Question

In: Operations Management

What are Locke’s three criteria for justifying private property? In your answer be sure to give...

What are Locke’s three criteria for justifying private property? In your answer be sure to give the ethical dimensions for each, as well as state the empirical condition he made clear

Solutions

Expert Solution

The English physician and philosopher John Locke mentions in the 2nd Treaties of Government (work of political philosophy) that human beings have a right of private property in the form of an enforceable and natural right that they get by being in nature. According to Locke, God created both worldly resources and human beings. Men may exert labor upon the natural resources and have a natural right to property. The views of Locke (also termed as the Labour Theory of Property) justify the “Homestead” principal as well. According to homestead principal, a man will get the permanent ownership of a property or natural resource when he performs the act of appropriation and is the first at it. Locke says that all men are created by God and the preservation of mankind is the fundamental law of nature. All men have a right as well as the obligation of self-preservation and self-ownership. He also stresses that men would have starved themselves even after having all the resources if they would have waited for permissions. Because originally nobody could have possessed a private property or dominion, Locke says that labor is the primary and first condition that can be used for validating private ownership.

While human beings may be granted right to private property by God, there are also three conditions/criteria that should be sufficed for the justification of private ownership of the world resources, according to Locke.

First Criteria

Locke’s first criteria regarding human ownership and labor are that God gave the world and its resources to men, and for benefiting themselves and mankind. Locke finds labor as an extension of self-ownership only and says that it not only increases private property but also adds to the stock of the whole of mankind. Locke says that labor is the catalyst that when combined with ownership can give rise to new products.

But ambiguity occurs when Locke liaise improvement of a product with its ownership. Also, there may be more than one contributors involved in an improvement process, and therefore there may be no criteria for providing sole ownership. Therefore, proper criteria should be laid to decide the limits of entitlement and ownership.

Second Criteria

The second criteria or condition introduced by Locke was the “non-worsening” situation. Men can create value through their labor. If one percent of natural resource is used for producing a product, 99% of it may be formed through the use of labor. This can be as good as owning a hundred percent of the property or product created. Such value creation also does not deteriorates/worsens the situation of others.

While this theory may have merits in the short term, it may be difficult to know whether the condition of others has improved or worsened in the long run. Also, labor may cause a commonly shared good to be held privately. Private ownership may not be good for all the people. But any deviation will reduce the desire/motivation of people to innovate and to create something new.

Third Criteria

The third criteria or condition given by Locke is the nonspoilage condition. Locke says that God has granted men all the resources that they can utilize for themselves, and can also improve them for the good of mankind. It may be wrong to neglect this grant and favor given by God. Labour main bi unpleasant and the only justification for motivation for it may be the expectation, value, or outcomes it has. Therefore, people should enjoy all the compensation and rewards they get for their labor and property. Locke also supports money, as it cannot be spoilt and may be a perfect substitution as well. But when property and value generated is exchanged for money (which cannot be spoilt), it goes against the grant of the god. Once money creeps into the system, the resources may not be free to be used for all the people.

According to Locke, ownership of private property is a right of human beings that comes from the state of nature and God. Humans can appropriate property and worldly resources while meeting the three indispensable conditions/criteria. But these criteria do not support the holding of unlimited private property, which Lock seems to indirectly support.


Related Solutions

1) What are private property rights? Why are private property rights so important? In your answer,...
1) What are private property rights? Why are private property rights so important? In your answer, please emphasize the role of private property rights incentives. 2) Elaborate upon the role that well-defined private property rights plays in business. How can organizations adjust how they approach the enforcement of property rights given their overall strategy and placement within the market?
For each statement, determine whether the statement is true or false. Give a sentence justifying your answer.
For each statement, determine whether the statement is true or false. Give a sentence justifying your answer. a. If tan(t)=0, then cos(t)=1 . b. The function f(x)=sin(x)cos(x) has period 2π. c. The graph of r = 1 is the unit circle. d. Two angles with the same cosine value must have the same sine value. e. The point (0, -3) in Cartesean coordinates can also be described by the ordered pair (-3, π/2) in polar coordinates
What are the three categories of moral responsibility? Be sure to give an example of each....
What are the three categories of moral responsibility? Be sure to give an example of each. (natural, vountary, solidarity - please explain)
What is the basis for property rights? Why is private property crucial to capitalism and what...
What is the basis for property rights? Why is private property crucial to capitalism and what are its benefits?
By justifying your answer determine whether the function T is a linear transformation. T:P3→ P4defined as...
By justifying your answer determine whether the function T is a linear transformation. T:P3→ P4defined as T(a+bx+cx2+dx3)=b−ax+adx4 T:P3→ M2,2 defined as T(a+bx+cx2+dx3)= [−d,c,√3a,a+b] its a matrix
Public-Private Partnerships When you are asked to share personal information, what are your criteria for sharing...
Public-Private Partnerships When you are asked to share personal information, what are your criteria for sharing it? Does the identity of the person who is asking determine your ease or restraint in sharing? How important is it for you to know how the information will be used? Does knowing that the information shared could impact the well-being of your community make a difference? When the need for information exchange is present, benefits are weighed against the risks. Imagine the complexity...
Discuss the three criteria for a well-functioning system of markets( honesty, information and property rights) in...
Discuss the three criteria for a well-functioning system of markets( honesty, information and property rights) in terms of economic efficiency.
Explain how Beachside Ltd should account for the following items/situations, justifying your answer by reference to...
Explain how Beachside Ltd should account for the following items/situations, justifying your answer by reference to the Conceptual Framework’s definitions and recognition criteria. (i) Beachside Ltd is the guarantor for an employee’s bank loan:      You have no reason to believe the employee will default on the loan. As the employee is in serious financial difficulties, you think it likely that he will default on the loan. (ii)  Beachside Ltd receives 5 000 shares in Monty Ltd, trading at $6 each, as...
3) give three characteristics of closed or private communicators at their "best" and three characteristics of...
3) give three characteristics of closed or private communicators at their "best" and three characteristics of closed or private communicators at their "worst".
What were Locke’s three primary reasons for keeping government and religion separate? Which one of those...
What were Locke’s three primary reasons for keeping government and religion separate? Which one of those reasons do you think is the most applicable today, and why?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT