What are the two most prominent objections to Simple Subjectivism?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Simple subjectivism interprets moral judgments as statements that can be true or false, so a sincere speaker is always right when it comes to moral judgments. when a person says that something is good or bad, the individual means that she approves or disapproves of it. there is no other meaning attached to this.

There are two objections to this claim.

1. it cannot account for disagreement

This objection states that this makes disagreement about ethics absurd. If you think being homosexual is wrong, and I think it is not, I cannot say that you are wrong. You are only saying that you disapprove, and I cannot say that it is false that you disapprove, because it is your moral judgment in which will always be true.

2. there is no right or wrong

This simply means that when making a moral judgment, no one is ever right or wrong. Likewise, no one is ever misguided about what one approves and disapproves of. the statements reflect the preferences of an individual. there can be no right or wrong preference.

Hayet Jeridi answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

What are the most prominent factors that determine a firm’s weighted average cost of capital?

What is the most prominent theory to explain the differential returns between cash and stock offers...

What is the most prominent theory to explain the differential returns between cash and stock offers in an acquisition?

On what basis can attorneys raise objections in depositions?

1. What are the most prominent socioeconomic barriers associated with achieving better health for minority individuals?...

1. What are the most prominent socioeconomic barriers associated with achieving better health for minority individuals? 2. What are the expectations of society to manage the health of individuals? 3. How do social influences affect the health of individuals?

What are cultural relatism? What are the some of the main motivations for it? What are the objections to this view?

What are cultural relatism? What are the some of the main motivations for it? What are the objections to this view? Do you agree with it? justify you answer with good examples.

Workers are compensated by firms with benefits in addition to wages and salaries. the most prominent...

Workers are compensated by firms with benefits in addition to wages and salaries. the most prominent benefit offered by many firms is health insurance. Suppose that in 2000 workers at one steel plant were paid $20 per hour and in addition received health benefits at the rate of $4 per hour. Also suppose that by 2010 workers at that plant were paid $21 per hour but received $9 in health insurance benefits. a. By what percentage did total compensation(wages plus...

Workers are compensated by firms with “benefits” in addition to wages and salaries. The most prominent...

Workers are compensated by firms with “benefits” in addition to wages and salaries. The most prominent benefit offered by many firms is health insurance. Suppose that in 2000, workers at one steel plant were paid $35 per hour and in addition received health benefits at the rate of $7 per hour. Also suppose that by 2010 workers at that plant were paid $36.75 per hour but received $31.5 in health insurance benefits. a. By what percentage did total compensation (wages...

What are the principal objections to the use of the average rate of return method in...

What are the principal objections to the use of the average rate of return method in evaluating capital investment proposals? Discuss the principal limitations of the cash payback method for evaluating capital investment proposals. Why would the average rate of return differ from the internal rate of return on the same project? ***Satisfactory posts are 15 points***

These are the three most prominent ways that therapeutic agents are found: (1) a completely new...

These are the three most prominent ways that therapeutic agents are found: (1) a completely new agent (the actual chemical structure) that binds to a known receptor, but elicits a different patient outcome due to more selective binding, reduced adverse effects, etc. (2) a new use for a known drug or agent – sometimes this is already used “off-label” or has colloquial usage for this indication, but the specific mechanism has not been identified or clinical trials not run (3)...

Which plant group or subgroup is the most prominent in each ecozone and how does this...

Which plant group or subgroup is the most prominent in each ecozone and how does this relate to the features of each ecozone?

Subjects