Question

In: Physics

What are the advantages for "professional astronomers" of the Cassegrain design over the Newtonian design?

What are the advantages for "professional astronomers" of the Cassegrain design over the Newtonian design?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Most reflector telescopes will use a smaller secondary mirror in front of of the large primary mirror to reflect the light to a more convenient viewing spot. Isaac Newton used a flat secondary mirror at a 45° angle to reflect the light to an eyepiece at the side of the telescope tube near the top. Such an arrangement, called a newtonian design is used by many amateur telescopes.

Many reflector telescope use another light path design called the cassegrain design to reflect the light back through a hole in the primary mirror, so that detectors or the eyepiece can be conveniently placed behind the telescope. Most of the large telescopes used for research, including the Hubble Space Telescope, are of this design. Some of the largest telescopes like the Hale Telescope and the Keck Telescope have places to put detectors at the prime focus, where the light from the primary mirror first comes to a focus. The images in reflector telescopes do not have holes or shadows in them because the light rays from the unblocked parts of the primary mirror are all added together when they are focussed together. Even though part of the primary mirror is blocked or missing, there is still plenty of usable primary mirror space to gather the light.

Advantages:

The main reason is that Cassegrain telescopes are much shorter than Newtonians for the same focal length. This means that the overall cost of the observatory, which includes a mount, dome, and building, will be much lower.

secondary reason is that professional telescopes use heavy detectors at the focus of the telescope. Newtonian telescopes put the focus on the side of the telescope, so heavy instruments and detectors would need to be placed on the side of the telescope; in general, this can make things difficult, because the weight on the focus exerts a variable torque on the telescope's tube.


Related Solutions

There are a number of reasons why professional astronomers locate their telescopes on the tops of...
There are a number of reasons why professional astronomers locate their telescopes on the tops of remote mountains. List two of those reasons.
What are the observations which cause astronomers to conclude that galaxies change over time.
What are the observations which cause astronomers to conclude that galaxies change over time.
What does it mean to be a professional? Also what are the advantages of being a...
What does it mean to be a professional? Also what are the advantages of being a professional versus an employee, and are there any disadvantages?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of implementing Design of Experiment based on factorial design and...
What are the advantages and disadvantages of implementing Design of Experiment based on factorial design and One Factor at a Time (OFAT)? Give examples to your answer!
What is the insurance that covers the professional negligence of design professionals?
law and ethicsWhat is the insurance that covers the professional negligence of design professionals?a.commerical claims made insuranceb. builders risk insurancec. owners controlled insuranced. errors and omissions insurancee. all of the above
What are the advantages of ICP over flame AA?
What are the advantages of ICP over flame AA?
What are 5 advantages of a seed over a spore?
What are 5 advantages of a seed over a spore?
what is the advantages to use PID controller in control system design ?
what is the advantages to use PID controller in control system design ?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of both REST and Student Super Professional Super Funds in...
What are the advantages and disadvantages of both REST and Student Super Professional Super Funds in terms of investment options, returns and risk allocation, associated fees and insurance premiums? Which fund will make a young person better off in the short term and better off in the long term?
What is optimization? What is simulation? What are the advantages of simulation over optimization and vice...
What is optimization? What is simulation? What are the advantages of simulation over optimization and vice versa?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT