Question

In: Psychology

Choose a policy designed to address a social problem. Briefly describe the policy and at least...

Choose a policy designed to address a social problem. Briefly describe the policy and at least three categories of critiques applied to the policy. Be sure to state which of the categories of critiques in your text applies to each example.

Solutions

Expert Solution

  • Affirmative action is a policy or program whose stated goal is to redress past or present discrimination through active measures to ensure equal opportunity, generally to higher education and employment. The stated goal of affirmative action is to counteract discrimination sufficiently such that the power elite reflect the demographics of society at large, at which point such a strategy will no longer be necessary. Groups who are targeted for affirmative action are characterized by race, gender, ethnicity, or disability status.
  • Proponents of affirmative action generally advocate it either as a means to address past discrimination or to enhance racial, ethnic, gender, or other diversity. Proponents argue that the simple adoption of meritocratic principles of race blindness or gender blindness will not suffice to change the situation for several reasons:
  • (1) Discriminatory practices of the past preclude the acquisition of “merit” by limiting access to educational opportunities and job experiences; (2) ostensible measures of “merit” may be biased toward the same groups who are already empowered; and (3) regardless of overt principles, people already in positions of power are likely to hire people they already know or people from similar backgrounds.
  • Opponents claim that affirmative action: (1) acts as a new form of discrimination and benefits privileged individuals within minority racial groups (such as middle-to upper-class blacks) at the expense of disenfranchised individuals within majority racial groups (such as poor whites); (2) increases racial tension and creates a stigma such that all minority groups within a college or employment setting are perceived as having received special treatment; and (3) creates a skill “mismatch” (i.e., individuals who are less qualified than their peers are admitted into more rigorous programs in which they cannot adequately perform).
  • A central issue in the evaluation of social policy interventions is how the outcome of interest is defined. Many Americans contend that because high poverty rates continue to exist in the United States, antipoverty programs must be ineffective. However, many public assistance programs have accomplished exactly what they were intended to accomplish.
  • Affirmative action is an example of a controversial social policy that provokes intense debate regarding its effects. The evidence suggests that affirmative action has had a major impact on the representation of minorities in university admissions and employment, even if the overall numbers of redistributed positions is small.
  • Replacement of affirmative action programs based on race and gender with class-based practices is likely to reduce the presence of minorities on college campuses while doing little to improve the overall position of white males.
  • There is some evidence that the performance of students admitted to colleges and universities with the aid of affirmative action lags behind that of students admitted without such aid. However, there may be an overall benefit to more diversity on campuses.
  • Moreover, minority students benefit greatly in the labor market from having attended college. Nevertheless, affirmative action programs remain under intense challenge.

Related Solutions

What is the social challenge that the Medicaid policy is designed to address? – What does...
What is the social challenge that the Medicaid policy is designed to address? – What does the Medicaid policy offer? – Who is eligible to receive the policy benefits? – How redistributive is the policy?
Choose one of the theories (e.g., behaviorism, cognitivism, social learning theory, Gestalt). Briefly describe the central...
Choose one of the theories (e.g., behaviorism, cognitivism, social learning theory, Gestalt). Briefly describe the central concepts of the theory. Then, describe one strength and one weakness of the theory. When explaining the strength and weakness, specifically state how that theory is stronger or weaker than another theory in a specific way.
What economic challenges is Fiscal policy designed to address?  nonplagarized material and answer must be 250...
What economic challenges is Fiscal policy designed to address?  nonplagarized material and answer must be 250 words
what are policy action to address the social determinants of coronary heart disease? give the title....
what are policy action to address the social determinants of coronary heart disease? give the title. consice background that covers all important and relevent information and provide a strong rationale for policy change. policy actions and implications of coronary heart disease. realistic recommendation for action based on firm evidence. compelling arguments.
What is a a social problem related to the environment and caused qat least at in...
What is a a social problem related to the environment and caused qat least at in part by our growing population and its effects on our planet. Describe this problem and how it is linked to our growing population and the effect it as on the environment.
Choose a brand and address the following: 1) Describe the organization’s founding, mission and values, and...
Choose a brand and address the following: 1) Describe the organization’s founding, mission and values, and any challenges or opportunities it faced. 2) In reviewing how the brand has evolved, which of the six reasons (New Company or New Product, Name Change, Revitalize a Brand, Revitalize a Brand Identity, Create an Integrated System, Company Merger) would have impacted the current branding used by the organization? 3) Did the organization engage in the branding process due to financial reasons (ex. launching...
What is a social contract? Briefly describe the “social contract approach to journalism ethics” in terms...
What is a social contract? Briefly describe the “social contract approach to journalism ethics” in terms of the privileges and obligations of the press.
choose a social problem and discuss it in the context of stephen pfohl's 5 components of...
choose a social problem and discuss it in the context of stephen pfohl's 5 components of critical theorizing
Briefly describe the characteristics of cross-functional business processes. Also, briefly describe at least three business benefits...
Briefly describe the characteristics of cross-functional business processes. Also, briefly describe at least three business benefits of cross-functional business processes.  
To complete this assignment address each of the following in your paper: Describe the physical, social,...
To complete this assignment address each of the following in your paper: Describe the physical, social, and cognitive changes that occur in middle adulthood for men. Describe the physical, social, and cognitive changes that occur in middle adulthood for women. Describe the psychosocial stage: generativity versus stagnation. Describe how physical, social, and cognitive changes can impact this psychosocial stage. Identify the challenges of the sandwich generation. Provide recommendations 3 to 4 recommendations for someone currently in the sandwich generation. Describe...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT