Question

In: Accounting

This is going to require a little reading, so take your time. Storybook Homes, Inc. developed...

This is going to require a little reading, so take your time.

Storybook Homes, Inc. developed the following formula for bonuses: [T]he bonus shall be computed in the following manner

a. 0 to $10,000 Net Profit No Bonus

b. $10,000 to $20,000 a maximum bonus of 5% shall be paid to both [employees]

c. $20,000 and over a maximum bonus of 22% shall be paid to each

The firm earned $25,000 in profits, and the employees and firm differed over how to compute the bonus!

The employees believed the bonus should be computed this way: Net Profit $25,000 Bonus 22% x $25,000 = $5,500

2. The firm believed that each bonus percentage was to be on the incremental portion of Net Profits, like this:

Profit portion Resulting bonus Net profits –1 st interval Net profits – 2 nd interval Net profits – 3 rd interval $10,000 $20,000-$10,000 = $10,000 $25,000 -$20,000 =$ 5,000 $ 0 5% x $10,000= $ 500 22% x $5,000=$1,100 Total bonus $1,600

Storybook Homes, Inc. v. Carlson is a famous case because it seems that the bonus description is ambiguous. Either interpretation could be correct and in contract law, ambiguity is generally interpreted against the contract writer. In this case, the contract writer would be the company. The jury ruled for the employees. The judge entered a “Judgment notwithstanding the verdict” in favor of the company. So, the company was able to pay the bonuses according to their interpretation. This was odd because the judge went against the jury and ambiguity should have gone against the company.

Required:

a. Suppose you were an employee and believed that you would be paid based on the employee interpretation (22% x Net Profits), and profits were $19,900 in the week before year end. Would it pay to purchase enough merchandise yourself to bump the profits to $20,000?

b. It seems to me that we have multiple challenges to paying an employee according to their work. Todd Henderson illustrated a lot of challenges. The Storybook Homes, Inc illustrated ambiguity in the bonus scheme. Does ambiguity create more incentive to work diligently or less incentive to work diligently?

c. Comment on the judge ruling against the employees. Part of the judge's argument was that it wouldn't make business sense to view the bonus provision according to the employee interpretation. Was the judge reasonable?

Solutions

Expert Solution

a) If the profit were $ 19,900 the bonus would be ($19,900-$10,000) x 5% : $ 495
No
The purchase to make the profit to $ 20,000 will not have big impact on the bonus receipt, in order to make the profit to $ 20,000, an additional $ 900 profit is needed, assuming the net profit margin on this product is 44%, it is necessary to purchase the goods for the value of atleast $ 2045. This amount of purchase will result in increase in bonus receipt of $ 5 at the cost of $ 2,045.00. Therefore, it is not advisable to make purchase decision
b) This system of bonus scheme will encourage the employees to perform effieciently and productively. Because any increase in profit beyond $20,000 will result in bonus increase by 22% which is reasonable amount for employees considering the profit mark-up in this business setup. This scheme is well suited for the organization which percieves growth through productivity.
c) The decision provided by judge is reasonable
The bonuss scheme clearly states the range and bonuss percentage for each limit, Also this scheme is business sense and employee supportive. This scheme will make sure that both businesses and the employees are benefitted from productivity enhancement and employee hard-work.

Related Solutions

This is Physics 2, College Level: Someone answered wrong so take your time, do not rush...
This is Physics 2, College Level: Someone answered wrong so take your time, do not rush to answer these questions. Explain how you got the answers. A 1.00 F capacitor is charged to 6.00 V. The capacitor and an open switch is connected to a coil of wire that consists of 500 windings, which has a resistance of 1.20 Ω. This coil has a diameter of 5.00 cm and a length of 16.0 cm. A slightly smaller coil is placed...
Let’s take the same example but add a little more complexity. So far we have assumed...
Let’s take the same example but add a little more complexity. So far we have assumed there was no resale value for the work already completed. Assume that the company could sell the half developed project to another property firm for $60m. The $60m now becomes an opportunity cost, as it is money that could be received. As we have already discussed opportunity costs are relevant costs and so MUST be considered when making a decision.
Does your risk of an infection increase in nursing homes? If so what are the most...
Does your risk of an infection increase in nursing homes? If so what are the most common types of infections
Managers encourage your team to take time off. “I’m going nowhere fast.” This was the concern one of my clients recently.
  Managers encourage your team to take time off. “I’m going nowhere fast.” This was the concern one of my clients recently. Her complaint wasn’t about working in quarantine per se, but about her frantic pace and static productivity. With the initial adrenaline rush of the crisis passed, vast numbers of my clients are reporting that they and their teams feel exhausted to the point of being useless, work demands are on the rise, and the time saved commuting has...
Answer the following questions based on your reading of "Take Your Licks" -- this week's required...
Answer the following questions based on your reading of "Take Your Licks" -- this week's required reading: 1. What is the point of this essay? 2. Who was Sisyphus? 3. Do you have an allusion, like Sisyphus, that you can add to your reflective essay? 4. What makes her ending powerful
Please! Take your time! No rush really! :) ! Windswept Woodworks, Inc. Input Data (millions of...
Please! Take your time! No rush really! :) ! Windswept Woodworks, Inc. Input Data (millions of dollars) Year 2 Year 1 Accounts payable 520 454 Accounts receivable 1,364 900 Accumulated depreciation 6,830 6,702 Cash & equivalents 308 198 Common stock 1,268 1,190 Cost of goods sold 1,500 n.a. Depreciation expense ? n.a. Common stock dividends paid ? n.a. Interest expense 140 n.a. Inventory 1,098 1,096 Addition to retained earnings 602 n.a. Long-term debt 896 806 Notes payable 230 380 Gross...
All cells require energy to live. In your assigned reading for this week, you learned how...
All cells require energy to live. In your assigned reading for this week, you learned how cells generate and then utilize that energy through the metabolic process. As our understanding of these mechanisms has improved, we have been able to apply that knowledge for our own benefit. For example, the aerobic and anaerobic respiration processes of various organisms have been harnessed by both the food and drinks companies and the waste/biofuels industries. Also, consider the impact of understanding the cause...
consider a time in your life when you had to look at something a little closer...
consider a time in your life when you had to look at something a little closer to make sense of it. This moment might focus on a document like the grocery list example from the previous screen, a longer piece of writing, a piece of art, a billboard, and so on.
consider a time in your life when you had to look at something a little closer...
consider a time in your life when you had to look at something a little closer to make sense of it. This moment might focus on a document like the grocery list example from the previous screen, a longer piece of writing, a piece of art, a billboard, and so on.
Rather than going directly to college, some students take time off to travel abroad, learn new...
Rather than going directly to college, some students take time off to travel abroad, learn new skills, or volunteer. This period is known as a “gap year.” Real Gap Experience provides hundreds of gap year traveling opportunities in over 45 countries around the world. The company offers everything from volunteering to building houses in Guatemala to teaching in China (for pay) to taking a year-long, around-the-world trip. What does this have to do with accounting, and why is it important?...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT