Question

In: Economics

a. James works for the county fire department and hasn't had a raise in three years....

a. James works for the county fire department and hasn't had a raise in three years. When he shows up at the mayor's house to put out a fire, he sees the mayor standing outside. James tells the mayor that he will put out the fire only if the mayor agrees to give him a raise. The mayor agrees. Is the mayor bound to give James a raise after he put out the fire? Explain.

b. Roberto has an art collection valued at $1,000,000. He has promised to donate his collection to a local arts foundation if that foundation satisfactorily obtains donations of equal value from other sources. The foundation manages to obtain matching donations. However, when Roberto died, his will stated that he had left his collection to his nephew, Michael. If the foundation sues, discuss whether the foundation would be awarded the art collection?

Please solve both the parts

Solutions

Expert Solution

A. No the mayor is not bound to give James a raise.

This is because any contract, be it verbal or written, is null and void if made under duress. The situation here is one of duress only. The mayor's house was under fire and he needed the fire to be extinguished as soon as possible. James had immense leverage in that situation since the mayor was under duress. Effectively the mayor was forced in agreeing to give a raise. At that moment, any promise made by the mayor is null and void. Hence, mayor is not bound to give James a raise later on.

B. This case is same as something called Proprietary estoppel.

This happens when a promise was made before death, but it was not granted in the will and now there is a contradiction. Roberto promised to the arts foundation to donate if they were able to raise a million. They did so, but Roberto died and the collection is going to his nephew.

In all such cases, there are 3 requirements that must be fulfilled if the claimant can sue. These are-

  • Assurance:

A promise must've been made to the claimant.
Does the arts foundation have that? Yes, as Roberto made a promise of donation if a million dollars were raised.

  • Reliance:

The claimant must be able to show that they relied on the promise.
Can the arts foundation show that? Yes, since they raised money in lieu of the promise.

  • Detriment:

The claimant must be able to show that they have suffered detriment due to the promise.
Has the arts foundation suffered detriment? Yes. They put efforts in raising the money due to the promise and now they are not getting the promised collection.

So we can see that the arts foundation fulfills all three requirements for there to be a case. So, the collection will be awarded to the foundation.

-----

Please upvote if you like my answer. Thank you.


Related Solutions

Employees of a county public works department used county-owned vehicles to travel to job sites where...
Employees of a county public works department used county-owned vehicles to travel to job sites where they inspected the work of subcontractors. The vehicles contained the tools and equipment the employees used on the job and served as their offices at the job sites. The employees were not allowed to drive the vehicles to their homes at the end of the day. Instead, they were required to bring them back to secure county-owned parking areas, where they also retrieved their...
The county fire department is considering two options (A and B) for upgrading its aging physical...
The county fire department is considering two options (A and B) for upgrading its aging physical facility. Assume an interest rate of 6% per year and 50-year time period. Option A: Involves remodeling the existing fire station by spending $2,252,000 now. In addition, the cost for personnel and equipment will be $126,000 per year. Option B: Calls for buying 5 acres of land for building a new fire station. The cost of the land in that area is estimated to...
A fire department plans to buy a truck in 3 years to, this trick would cost...
A fire department plans to buy a truck in 3 years to, this trick would cost $ 625,000, but the cost is increasing at the rate of 4% annually. Find the semiannual payment needed to accumulate funds to buy the truck if money earns 16% compounded semiannually.
PLEASE ANSWER ASAP !!!!!!!! VERY URGENT !!!!!!! THANK U !!!!!!!!!! Question: Imagine the fire department had...
PLEASE ANSWER ASAP !!!!!!!! VERY URGENT !!!!!!! THANK U !!!!!!!!!! Question: Imagine the fire department had to evacuate the 25th floor of an office building. For firefighters to safely reach people at this height, how long would the truck’s ladder have to be and how much would it weigh? Based on this, do you think Pierce should manufacturer this apparatus? Explain.
James King bought a house three years ago that cost $750,000. James put up 20% deposit...
James King bought a house three years ago that cost $750,000. James put up 20% deposit and borrowed the rest from FC Bank at a rate of 7.2% per annum, compounded monthly, for 10 years. Three months ago, FC Bank notified James that after the last monthly payment for the third year, the interest rate on his loan will increase to 9.6% per annum, compounded monthly, in line with market rates. Also, from the fourth year of his loan James...
James King bought a house three years ago that cost $750,000. James put up 20% deposit...
James King bought a house three years ago that cost $750,000. James put up 20% deposit and borrowed the rest from FC Bank at a rate of 7.2% per annum, compounded monthly, for 10 years. Three months ago, FC Bank notified James that after the last monthly payment for the third year, the interest rate on his loan will increase to 9.6% per annum, compounded monthly, in line with market rates. Also, from the fourth year of his loan James...
TTC is planning to raise $3.25 million for three years at an interest rate of 7.35...
TTC is planning to raise $3.25 million for three years at an interest rate of 7.35 percent to finance their expansion. The Alban County Board of Commissioners has just offered the firm the $3.25 million they need at 5.25 percent if the firm builds in Alban County, pays the interest annually, and repays the principal at the end of three years. What is the net present value of the loan to TTC if the firm's tax rate is 21 percent...
A divisional manger, John James, expects to retire in three years. John is paid a fixed...
A divisional manger, John James, expects to retire in three years. John is paid a fixed salary plus 10 percent of his division’s profits. Make the unrealistic assumption that John cares only about cash compensation. He can spend $200,000 on process improvements this year and that will yield $125,000 of cost savings for each of the following four years. Use Excel and show all work—use formulas where useful Required:             Illustrate the case flows for seven years. Should John James accept...
Three years ago, you bought a 12% bond that had 7 years to maturity and a...
Three years ago, you bought a 12% bond that had 7 years to maturity and a yield to maturity of 12%. Today (after the sixth interest payment), you sold the bond when it is yielding 13%. What is your annual rate of return for the three year period? All coupon payments are semi-annual, and the par value is $1,000.
Birch Corp., a calendar-year corporation, was formed three years ago by its sole shareholder, James, who...
Birch Corp., a calendar-year corporation, was formed three years ago by its sole shareholder, James, who has operated it as an S corporation since its inception. Last year, James made a direct loan to Birch Corp. in the amount of $7,200. Birch Corp. has paid the interest on the loan but has not yet paid any principal. (Assume the loan qualifies as debt for tax purposes.) For the year, Birch experienced a $25,500 business loss. What amount of the loss...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT