The only cost effective test available demonstrates a positive predictive value of less than 50%. What...

The only cost effective test available demonstrates a positive predictive value of less than 50%. What ethical and economic concerns do you have about using this test for screening the population for an STD infection? (Consider what we know about the effect of prevalence on predictive value.) This question takes into account that the prevalence is low

Solutions

Expert Solution

The measure of frequency of occurance of a disease in a specified at risk population at a specific time is called as Prevalence.

Prevalence = Total number of persons with a disease / Population at risk for the disease

For example,if the prevalence of a disease is 1% of the total population, then approximately 1 in 100 people are expected to be affected with that disease before any diagnostic testings. Thus,the Prevalence of a disease have an impact on the positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of tests.

Predictive value of a test is the number of times the result generated were proved to be correct. Positive predictive value(PPV), is the actual percentage of people affected with the disease condition out of those who were tested positive during screening process. Negative Predictive Value (NPV) is the actual percentage of people who are not having a disease out of those who tested negative. Predictive values are effective tools that aids in clinical decision-making as it gives a measurement of possibility of an individual to contract a particular disease. Also the PPV and NPV vary dramatically depending on the prevalence of the condition in the specific population being tested.

Screening tests are considered as the corner stones to secondary prevention. A Periodic health screening helps in early detection a disease. In case of infectious diseases, screening tests contributes to breaking the chain of transmission thus prevent onset of new cases.

Characteristics of good screening test:

Some of the necessary qualities of an effective screening tests are

Simple and quick to administer.
Inexpensive and safe to use.
Readily available and provides access to a proper plan of treatment if results are positive.
Acceptable to the target population.
Needs to be researched adequately and proven to be valid, reliable, and must have good predictive values.

Mass screening for prediction of probability of occurance is important when the incidence of cases are high in a particular set of population. For such a population it is not ethical to administer a test with only half chances of positive predictive values. That means a screening test can be cost-effective if the disease condition is common enough and the test results are accurate enough. A test is considered to be cost-effective also, if the patients who are tested positive have access to effective treatment measures at an affordable cost. A test with only half chances of beigng accurate, definitely cannot be administered to a vulnerable population as it affects the promptness in initiating care measures. Here the population mentioned have a low prevalance rate of STDs. A screening test with high sensitivity,specificity and predictability,may still have a low PPV if the disease prevalence is sufficiently low in the target population.

Nightingale answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

4. What is the predictive value of positive test? What does this mean in words and what does this mean for the practical value of the test?

Sensitivity and Specificity We are interested in looking at the connection between a test and a disease to investigate the ability of the test to distinguish between sick and healthy. We look at a sample of 50,000 people who have been tested for a particular disease. Of these, 100 have the disease. Of the 100 who have the disease, 95 are receiving positive test results. Of those who are healthy, there are 48902 people who get negative test results....

Assuming the test statistic is less than than the critical value, what is your conclusion? a....

Assuming the test statistic is less than than the critical value, what is your conclusion? a. Reject the null hypothesis b. Reject the alternative hypothesis c. Fail to reject the null hypothesis d. Both b. and c. are correct Assuming we reject the null hypothesis in the test above above, what is your interpretation of this result? a. Tesla's new cars can travel further than their old cars. b. Tesla's old cars can travel further than their new cars. c....

Simple Linear Regression Hypothesis Test A researcher was interested in whether there was a positive predictive...

Simple Linear Regression Hypothesis Test A researcher was interested in whether there was a positive predictive relationship between the number of years employed at a company and the annual salary in dollars. The following data was obtained for 10 participants: Table 1 Data for Salary/Years of Job Experience Case Years Salary (x 1000 $) 1 1 27.314 2 4 61.870 3 6 42.755 4 10 78.096 5 15 54.180 6 20 95.735 7 22 94.320 8 3 45.720 9 8...

To test Upper H 0: mu equals 50 versus Upper H 1: mu less than 50,...

To test Upper H 0: mu equals 50 versus Upper H 1: mu less than 50, a random sample of size n equals 22 is obtained from a population that is known to be normally distributed. Complete parts (a) through (d) below. LOADING... Click here to view the t-Distribution Area in Right Tail. (a) If x over bar equals 47.1 and s equals 12.9, compute the test statistic. t 0 equals nothing (Round to three decimal places as needed.)

A formula with a positive integer (less than 32 bits) and a positive decimal (number with...

A formula with a positive integer (less than 32 bits) and a positive decimal (number with decimal points) is expressed in the median formula. Change the given median to postfix and write a program that outputs the results of the calculation. operand ::= positive integer or positive error Positive integer ::= A number expressed as less than 32 bits consisting of 0 to 9. Positive integer representation of 0, 0100, 00934, 1056, 65535 is allowed Positive decimal ::= Positive integer...

1)Under the net-present-value method, if the cost of the asset is less than the present value...

1)Under the net-present-value method, if the cost of the asset is less than the present value of the future cash flows, the: investment's expected return is greater than the firm's cost of capital firm's cost of capital is greater than the rate of return on assets net-present-value is negative investment should not be made 2) A capital investment generates a satisfactory rate of return when its return is: Greater than the internal rate of return Less than the cost of...

14. Claim: The average cost to repair a smart phone is less than $100. Test at...

14. Claim: The average cost to repair a smart phone is less than $100. Test at α = 0.1. Data: 7 smart phone repairs are chosen at random. The average of these is $95.56, with a standard deviation of $20. (a) Are these data statistically significant evidence to support the claim? (b) Are these data statistically significant evidence to refute the claim?

Much research in Positive Psychology demonstrates that excellence is learned rather than uniquely an innate genetic...

Much research in Positive Psychology demonstrates that excellence is learned rather than uniquely an innate genetic trait. Essential elements towards achieving excellence include: dedication and frequent practice, a strong intrinsic interest in developing one's expertise, and persistence over time. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, excellence requires a passion for one's area of interest. For this discussion research an example of an individual you find to demonstrate true "excellence". Explain how they fit the definition of excellence in terms of the...

Find the p-value of the test. A) Less than 0.25% B) Between 0.25% and 0.5% C)...

Find the p-value of the test. A) Less than 0.25% B) Between 0.25% and 0.5% C) Between 0.5% and 1% D) Between 1% and 2.5% E) Between 2.5% and 5% F) Between 5% and 10% G) Between 10% and 15% H) Between 15% and 20% I) Between 15% and 20% J) Bigger than 20%. Are births really evenly distributed across the days of a week? Here are data on 700 births in a hospital: Day Sun. Mon. Tue. Wed. Thu....

In cost Accounting if Budgeted cost is less than Actual cost what it called over costed...

In cost Accounting if Budgeted cost is less than Actual cost what it called over costed or under cost? what is differents between current method and Activity based method

Subjects