Question

In: Economics

Make a reasonable argument for the "American bystander" approach as the best approach for this situations

Make a reasonable argument for the "American bystander" approach as the best approach for this situations

Solutions

Expert Solution

Dear Student,

Please find below answer to your question

Abstract

Let us understand this argument from Economic Point of view, Historically the Good Samaritan Rule is named after a story in the Bible in which a Samaritan an ethnicity of people the Jews generally disliked at the time helps a Jew in a time of need, thus making him the "good Samaritan.""

It says essentially that we have some obligation, either morally or legally, to help others who need help. When you ask people, most of them agree with something similar to this; if you can help without great cost to yourself, you ought to do so.

The American Bystander Rule, on the other hand, is a legal doctrine in common law (originating in the US, hence the name) that bystanders do not have any legal or criminal liability for failing to help someone in need, even if they could have done so very easily.

One of the arguments in its favor is that people already tend to help out of a feeling of moral obligation; but if they don't (and some people don't!), the American Bystander Rule requires that they cannot be punished for their inaction.

Both principles prescribe approaches to dealing with incidents where someone helps or doesn't help someone else; but they prescribe fundamentally opposite actions.

The Good Samaritan Rule says that we must help; the American Bystander Rule says that we do not need to help, and no one can punish us if we don't.

It is possible to believe in the Good Samaritan Rule morally but the American Bystander Rule legally, on the grounds of personal liberty:

Perhaps the government has no right to compel you to act, even if morally you should.

However the reasonable argument for the "American bystander" approach is validated

If you like the answer, Kindly up vote

Thank You!!


Related Solutions

Make a reasonable argument for the "Good Samaritan" doctrine as the best approach for this situations
Make a reasonable argument for the "Good Samaritan" doctrine as the best approach for this situations
Make an argument that the income based approach / earnings based approach is the best business...
Make an argument that the income based approach / earnings based approach is the best business valuation approach.
In brief paragraph Explain the Electoral College and make your best argument for why it should...
In brief paragraph Explain the Electoral College and make your best argument for why it should be preserved or eliminated. Is it still serving a legitimate function or is it an impediment to real democracy?
Make an argument that Facebook is indeed a monopoly. In developing your argument make sure to...
Make an argument that Facebook is indeed a monopoly. In developing your argument make sure to address relevant ideas such as competition, conditions for emergence of a monopoly, profit maximization and the like. Discuss the potential consequences of a Facebook monopoly and what, from a public policy perspective might be done about it?
Explain what capital structure theory (or theories) best describes the following situations. Make sure to cite...
Explain what capital structure theory (or theories) best describes the following situations. Make sure to cite at least one of the required textbook chapters for each answer, and to cite at least two references for this section: A CEO decides to borrow $50,000 in new debt, and the share prices rise dramatically. He then decides to sell half of his own personal shares, and when this is reported in the Wall Street Journal, the share prices drop dramatically in value....
Find the reasonable final state of Ks using CAPM as well as DCF approach. If the...
Find the reasonable final state of Ks using CAPM as well as DCF approach. If the rRF = 7%, RPM = 6%, and the firm’s beta is 1.2, what’s the cost of common equity based upon the CAPM? Also calculate the required rate of return with DCF approach if the current dividend is $4.19 and P0 = $50. The firm has been earning 12% on equity and retaining 40% of its earnings. This situation is expected to continue. (5)
Is the Morkowitz Theory the best Approach for all Portfolios?
Is the Morkowitz Theory the best Approach for all Portfolios? Explain Markowitzâs train of thought about why investors should seek an efficient portfolio.  
Explain which approach you think is the best approach for defining legal duties to act. Be...
Explain which approach you think is the best approach for defining legal duties to act. Be sure to explain the reasons for your position
In 400 words, make an ethical argument either in support in surrogacy or against surrogacy. Make...
In 400 words, make an ethical argument either in support in surrogacy or against surrogacy. Make sure that you support your argument by both ethical principles?
Make and support an argument about rather or not it is ethical for physicians to participate...
Make and support an argument about rather or not it is ethical for physicians to participate in a death row executions? Use at least one ethical principles to support your argument.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT