Business law: Eminent domain is the constitutional principle that the government can take private property from...

Business law:

Eminent domain is the constitutional principle that the government can take private property from an owner for a public purpose with fair compensation. Examples would be to build an airport, a park, or a highway. One controversial Supreme Court case allowed a city government to transfer ownership from one set of owners to a private corporation for a new headquarters building. The city said it was for "urban renewal" and would bring in more money for the city. Share your thoughts about whether this is a fair public use or if that transfer or ownership should not have been allowed.

Expert Solution

What is fair is a matter of one's own judgement.

Although we find a pattern in which one may think.

The main factor here to be considered is the Constitution of the country in which this transfer took place. In constitution, the power of government has been defined clearly. So no government can do what is not in its power (Ultra-Vires). If a government do so, every citizen of the country has the right to sue that government.

Nevertheless, we can't just comment whether which of the party is right without knowing the reason behind both of the parties action. From the given information, it is clear that the transfer is made for public benefit even though made to a private company. Assuming there is no secret profit made by any government or any government's officer, it is fair use.

ekkarill92 answered 2 years ago

Historically, the exercise of eminent domain has been limited to the taking of private lands for...

Historically, the exercise of eminent domain has been limited to the taking of private lands for public works projects---roads, schools, water treatment projects, etc. Within the past couple of years in the Northeast, a city took (via its power of eminent domain) private land to be used for private commercial purposes as a means to increase the municipality's tax base (i.e., taking family homes for the construction of a Wal-Mart, although this was not exactly the case in this instance)....

Topic: Should Eminent Domain Be Used to promote Private Development? Please explain in 4-5 paragraphs with...

Topic: Should Eminent Domain Be Used to promote Private Development? Please explain in 4-5 paragraphs with no plaigiarism

What is Public Sector Law and how is it different from Constitutional Law and Administrative Law?

How is property law relevant to business? If a business is thinking about acquiring property, what...

How is property law relevant to business? If a business is thinking about acquiring property, what are the important considerations?

A) According to Madison and the Constitution, what is the role of government and private property?...

A) According to Madison and the Constitution, what is the role of government and private property? B) In Property, Madison stated, “In a word, as a man is said to have a right to his property, he may be equally said to have a property in his rights.” Interpret what you think Madison meant. C) What is the correlation between property and rights, such as free speech, press, and assembly?

Business law survey: The US Court system is a great system, but can take a lot...

Business law survey: The US Court system is a great system, but can take a lot of time. Some parties have put mandatory arbitration clauses in their contracts. Given what you know about the court system and ADR, share your thoughts on whether Courts should enforce arbitration agreements and force parties to arbitrate instead of using the court system.

Does public international law or private international law impact business more?

The city has the power to take private property for public use.The Fifth Amendment to...

The city has the power to take private property for public use. The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states, ". . . nor might private property be taken for open use, without just pay." The Supreme Court has held this applies to state and neighborhood, and in addition the elected, government. Richmond must pay the Neelans a reasonable cost for their genuine property. This, by and large, means the sensible market esteem. On the off chance that the Neelans...

Write a paper describing in detail your business interests or career plans and how constitutional law...

Write a paper describing in detail your business interests or career plans and how constitutional law applies to them. Build on what you discussed in your introduction on the first discussion board. Describe in detail what kind of business you want to own/operate or what occupational field you want to work in. Then describe at least three ways in which constitutional law applies to your business/field. For example, suppose your business needs property for its operations. You could explain how...

Can you briefly discuss the purpose of Government Contracts in doing business with the Public/Private companies?

Question