Question

In: Nursing

Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation,...

Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation, health of individuals in society, or distributive justice. What are the controversies surrounding this issue? What are the opposing ethical principles? How has past or current health policy addressed this dilemma? Support your reasoning with reference citations.

Solutions

Expert Solution

An ethical dilemma concerning health policies is notable in Preventative Punishment. Morally, the theory of Utilitarianism may justify preventive detention – i.e., punishment related not to actual wrongdoing but to expected wrongdoing, IF there was a sufficiently high amount of expected utility to be gained from doing so. However, morally, this would result in punishment of persons who were not (yet) actually guilty of any wrongdoing. Distributive Justice is concerned with the distinction between Preventive Confinement and involuntary commitment under mental health legislation. However, involuntary commitment undertaken on health grounds or in order to protect the person or others is considered Paternalism. Health policies and legislation negative preventative incarceration due to their morally infallible grounds. However, if a person is temporarily detained for treatment and then released once treatment has helped with recovery, it is morally just as well as in line with policy and health legislation. According to Greene and Cohen, Punishing the innocent, for instance, would involve systematic deception and corruption.

Reference:

Greene, J. D., Nystrom, L. E., Engell, A. D., Darley, J. M., & Cohen, J. D. (2004). The Neural Bases of Cognitive Conflict and Control in Moral Judgment. Neuron,44(2), 389-400.


Related Solutions

Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation,...
Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation, health of individuals in society, or distributive justice. What are the controversies surrounding this issue? What are the opposing ethical principles? How has past or current health policy addressed this dilemma?
Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation,...
Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation, health of individuals in society, or distributive justice. What are the controversies surrounding this issue? What are the opposing ethical principles? How has past or current health policy addressed this dilemma? Support your reasoning with reference citations.
Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation,...
Select an ethical dilemma related to health policy from the categories of moral values, professional regulation, health of individuals in society, or distributive justice. What are the controversies surrounding this issue? What are the opposing ethical principles? How has past or current health policy addressed this dilemma? Support your reasoning with reference citations.
Provide one example of a laboratory related ethical or professional dilemma and explain why the example...
Provide one example of a laboratory related ethical or professional dilemma and explain why the example presents dilemma.
Provide a brief description of the ethical dilemma, including your opinion on the ethical dilemma. Select...
Provide a brief description of the ethical dilemma, including your opinion on the ethical dilemma. Select an ethical theory (Golden Rule, virtue, utilitarianism, or universalism) that supports your personal belief.
Discuss Professional Responsibility of engineers in a situation of ethical dilemma.
 1. Discuss Professional Responsibility of engineers in a situation of ethical dilemma. CLO1(2.5) 2. How individualism effect the situation when whistle blowing is going on? CLO2 (2.5) 3. Why safety is important in state of practicing whistle blowing? CLO3 (2.5) 4. How much the impact of personality and cultural norms effect on engineer's responsibilities in society? CL04 (2.5) CLO 1: Discuss awareness of professional, social and ethical responsibility in engineering practice CLO 2: Distinguish between individual behavior and behavior in a group CLO 3: Choose different...
A human service professional is working with a particularly difficult client wno presents an ethical dilemma to this professional.
A human service professional is working with a particularly difficult client wno presents an ethical dilemma to this professional. In responding to the client, the professional realizes that if he uses the NOHS ethical code, he would have to respond in one way, but if he uses the APA code, he can respond in a different manner, more in harmony with what he would like to do. He decides to go with the APA code. Is this ethical? Professional? Legal?
Explore an ethical dilemma from the documentary the waiting room 2012. Describe one ethical dilemma. What...
Explore an ethical dilemma from the documentary the waiting room 2012. Describe one ethical dilemma. What individual s and groups have an important stake in the outcome and discuss three options that could be used for resolution of the dilemma.
Identify an ethical dilemma. Use the values clarification process to explore and confirm your values. Use...
Identify an ethical dilemma. Use the values clarification process to explore and confirm your values. Use the ethical decision making process to identify a specific action.
Think about an ethical dilemma you have confronted in your practice. Select an ethical framework to...
Think about an ethical dilemma you have confronted in your practice. Select an ethical framework to help you think through this dilemma in a meaningful way. Would you find this framework helpful as you encounter ethical dilemmas in your future practice? (Minimum 1 word, maximum 500 words. Once submitted, your response cannot be edited. This response will be posted on a public discussion wall for all your classmates to view.)
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT