Question

In: Economics

Abby is debating whether she should take a big loan to go to a graduate school...

Abby is debating whether she should take a big loan to go to a graduate school or continue whit their daily boring job.

which type of motivational conflict does abby experience above?

How can graduate schools helps people like abby to resolve their motivational conflict to enroll in graduate programs . please list two different stratergies focusing on different aspects?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The background for this answer will be provided by the Motivation Equation MEVID:

Motivation = [(Expectancy x Value) / (Impulsivity x Delay)]

which is to be interpreted as saying that

Motivation is directly (positively) related to

i) Expectancy or Probability of Success: We feel more motivated to do something if there's a realistic chance of succeeding;

^ that's (one explanation for) why students from certain backgrounds do worse than others: not genetics, but rather looking around at family / community members and coming to the subconscious conclusion of inevitable defeat deals a death blow to the motivation needed to foresake leisure and/or low-skilled employment and study instead.

ii) Value, or how much the desired outcome is perceived to be worth it: economics is the study of incentives, the incentive exists because of desire to consume Value, more Value translates to stronger incentive.

and Motivation is inversely (negatively) related to

iii) Impulsivity or Opportunity Cost: the more options there are for what we could rather be doing, and the more enticing these options are, the less motivated we'll be to start one activity (because paralysis by analysis) and fall into a state of flow doing it (because constant distracting thoughts have to be controlled using willpower, a finite resource)

iv) Delay or intertemporal discounting: The further away in time the desired outcome is perceived to be, the less motivated we are to put effort towards it. This explains why we experience a spike in motivation a week before the exam: now the desired outcome (being able to write well on the test) is only 168 hours away rather than months away.
^ David Laibson has talked about this in discussions on the "pull of instant gratification"; humans have hyperbolic discounting bias and choose a smaller immediately-available reward over a larger-reward that comes with a delay, even if the total value of that larger reward (even after normal exponential discounting) is more than the value of the smaller reward; google Stanford marshmellow experiment for more reading.

------
The last point iv) Delay is most relevant to the question here.
Abby is biased towards short-run hits of gratification (she's likely a fellow member of the want-it-now generation, as somebody once called millenials)
so even if going with higher education will bring significantly more value to her over time
she's taking (what is called) the Path of Least Effort

Graduate schools can employ the simplistic modelling of behavior provided by MEVID to come up with many possible strategies (or combinations of tactics): pick one component of EVID and brainstorm a tactic to address it.

Some exampes:

i) Increase Expectancy component by having a roster of successful alumni across industries and the world, but also across backgrounds; show that there's something for everyone, that this is the place where weak students are nurtured (and not ignored to their own fate).
ii) Increase Value component by achieving market differentiation i.e. offering side-benefits like unique campus culture which will not be available anywhere else in the world; (perceived) scarcity drives up (perceived) Value
iii) Reduce Impulsivity by offering free-of-cost student counsellors to potential applicant(s) even before their admission, to sit down and honestly decide together whether the benefits outweigh the costs given that particular applicant's short-term and long-term goals. People who do come on board are the ones who pass through this filter, and are thus committed candidates by definition - this has network externality benefits (committed students inspire other students to become committed themselves)
iv) Reduce Delay by tying up with corporate entities to offer immersive (and paying) internships; Northeastern University in the States provides a good example of execution.
-----
Please leave an upvote if this helped!


Related Solutions

2. Abby is about to graduate from OSU, and she cannot decide if she should go...
2. Abby is about to graduate from OSU, and she cannot decide if she should go to Medical School or Law School. To cover her bases, she decides to take both the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) and the Law School Admission Test (LSAT). Her scores on each of these standardized exams are presented in the following table, along with the means and standard deviations of those exams. Both exams have distributions that are Normal. Please use this information to...
You are trying to decide whether to take a job after you graduate or go onto...
You are trying to decide whether to take a job after you graduate or go onto graduate school. Consider the following questions as you make your decision. A. Which of these costs, for the most part, would be relevant (R), and which would be irrelevant (IR)? ◦ Cost of your undergraduate education ◦ Salary with an undergraduate degree ◦ Salary with both an undergraduate degree and a graduate degree ◦ Rent ◦ Car Insurance ◦ Graduate school tuition and fees...
Rebecca is 29 and considering going to graduate school so she sits down to calculate whether...
Rebecca is 29 and considering going to graduate school so she sits down to calculate whether it is worth the large sum of money. She knows that her first year tuition will be $54,000, due at the beginning of the year (that is, right away). She estimates that the 2nd year of tuition would be $56,000. She also estimates that her living expenses above and beyond tuition will be $10,000 per year (assume this extra expense occurs at the end...
A graduate student in the School of Education is interested in whether families of students in...
A graduate student in the School of Education is interested in whether families of students in the Chicago Public Schools are for or against the new legislation proposing school uniform requirements. She surveys 600 students and finds that 480 are against the new legislation. Compute a 90 and 98 percent confidence interval for the true proportion who are for the new legislation.
At a local high school 80% of students who enter as freshmen go on to graduate....
At a local high school 80% of students who enter as freshmen go on to graduate. 20 freshmen are randomly selected. a. What is the probability that at most 12 students will go on to graduate? Round your answer to 4 decimal places. b. What is the probability that at at least 15 students will go on to graduate? Round your answer to 4 decimal places. c. What is the probability that at least 12 and no more than 16...
Beverly really wants to go to graduate school in psychology and has the grades to get...
Beverly really wants to go to graduate school in psychology and has the grades to get in, but she knows that she needs to have some research experience. She therefore begins working with Dr. Miserendino on a project in which she is observing white rats and measuring the amount of time it takes them to learn to navigate through a maze, depending on whether the animal has been given a drug or a placebo. Beverly is supposed to collect data...
You are looking to take out a ​$47,000 loan to pay for school. The loan would...
You are looking to take out a ​$47,000 loan to pay for school. The loan would be a​ five-year loan. The lender offers you a 7​% interest rate on the loan and also offers to structure it in one of three​ ways: what‘s your ending balance of the first year? ​a) As a discount loan ​b) As an​ interest-only loan c) As an amortized loan.
You are looking to take out a ​$53 ​,000 loan to pay for school. The loan...
You are looking to take out a ​$53 ​,000 loan to pay for school. The loan would be a​ five-year loan. The lender offers you a 8 ​% interest rate on the loan and also offers to structure it in one of three​ ways: ​a) As a discount loan ​b) As an​ interest-only loan ​c) As an amortized loan. Rounded to the nearest whole​ dollar, what will be your balance at the end of year 1 if you take the...
Cindy, who will graduate from college in a year is deciding whether to go on for...
Cindy, who will graduate from college in a year is deciding whether to go on for her master’s degree which will last two years. She figures that if she takes a job immediately, she can earn $40,000 per year in real terms for the remainder of her working years. If she goes on for two more years of graduate study, however, she can increase her earnings to $50,000 per year. The cost of tuition is $40,000 per year in real...
Cindy, who will graduate from college in a year is deciding whether to go on for...
Cindy, who will graduate from college in a year is deciding whether to go on for her master’s degree which will last two years. She figures that if she takes a job immediately, she can earn $40,000 per year in real terms for the remainder of her working years. If she goes on for two more years of graduate study, however, she can increase her earnings to $50,000 per year. The cost of tuition is $40,000 per year in real...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT