e.g. Consulting) for an audit client will have their independence impaired has been going on for some time in the accounting profession. While Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 expressly restrict auditors from performing consulting and other non-attest services for their audit clients, the AICPA does not have such stringent restrictions. Required: Present an argument why you believe that performing non attest services for an audit client would or would not impair...
Required (i)Define and Discuss to Non-audit services. (ii)Define and Discuss Non-audit services supplied to an audit...
Required (i)Define and Discuss to Non-audit services. (ii)Define and Discuss Non-audit services supplied to an audit client should be stopped. Note Please do new post (400 words longs )
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages from a client’s perspective of engaging its auditor to perform non-audit...
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages from a client’s perspective of engaging its auditor to perform non-audit services in addition to the audit. (NB. Do not discuss this from the auditor’s perspective, discuss this from the client’s perspective).
The auditor of three independent companies have just concluded their audit. For each company audit described...
The auditor of three independent companies have just concluded their audit. For each company audit described below, identify and briefly explain the type of audit report that can be issued by an auditor to that company: a. COMPANY A: The auditor of Company A concludes that the overall financial statements are fairly presented, but the scope of the audit has been materially restricted, or GAAP were not followed in preparing the financial statements. • Based on audit tests and evidence...
what was the role in the Enron case of the independent auditor, audit committee and internal...
what was the role in the Enron case of the independent auditor, audit committee and internal auditors?
The SEC is an independent, non partisan quasi-judicial agency that is responsible for administering the federal...
The SEC is an independent, non partisan quasi-judicial agency that is responsible for administering the federal securities laws. Publicly traded companies must file a variety of forms electronically through the EDGAR system. The primary purpose of this is for fairness and accessibility. Visit the SEC website (www.sec.com) looking under the link Description of forms. Describe the form 8-K, 10-K, and 10Q. Note what these represent and why they are required? Under Company Filings search for the most recent 10-K of...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT