Question

In: Economics

Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically...

Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically consumed is supplied by domestic producers and the rest of it is imported. Then suppose that the government pays a subsidy of S dollars on each unit of Z that is produced domestically, so that the quantity of Z imported is somewhat reduced (but not reduced to zero). Draw a demand and supply diagram that shows the effect of the subsidy. Compare this subsidy to a tariff. Explain why the subsidy is generally regarded as the more desirable policy instrument. (10 Marks, maximum word limit: 250 words)

Solutions

Expert Solution

a) The graph of subsidy:

  

b) When the government povides subsidy to domestic producers, taxpayers' money is used for subsidy. Before subsidy, Q3 was poduced by domestic producers, and (Q2 - Q3) was imported. After subsidy, Q4 is the domestic production; and imports reduce to (Q2 - Q4).

There is no loss of consumer surplus, as price paid by cosumers does not change. Whereas in the case of tariff, price increases and there is a loss of consumer surplus. Government spends subsidy amount which equals Q4 -times- subsidy amount (shaded rectangle). while in the case of a tariff, there is government revenue from tariff. Producers gain from both subsidy and tariff. There is deadweight loss in the case of subsidy, associated with supply curve. This is because the area marked 'X' is wasted. Although government spends that money as subsidy, it does not go to anybody. The rest of the subsidy amount goes to producers. However, deadweight loss is less in case of subsidy than in case of a tarriff. Deadweight loss associated with demand curve does not exist in case of subsidy as it does in case of a tariff. This is because consumerrs are not affected by subsidy as price they pay does not change. It is Pw before and after subsidy. Because of these reasons, subsidy is the desirable option.


Related Solutions

Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically...
Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically consumed is supplied by domestic producers and the rest of it is imported. Then suppose that the government pays a subsidy of S dollars on each unit of Z that is produced domestically, so that the quantity of Z imported is somewhat reduced (but not reduced to zero). Draw a demand and supply diagram that shows the effect of the subsidy. Compare this subsidy...
Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically...
Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically consumed is supplied by domestic producers and the rest of it is imported. Then suppose that the government pays a subsidy of S dollars on each unit of Z that is produced domestically, so that the quantity of Z imported is somewhat reduced (but not reduced to zero). Draw a demand and supply diagram that shows the effect of the subsidy. Compare this subsidy...
Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically...
Consider a small country that imports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z domestically consumed is supplied by domestic producers and the rest of it is imported. Then suppose that the government pays a subsidy of S dollars on each unit of Z that is produced domestically, so that the quantity of Z imported is somewhat reduced (but not reduced to zero). Draw a demand and supply diagram that shows the effect of the subsidy. Compare this subsidy...
Consider a large country that imports good R. Some of the total quantity of R domestically...
Consider a large country that imports good R. Some of the total quantity of R domestically consumed is supplied by domestic producers and the rest of it is imported. Then suppose that the government imposed a tariff on each unit of R that is imported, so that the quantity of R imported is somewhat reduced. Draw a demand and supply diagram that shows the effect of the tariff. On your diagram, 4 of 4 shade-in the area that represents the...
Consider a small country that exports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Zthat is...
Consider a small country that exports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Zthat is domestically produced is consumed by domestic consumers and the rest of it is exported. Then suppose that the government places a subsidy s on each unit of Z exported. While, obviously, this subsidy increases the quantity of Zexported, some of the production of Z continues to be purchased by domestic consumers. Show the effects of this export subsidy using a carefully labeled demand and...
Consider a large country that exports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z that...
Consider a large country that exports good Z. Some of the total quantity of Z that is domestically produced is consumed by domestic consumers and the rest of it is exported. Then suppose that the government places a subsidy s on each unit of Z exported. While, obviously, this subsidy increases the quantity of Z exported, some of the production of Z continues to be purchased by domestic consumers. Show the effects of this export subsidy using a carefully labelled...
Consider a small country (perfect competition) applying a tariff, t, to imports of a good a....
Consider a small country (perfect competition) applying a tariff, t, to imports of a good a. Suppose that the country currently has a tariff on imports, but decides to reduce it from t to t’. Draw graphs for the Home and import markets and illustrate this change. b. What happens to the quantity of goods produced at Home and their price? What happens to the quantity of imports? c. Are there gains or losses to domestic consumer surplus due to...
Show and explain the case where the small nation Country 1 imports Good A. Initially it...
Show and explain the case where the small nation Country 1 imports Good A. Initially it has an import tariff on Good A, then it eliminates the tariff. Depict this graphically. [Be sure to label the axes and curves of your graph. Label the appropriate surplus areas with letters.] (a) When the country changes from having a tariff to no tariff, what happens to (i) producer surplus, (ii) consumer surplus, (iii) deadweight loss, and (iv) government tariff revenue? (Describe the...
Question (2) Consider a country that imports a good from abroad. For each of following statements,...
Question (2) Consider a country that imports a good from abroad. For each of following statements, say whether it is true or false. Explain your answer. “The greater the elasticity of demand, the greater the gains from trade.” “If demand is perfectly inelastic, there are no gains from trade.” “If demand is perfectly inelastic, consumers do not benefit from trade.”
Consider a country that is small in the market of a particular good, facing an international...
Consider a country that is small in the market of a particular good, facing an international price of 30. In this country, the demand is given by D = 400 - 5P and the supply is given by S = -200 + 10P. 1) What is the total welfare when there is free trade? 2) What is the welfare change caused by a 5 dollar import tariff? 3) Should this country impose the 5 dollar tariff? (Yes/No) 4) Now assume...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT