What are the advantages of a federal system? What are
the disadvantages?
What are the advantages of a federal system? What are
the disadvantages?
Solutions
Expert Solution
Advantages:
As a Protection Against Tyranny – One of the
most important points of federalism in dividing the power between
the national government and state governments, and spreading the
national government’s power among three branches that serve as a
check and balance on each other, is that it serves as a deterrent
to tyranny and runaway power. The protections we have in our system
against a tyrannical, runaway government are one of the most
important points to why the system was designed the way it
was.
Diffusing Power – The form of federalism that
we have in our country, where power is shared with state
governments, and where the federal government is separated into
three branches, serves as a means to make sure that all power is
not centralized into a single person or group of people, since
excessive power among a single group tends to be corrupting.
Increasing Citizen Participation – By not
centralizing all power into the hands of a national government, but
sharing that power with state governments, which are closer to the
level of the common citizen, our founders actually increased a
citizen’s ability to effect their government, government policy,
and lawmaking.
More Efficient – When some of the power of the
government is dispersed among the states, giving states the right
to solve some of their own problems, you allow for more efficiency
within the system. To try to have a national solution to all
problems, which could be refered to as a ‘cookie-cutter method’ of
law and policy making, you end up with solutions that are more
effective in some states, and less effective in others. To allow
states to create solutions to their own problems, using policies
and laws that work best in their state, means that each state can
come up with its own solution, making government more
efficient.
Conflict Management – By allowing different
communities and states to create their own policies, they allow for
people with irreconcilable differences, or very strong
disagreements, to live in separate areas, and create their own
solutions, or policies, that would be totally disagreeable to the
other people in other states or regions of the country.
Innovation in Law and Policy is Encouraged –
By allowing for many state governments, different sets of policies
can be tried, and the ones found most effective at solving its
problems can then be implemented in other states, or on the
national level. Imagine Christopher Columbus trying to get funding
to voyage across the Atlantic Ocean if there was a unified Europe
back then, with its head saying ‘no!’ to him; instead, he had
several governments from which he could try to get his funding – he
got turned down by several governments before Spain gave him the
okay. The same principle applies today with our many states –
something that is rejected in one state can most likely be tried in
another state, with competition leading the way, based on
effectiveness of those laws.
State Governments Can be More Responsive to Citizen
Needs – The closer a government entity is to its citizens,
the more likely it is the respond to the needs of citizens. States
are more likely to listen to citidzen needs, and respond to them,
than the national government would be.
Disadvantages
had a History of Protecting Slavery and Segregation
–This is often cited as one of the main detriments of the
system of federalism that we have in this country, that since
slavery was a state issue, it was something that could not be
removed on the national level.
It Allows for Inequalities Between Different States
– For example, instead of education funding throughout the
country being the same, since it is a state issue, some states will
spend more, per capita, on education than other states, causing
what could be considered a disparity. The same goes for other
things, as well, such as taxes, health care programs, and welfare
programs.
The Blockage of Nationalist Policies by States
– States can fight against the existence of certain
national laws by challenging them in court, or going out of their
way to not enforce those national laws, or even deliberately
obstructing enforcement of national laws.
Racing to the Bottom – One argument given is
that states will compete with each other in an oppositional way, by
reducing the amount of benefits they give to welfare recipients
compared to, say, a neighboring state, motivating the undesirables
to go to the neighboring state, thereby reducing their welfare
costs even more. This reduction of state benefits to needy has been
deemed the ‘race to the bottom.’
What are the advantages and disadvantages of decentralized
government? Why can a federal system of government take advantage
of both centralized and decentralized collective decision making?
Why are local governments likely to be limited to a greater degree
than the central government in the extent to which they can engage
in redistribution and stabilization programs?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of an
asynchronous system?
What is a fundamental mode of an asynchronous system?
Why is it important that asynchronous circuits be hazard free?