Question

In: Physics

Could anyone explain me in simple words what is being said in this topic from Feynman...

Could anyone explain me in simple words what is being said in this topic from Feynman Lectures Vol.1 Chapter 4 topic 4-2 Gravitational Potential Energy (great book and author btw)...please refer to the book (pdf on net or a copy) to get what i'm asking.
i don't understand after it starts talking about perpetual motion and lifting and lowering of weights.please explain in simple words.
so i got confused at this point-
"Consider weight-lifting machines—machines which have the property that
they lift one weight by lowering another. Let us also make a hypothesis: that
there is no such thing as perpetual motion with these weight-lifting machines. (In
fact, that there is no perpetual motion at all is a general statement of the law of
conservation of energy.) We must be careful to define perpetual motion. First,
let us do it for weight-lifting machines. If, when we have lifted and lowered a lot
of weights and restored the machine to the original condition, we find that the
net result is to have lifted a weight, then we have a perpetual motion machine
because we can use that lifted weight to run something else."



umm like how exactly weight lifting machine lift one weight by lowering another.and what does that line mean that no perpetual motion at all is a general statement of the law of conservation of energy.im also confused by the last four lines and the whole topic that follows...can't seem to visualize what is being said...so if anyone can say the whole thing in this topic in simpler words or help me visualize it would be of great help.

im also a bit more confused by the next para-

"
A very simple weight-lifting machine is shown in Fig. 4-1. This machine lifts
weights three units “strong.” We place three units on one balance pan, and one
unit on the other. However, in order to get it actually to work, we must lift a
little weight off the left pan. On the other hand, we could lift a one-unit weight
by lowering the three-unit weight, if we cheat a little by lifting a little weight
off the other pan. Of course, we realize that with any actual lifting machine, we
must add a little extra to get it to run. This we disregard, temporarily. Ideal
machines, although they do not exist, do not require anything extra. A machine
that we actually use can be, in a sense, almost reversible: that is, if it will lift
the weight of three by lowering a weight of one, then it will also lift nearly the
weight of one the same amount by lowering the weight of three. "

why would you need to lift a little weight off the left pan?wouldn't the machine lift the right side(with one unit) up as soon as you placed 3 units on the left side?also what does the last four lines here mean again?how will you lift a weight of 3 by lowering a weight of one?how can one weight on one side make 3 weights on the other side go up?

Solutions

Expert Solution

First para explanation:

Perpetual motion machines are systems where the system is self contained and the motion of first thing generates motion for second thing and then this second thing generates motion for the first thing (The "thing" could be mechanisms of some sort ). You can add more mechanisms in between (In between the first and the last mechanism). In this way we get a machine which is self contained and just requires some initial energy input and the machine will run indefenitely, these are known as perpetual motion machines. Since nothing in the world is ideal, there will be always some loss of energy due to friction..etc, hence a perpetual motion machine is not possible as per the law of conservation of energy as the mechanism will continously loose energy and eventually it will stop. The example Sir Feynman is telling about the weight lifting machine where, there is lever action, (its like see-saw) so, when one weight lowers down, the other weight comes up.

Second para explanation:

As said above the weights are being lifted due to lever action, so one unit of weight is enough to lift the other three units of weight (or vice versa) since both the moments produced are almost equal we can say that in both ways the weights can be lifted (remember lever action).


Related Solutions

can anyone explain to me according to the own simple word not copy and paste about...
can anyone explain to me according to the own simple word not copy and paste about the theory of the blanned behavior and social Learning and relate them in the dental Hyegene thank You
Hi Could anyone please explain to me the principle behind the RNA isolation experiment.
Hi Could anyone please explain to me the principle behind the RNA isolation experiment.
Can anyone please tell me what function in excel I could use in this instance: I...
Can anyone please tell me what function in excel I could use in this instance: I have two spreadsheets with sales of products for a company. I am needing to create a new spreadsheet with gross sales by month and by region. It haven't included all the worksheets, because I truly just need pointed in the right direction.
This is Python coding question, and topic is loop Can anyone help me figuring these out?...
This is Python coding question, and topic is loop Can anyone help me figuring these out? (Please do not use build in function) Thanks. 1. Write a program that prints your name 100 times to the screen. 2. Write a program that takes a string s and an integer n as parameters and prints the string s a total of in n times(once per line) 3. Write a for loop that prints all the integers from 3141 to 5926, skipping...
I have several question regarding axion. Could anyone give me some brief introduction to what is...
I have several question regarding axion. Could anyone give me some brief introduction to what is a axion string, axion field and how is this related to fermion zero mode and chiral zero mode?
Wi-Fi RF Linearization can you explain this topic in a simple way to make me understand...
Wi-Fi RF Linearization can you explain this topic in a simple way to make me understand it ?
If anyone could simplify this for me. I'm having trouble understanding the material and I just...
If anyone could simplify this for me. I'm having trouble understanding the material and I just need a keep it simple stupid approach Discuss the various non influential as well as influential investments that company may have on their financial statements. Also compare and contrast how they are treated/recorded on the companies financial statements.
Can anyone explain what is the difference between EARs and APRs? please give me an example....
Can anyone explain what is the difference between EARs and APRs? please give me an example. I am little confused about the quoted rate. Can anyone explain it? What is a pure discount loan please give me an example? What does it mean to amortize a loan?
could you write an essay for me with 500 words. "what is a professional nursing" provide...
could you write an essay for me with 500 words. "what is a professional nursing" provide the references.
Hi Could anyone please provide me the principle needed to use single nucleotide polymorphisms to predict...
Hi Could anyone please provide me the principle needed to use single nucleotide polymorphisms to predict bitter tasting ability.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT