Question

In: Nursing

The Case In How Doctors Think, author Dr. Jerome Groopman reflects on the reasoning process that...

The Case

In How Doctors Think, author Dr. Jerome Groopman reflects on the reasoning process that doctors use to arrive at a diagnosis. He refers to the problem of physicians becoming “locked in” to a diagnosis so early in the process that they overlook the important clues. The result, very often, is an incorrect diagnosis and inappropriate treatment.

The best example I can recall involved my twin brother, John.

He had developed chronic pain in his right hip and was referred to an orthopedic surgeon for advice. The surgeon obtained a CT scan of the hip. It showed some activity at the head of the femur, suggesting the possibility of a cancerous growth. My brother called me from San Francisco (he was on a business trip) and I advised him to arrange a visit with an oncologist at the university hospital located in his hometown. I flew up to be with him during a day of consultations and examinations.

The oncologist, with knowledge of a possible malignancy involving the head of the femur, ordered a new CT scan of the hip. It showed evidence of increased blood flow, furthering the conclusion that there was a tumor. At that time, I asked whether the pain could be due to aseptic necrosis (bone death caused by poor blood supply) of the hip. The response: “Oh no, the nuclear scan would not light up like this. It would be just the opposite.”

A chest x-ray was obtained as part of the workup for presumed metastatic carcinoma. The radiologist noted numerous tiny densities throughout both lungs. Equipped with the referral note from the oncologist and the interpretation of the CT scan, he said to me, “This has to be metastatic carcinoma.”

Late in the afternoon, the oncologist informed John that all findings indicated cancer that had traveled to his bone and lung. (The three main cancers in men that metastasize to both bone and lung are prostate, lung, and lymphoma.) A biopsy of the hip lesion was arranged, and we returned home where John sat down with his family and shared what the doctors had said. He told everyone that he had enjoyed a good life and was ready to die. Many tears were shed.

But John looked very healthy for a man with a tumor that had metastasized to his lungs and bone. Except for his hip pain, he felt well. Sure enough, when the biopsy was done, there was no cancer found. Evidence of aseptic necrosis was found, however, which was healing spontaneously. This explained the findings on the CT scan. Again, there was much cheering and more tears among the family members—this time, though, it was tears of joy and relief.

(The report of a chest x-ray taken some years earlier in another city was tracked down and found to be identical with that of the current chest x-ray—findings thought to be scarring from old granulomas, small areas of inflammation due to tissue injury.)

Within a matter of weeks, John’s hip pain disappeared!

Please provide an assessment of what the facility can do going forward to create a culture of quality and safety.

Solutions

Expert Solution


Related Solutions

1) How doseany author explain the shareholder theory requires no ethical reasoning? and why? 2) why...
1) How doseany author explain the shareholder theory requires no ethical reasoning? and why? 2) why does use of the shareholder theory prevent effective resolution of the 13 common business practices?
PROMPT:  The author offers what he claims to be a simple proposal on how regulators should think...
PROMPT:  The author offers what he claims to be a simple proposal on how regulators should think about concentrated industries: “…when members of a concentrated industry act in parallel, their conduct should be treated like that of a hypothetical monopoly.” Explain why you believe that members of a concentrated industry should or should not be considered similar to a monopoly. Comment on whether there is in fact a problem that needs to be resolved if firms in the same industry happen...
Part II: Case Study Market Research Example: How Coca-Cola Lost Millions with This Mistake Author: Scott...
Part II: Case Study Market Research Example: How Coca-Cola Lost Millions with This Mistake Author: Scott Smith, Ph.D. Source: Qualtrics In the mid-1980s, the Coca-Cola Company made a decision to introduce a new beverage product (Hartley, 1995, pp. 129–145). The company had evidence that taste was the single most important cause of Coke’s decline in the market share in the late 1970s and early 1980s. A new product dubbed “New Coke” was developed that was sweeter than the original-formula Coke....
How far do you think doctors should go to save someone who has been declared brain-dead?...
How far do you think doctors should go to save someone who has been declared brain-dead? How should this be determined? Explain
Describe how your diagnostic reasoning process has evolved after experience this course. Find one scholarly article...
Describe how your diagnostic reasoning process has evolved after experience this course. Find one scholarly article on the subject of diagnostic skills and clinical reasoning of Advanced Practice Registered Nurses and summarize your findings. Use at least one evidence-based scholarly source in support of your discussion
Please describe how you think models of events for the purpose of studying a case might...
Please describe how you think models of events for the purpose of studying a case might influence the outcome and accuracy of the proceeding. Are models and recreations helpful in the pursuit of a just outcome or not
discuss how you think companies make capital budgeting decisions and how the process would be different...
discuss how you think companies make capital budgeting decisions and how the process would be different during special times, such as pandemic?
Do you think differently about the process of how carbohydrate, lipids and protein are metabolized and...
Do you think differently about the process of how carbohydrate, lipids and protein are metabolized and energy is released? Or perhaps about how the pathways in metabolism work? Does it make sense now why lipids have 9 kcalories per gram and carbohydrate and protein have 4 kcalories per gram?
for a fraud investigation the current trends in interview techniques. How do you think this process...
for a fraud investigation the current trends in interview techniques. How do you think this process has changed over the years or do you believe it has remained the same? Provide 3 questions you would ask a suspect during an initial interview and 3 questions you would ask a suspect during a follow up interview. Be sure to explain your reasons for the questions asked
Think of a recent purchase you made in your everyday life. Explain how the purchasing process...
Think of a recent purchase you made in your everyday life. Explain how the purchasing process would be different if you were buying the same product for a firm on a regular basis versus purchasing it for yourself. Please write clear complete sentences and answer the question with great detail.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT